Brewster Gulf

Very Clean! We…read morestopped by for an emergency bathroom break during our road trip and this has to be one of the cleanest restrooms I've ever seen in a gas station. For paying customers only but it's so clean that it's review worthy!

My brother came into this gas station after coming back from a leisurely drive into Connecticut…read moretoday with my mother and me(Grammarly said this was the right verbiage here, but i wasn't taught this as being right years ago) in the car, and although he was the one pumping and paying at the pay-at-the-pump transaction, from what I saw of the place from my #backseatview, i wasnt impressed with what i saw. Although it looked clean on the outside,l and rhere were no issues to the transport surface, the trash bins were quickly filling and you could tell from the number of cars there, that this place isn't used often - probably a big influx at other stations nearby. With the exception of a T-Webber truck, I only saw one other car and that car was only vacuuming their car at the vacuums near the exit. I'm sorry that when I checked into your location on Yelp, I checked in on the Yelp page for a BP in Carmel. When I asked my brother about this location, he referenced Carmel and not Brewster - on the way to you. I checked into your location through Yelp's competition with ease and accuracy, so i dont know what got into me to not be looking too carefully when I checked in with Yelp as well. Heard and saw the map that said we were coming around the corner from the Southeast (Metro-North) railroad station's rail yard- something we passed on the way to you. (I verified this new listing's address from the address I received on my competitor's check-in that said we were within 100ft of the business. when I checked in at the gas pumps inside his car.) Prices at this station remained pretty consistent with what was listed on GasBuddy - it was pretty clear that prices don't change all that much or often. They were only off one or two cents, and it was easy to update for accuracy reasons. His fill-up got the job done, and got us the gas needed to come home the remainder of the way.

Mobil

(1 review)

I think this is the best gas station in Brewster. It's very clean and easily accessible from the…read morebike path entrance. I drive past 2 other gas stations to shop here because the staff are friendly and customer orientated. A little service goes a long way with me. They've always got some classic soft rock playing, it's fun to hear an obscure song I've not heard in decades. Aside from the standard gas station features, this location has: - One diesel pump - 7 regular gas pumps - Very large candy & sweets selection - Tums is thoughtfully placed next to the 'Super King Size Reeses Cups' - Decent drinks & beer selection - Decent dry goods in a pinch (dog food, canned soup, shampoo etc) - A few pre-made sandwiches - Bagged ice - Scratch off vending machine - Clean bathroom

Shell

2.6

(5 reviews)

I moved far from Brewster 8 years ago and honestly tried to find somewhere to have my repairs done…read more I now drive down to Brewster Shell where I can leave knowing my car has been cared for as it should be. I have called many times with what I thought was a problem only to be told that I can take care of the issue myself with the advice they are willing to give me without charging me for an in person repair appointment.

0 stars for this dump and extreme rip off. This guy that owns this place is such an asshole. I used…read moreto only go here for a car inspection and have been going for years but last year (2022) was the absolute last time cause he's always trying to find something wrong with my car and tries not to pass it in inspection. The owner is just an absolute jackass. And not only that, his gas prices are a rip off. I dont know if he ever changed his prices but last time I was there for an inspection, this scumbag was charging $6.50 PER GALLON for diesel when every single other gas station on 22 are about $4.00 per gallon and over $5.00 for the lowest priced gas (these are cash prices) when all the other stations are about $4.50 (for credit card prices). So you could save $2.50 per gallon for diesel if you go to a different station that sells diesel. This dirtbag should be fined for ripping people off for not only having those prices but for being an absolute asshole to everybody that goes to this place.

Mystik

2.5

Thank God I found this gas station when I did. I was running on fumes & had to get someplace…read morepromptly. Thankfully, they were open at 9:30ish in the evening. Fairly straightforward transaction. The store itself is a bit tiny but there are a few convenience items if needed. Just as an FYI, I drove past a few days later and they were closed after 10 p.m.

Dishonest. Last week I was in there to rent a u-haul van. The gentleman behind the counter told me…read moreI had to pay an additional $9 for insurance. Even though I know it is illegal to force the consumer to opt for Insurance, I asked repeatedly if I were obligated to take insurance. He kept telling me I had to take it. Finally I called their corporate number and I got reimbursed for $9. I will never do business with them again because of their illegal business practices.

Brewster Gas

2.8

(5 reviews)

Gas is reasonably price all the girls in the store are wonderful always has a pleasant attitude…read moreevery day and any day. Coffee is always full and they're ready and waiting. The place is very clean and neat with the amount of people that come in and out of their I don't know how those girl keep it so organized and clean. Keep up the good work love your smiles in the morning.

