Amazing pizza! The crust was fresh and crispy, the ingredients were high quality, and the flavor was delicious. The service was friendly and fast. I highly recommend this place and will definitely come back read more

Prima Pizza - Amazing - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Awful and no acknowledgment of how awful This was - ordered a pizza with at least three meat, toppings, and other toppings, none of which were on the pizza and paid over $40 and this is what I got, and instead of recognizing that I received an uncooked subpar pizza, they just told me a good deal with Uber eats..... read more

Prima Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Used to really like this place but it has gone downhill. It's so incredibly dirty inside of the restaurant I just can't get myself to order anymore from there even though it's right in front of my neighborhood. Check out the glass on the door as you're walking in and out, then go look in their bathroom. Now imagine how their food is probably cooked in the kitchen. I'm done with this place. read more

Prima Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

The staff was BUSY! Today is the day after Thanksgiving. We ordered and ate in. Almost no one else ate in....so many takeouts! The pizza was really good - it was made fresh, fast and hot! We ordered a Caesar and a house salad. We would not order that again. It was very basic and no homemade dressing. Appears the pizza is what to get. We will probably try the calzones next time. read more

See all

Had a big craving for a delicious pizza. Looked on Yelp to find a place near my brother's house for carry out that had great reviews. I ordered a large for three people. I picked it up and couldn't wait to get home to try it. Worst pizza I have ever had. The bottom was burnt, the thin crust was tough, and it had no flavor for a meat lover's pizza. I normally don't complain, but this was not good and very expensive. I work hard for my money and expected something good, especially from the reviews. read more

Prima Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

They cook partially on a screen and use sliced sausage, neither of which I'm a fan. Their cheese is whole milk, and definitely tastes like Grande, so that's a plus. It's a nice oily, orange pie. Nothing worse than cheap part skim Mozzarella on a pizza. This is my second time in since the soft opening a little over a week ago, and it's the best pizza out this way right now. They're a little disorganized, but they will get their sea legs quickly because it's been packed since they opened. read more

See all

This was our 1st time trying this place but probably our last. We ordered a plain cheese and a meat lovers plus garlic knots, mozz sticks and meatballs. I only eat cheese pizza and mine was good, no complaints. The meat lovers is totally different, a different cheese and floppy. I don't understand why a different cheese is used or why it's so different than the plain as you can see in the photos. The mozz sticks had no pull, it's like biting into a string cheese, wasn't melted at all. My son didn't like the meatballs but hubby said they were fine. If the base of the meat lovers was like the cheese, this would've been a different review. read more

Prima Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

New Ownership/management at our go to neighborhood pizza spot after almost 30 years. Reopened and with actual business hours! I order a few times a month for my staff or when I host an in office lunch meeting. Super NY style pizza. They use quality ingredients, fresh crispy crust, just the right amount of oil in the cheese and meats. No processed ingredients here. So happy to have new owners/management. read more

Prima Pizza - Large half and half pizza ordered for pickup take-a-way. - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

The worst pizza ever! It was soggy and literally tasted like cardboard with salt. Aside from the pizza was orange! Orange! No joke! Horrible! read more

I took a chance and I am very happy. VERY GOOD PIZZA YOU'RE NOT GOING TO BE DISAPPOINTED Try it You will thank me later They have sliced sausage delicious read more

Very good pizza with tasty crust and toppings, NY water makes for good dough, we will be coming back again. Ordered over phone and pizza was ready right on time when we went to pick up. read more

The pizza tastes exactly like authentic NYC pizza! Great service, staff is very warm and welcoming to every single guest I saw come through. I'll be looking forward to this every time I visit the area. read more

They burned their pizzas. It was tasteless and crunchy. You couldn't even eat the crust.

Prima NY Pizza is straight fire Slices are always fresh, cheesy, and legit NY-style. Crust hits every time, toppings are stacked, and the flavor is on point. Staff is cool, service is quick, and it's the perfect go-to when you're craving pizza. No misses here--def coming back read more

Excellent pizza!! Nice crust. Perfect sauce. LOVE the sausage. We had the 20 inch pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. Definitely better than Anthony's. They just opened and are still working on all the details but honestly a really great pizza option in this area. I will order again. read more

See all

Excellent pizza and service. Loved the specials and the restaurant overall! Definitely will return and highly recommend giving it a try read more

The pizza was very good. Classic NY style, foldable HUGE slices (I got a large pizza).

Amazing pizza, my kid said it's one of the best she has ever tried. the meatballs and fries were super fresh. Cute little place. The owner/employee is very kind and friendly. highly recommend! read more

This place is NOT near Sims park like their website say!!! Total false advertising! I was looking for a pizza place close to the park and their website says they are. They are NOT! read more

The food and the people here are amazing. Their largest pizza is absolutely huge for the price and the family is excited that we found a new pizza place (: read more

I'm going to start by saying I understand it was Halloween and more people are ordering out but if you can't handle the volume you shouldn't be open tonight. My husband went in and ordered a buffalo chicken pie at 4:45. He was told 45 mins wait. He finally received the pie at 6:40! He brought it home and the box was dripping oil. I have never seen so much oil on a pizza . It looks like a 1/2 cup oil was poured on it. Bottom of the pie is saturated with oil. I had to use paper towels to soak up the oil on the cheese. There was NO Buffalo sauce on the pie or chicken and chicken was sparse. Pizza was inedible. I'm sorry to say it was the most disgusting pizza I have ever experienced. We have ordered a couple pies in the past month with them and they were ok. This was shocking . It was a very expensive pie that took forever to get and was inedible. I tried to call them to ask about what happened but they were not answering the phone and their voicemail is not set up. read more

Prima Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

Absolutely the best pizza in the area. The water comes from NYC and you can definitely taste the difference. The owner delivered the pizza and was so friendly. I would give this pizzeria 6-stars if I could! read more

Really good!! I had the pizza at a neighbors party. It was so good I had to ask where did you get this? She is from NY and she laughed saying I knew another NY'er would love it lol! I went back to get a couple of heros they were good too!!! I will try everything on the menu and let you know. But so far I would say checkout this pizza parlor!!! The guy working was very nice and happy. The whole place was tiled nicely. Great place to bring the kids for pizza. Great prices!! Check it out!! read more

Best pizza I have had in Florida. Truly NY style. Can't wait to return! Crust was awesome.

Excellent pizza, seriously tastes like up north, fabulous pizza sauce ~ my entire family really enjoyed it. I recommend this place to anyone who wants a taste of what NY pizza should be. read more

Stopped in for a Pizza and salad. Keeping in mind this is a "Pizzeria". Nothing fancy. You order at the register, pay for your meal and sit down. The pizza was cooked perfectly, excellent blend of cheese, sauce and toppings. Restaurant was super clean and very different from the previous establishment that was there. I think next time we will order to go. I would like to try more items offered on their menu. read more

The pizza here is as close to ny pizza as it gets. If you like that type of pizza you won't be disappointed. Definitely recommend you give it a try read more

the pizza and hospitality at this restaurant is outstanding. as close to traditional ny pizza that we have had in 42 years of being in florida highy recommend you try it read more

I foolishly ordered on DoorDash for an order I was picking up, the store tags on 20-25% to prices, claiming to cover for Doordash cost to the store, yet I know stores that don't do this. Pizza was OK, but not worth it to me. read more

best pizza in the west coast flotida area. made with real ny water you can see the difference in the dough! they just got real authentic gelato. they gave my favorite an Italian pistachio. try one read more