This is the Hess Station on RT 22…read more While I almost always buy gas based on price, sometimes they do something to set themselves apart to make me add them to a list of "places to avoid" This Hess station has done it twice, Once by not allowing a credit card purchase of the Hess Holiday truck last year "Cash Only" and the final straw was this month where we were informed that the "boss does not let customer use the bathroom" That's all good bye, I will pay more or go to the BP just down the street.

Friendly Service

1.0

The pump number pads are in need of repair. The window washer cleaners didn't have the squeegees…read more(but had the stagnant water still in the container!). Sign says "Under New Management" - I think they mean that as a warning ... Should read "Under Bad Management"

The worst service I ever had. Unfriendly operator. Full tank of 93 octane Vpower and the car really…read morelost some power compared to 93 Mobil. What is this? That wasn't quality fuel. But my money was. Stay away.

Chris' Automotive Center

3.3

(67 reviews)

My favorite neighborhood car service is Chris' in Carmel, New York. They are courteous, timely and…read moremost of all professional. I appreciate timely reminders of up coming services. I just had my car inspected. Mark, the service representative had my car in and out within 30 Minutes. The office staff is friendly and you can usually get an appointment within a few days depending on the required service. I have recommended Chris' before and will continue to do so!

We had new tires put on with Chris'. The entire process was simple and smooth! We dropped off the…read morenight before, and they called the next day when the car was ready. Tires were balanced well and the alignment was perfect.

Q-TIPP Treatment

(16 reviews)

Great place for those nasty scratches from parking lots; however, their specialty is detail work…read morefor your car when it starts to look like it needs more than touch up and wax. Great customer service with reasonable rates. Todd and Anthony will go over the work and tell you what is needed. Give them a try to make your car look great again.

An acquaintance suggested this place years ago and at that time they did a terrific job, but the 2…read moretimes I went afterwards for a full detailing my car was left dirty and dusty. When I pointed out that they didn't complete the services I paid for and tipped on before I realized just how dirty they left the car I was told that was how they worked and that they were leaving early for the day, so they could enjoy the weather. The service and quality for the price charged was garbage.

A & R Service Center

3.7

(15 reviews)

My AAA tow truck took my car and I to 2 other places on a saturday afternoon, to remove a nail from…read moremy tire. Those 2 places, also in Brewster, would not take me. They didnt even seem busy which was odd. Anyway, A&R was the last place we tried and they were not only so kind and welcoming, but did a terrific job at a great price. Even the Tow Truck Driver took note and was impressed with their work. Five stars all-around.

I was 6 minutes late to a 10am appointment and after I gave my name and appointment time to the…read moremost disgustingly rude employee Maria, her response was 'YOUR LATE'. And then told she would have no idea when I could be seen -- Maria had no empathy or even asked how I was, I felt like less than a human at that point but more of an inconvenience. I ended up leaving, and honestly this was all for a state inspection. I will be complaining to the owner Saul -- don't be late to your appointment or you'll be talked to like dirt. I honestly can't talk to the work they do, but I can tell you I won't be back here ever again.

Brewster Gulf - servicestations - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Brewster Gulf also viewed

Montgomery Valero

This is a decent gas station and convenience store located on 17K in Coldenham. The gas prices are…read moreconsistently one of the cheapest in the area. They also have the E-85 fuel (for vehicles containing the "flex fuel" option). The store inside is generally clean and stocked well. They have a decent assortment of typical gas station food and coffee. The staff generally seem pretty cold and down in the dumps, although I'm not sure why. You don't get a friendly feeling when you walk into this store. If I'm in the area, I generally use this gas station for the cheap fuel prices but not for the store.

In Newburgh this valero is my preferred gas station that I go to. They do have a lot of pumps here…read morewhich makes it easy to get a spot you don't have to wait in line. I also like the fact that there's two entrances to get in and out of this valero. one entrance is off of the main road 17 K and the other entrance is down a side street off of 17 K. From there then you can turn into the gas station. One of the biggest bonuses of this gas station is that they are one of the only gas stations in the Newburgh area that have E-85 gas This Valero is a pretty big gas station it is a full service convenient store as well. The staff here is great the two same guys are pretty much there every single time that I come here. There is a full service subway restaurant inside of the gas station that has its own subway staff members. I have eaten at that subway a few times on the way back from trips and they do do a good job for a subway. Overall this is the gas station that I go to get my gas. not only do they carry regular gas but they also carry E-85 gas. The station has a lot of pumps and the staff is always friendly. I do recommend going to this Valero if you're in the area. PROS: - they have E-85 gas! - staff is nice

Exxon

Love the staff they are so helpful and nice. And love the regular coffee I get it every morning!!!read more

Great local gas station and deli. Firewood, Propane tanks and great sandwiches. Always a friendly…read moresmile and great service. Also an air compressor station to keep your tires properly inflated.

Xpress Fuel

Not sure if they are open 24 hours or just early in the morning, but Xpress is very convenient…read more They are Always the cheapest gas in New Milford. They are 3.03 per gallon today, everyone else is 3.05 or higher per gallon. Lots of pumps for no wait, including two diesel pumps on the end. They have a convenience store inside which I've never visited. They do get flooded rarely when the river overflows. Don't know if that seeps into the gas lines, but I always wait a few days to go after that. Xpress is definitely the go to for gas and savings.

This gas station has a friendly staff and good service. It contains great collection of soda,…read moresnacks, juice and tobacco products suck has Cigar, Vape juice, cigarettes and wraps. In addition, Candies, gums and Lotteries.

BJ's Gas

I was in the area and needed to fill up prior to our travels back home. BJ's Gas in Newburgh, NY is…read moreconnected to the wholesale club which makes it convenient. There was a short queue till it was our turn at the pump. BJ's membership is required and carries regular, premium, and diesel.

Went here on Monday May 19th 2025 with my dad to fill up after a long trip coming from south…read morecarolina. We immediately pulled in, pumped gas. Again we use this because with BJ's membership one can get a discount on gas, so the price is less and saves money. highly recommend doing that. unfortunately can't remember the price we paid, but so worth it. Went on our merry way after that.

Millwood Market

3.1

(18 reviews)

•$$

Your standard Gas Station Mart. No surprises....nothing great, yet nothing terrible. After…read morefilling up at $4.89/gallon (wow!) grabbed a few snacks after a quick bathroom break. Met expectations.

I go there often to get my Arizona Tea craving at night. It is open 24 hours and the place is well…read moreorganized all the time. In fact, I went there last night and pleasantly surprised how neat and organized the place is all the time. It is great for late night snack, coffee, drinks,etc.

Magyar Svce Ctr

3.7

(3 reviews)

I came here to rent a Budget truck. When I rented the truck, I waived insurance coverage. A lady…read morecalled me about 2 weeks before pick up if I needed insurance and well I did. The price over the phone was cheaper than what was quoted on the Budget website. So I quickly signed up instead of calling my insurance company and getting a new policy. It was still expensive, but less hassle. Customer service: they were welcoming, but not super friendly. We were out of there in no time since I did all the paperwork online and just needed to do some last minute signing. The facility and bathroom was super clean. Truck: The truck was beyond gross. There was soda stains all over the seats. There was mud on the dash. I did a quick cleaning in the parking lot because it was that gross. Then when I arrived to where I was loading, i grabbed a bunch of cleaning materials and did a deep clean of the interior. The loading area was super gross too full of dirt and mud. Had to grab a broom to sweep it out and if I had time to do a full scrub, I would have. The truck tires in the front were really worn. The truck did not have cruise control for those that want that. If you need packing material, you can buy it here. I am not sure of the price, since I had my own. Magyar you need to clean your trucks to match the cleanliness of your facility. If the truck was as clean and neat as the service center, I would say 5 stars.

Rented a Budget Rental Truck from Magyar's. Paperwork was quick since we did most of it online in…read moreadvance when we booked the reservation. Customer Service: Overall pleasant folks. Truck quality: below average. Our truck recently had an oil change. But interior was filthy and disgusting (we spent 45 minutes cleaning the interior before we departed New York). Front tires were very worn. Climate controls not fully functional as the vents that blow toward passengers did not work at all. Would have given Magyar 5 stars if the truck had been fully functional and not filthy. Misc: Offers various packing and moving supplies. Overall cleanliness: above average Bathroom cleanliness: above average

Garrison Gulf

3.4

(8 reviews)

Had a friend go there for mechanic services and they partially fixed the problem for their vehicle…read more Less than a week later the vehicle had the same issue come up. They brought the vehicle to another mechanic and it was proven that the issue that Gios repair shop (Garrison Gulf) was supposed to fix didn't fix at all. They scammed them out of $400. They will not be returning there. Please don't waste your money or time. Go somewhere more reputable!!!!

Finally. A station you can rely on. The owner is great and very knowledgable. The auto tech is on…read morepoint and committed to customer service. Although they sell cigs and other convenience store items they do not advertise or promote the sale of cigs or alcohol products, because they are next door to a school. That alone says it all for me. The tech brought life back into my wagoner. Thank you.

Guy's Sunoco

3.5

(6 reviews)

Clean convenience store with a Dunkin Donuts. The Dunkin Donuts is not a 24 hour location…read more Otherwise it's a good place to Pick up snacks, sundries, lotto, a clean bathroom if needed.

Went to the gas station to pump gas and to buy a bag of ice and few drinks for a Barbecue Party…read more They tried to charge me $70 for a package of water bottle. I pump gas and went to Walmart for the ice and drinks.

Flory's