Absolutely love this place! From the bagels to the coffee to the branding especially it is amazing. Great atmosphere with kind employee. Definitely is a new go to spot for me and my friends! read more

Wicked bagel sandwich! Had a bacon egg and cheese with cream cheese added. The bagel crust had a nice bite to it, and the bacon rounded it out to a great breakfast. They had a line but it moved fast for a newly opened spot. Was able to sit outside and get some work done while I ate. This is going to be a regular spot for me. read more

I'm a huge bagel eater so I'm super picky about them. This place is definitely doing something right. The bagels are toasty on the outside and chewy in the middle. The way a good bagel should be. Staff is super friendly and attentive. They're helpful in recommending What to order. Prices in my opinion are pretty fair. And quite honestly, as long as a good product is produced, I'll pay whatever the price is. Definitely making this place my first weekend stop! I'll stock up on bagels since it's out of my way. read more

Service was excellent. Pretty much everything else was average. Zero unique ambiance, felt like waiting in line at a Starbucks. The bagels (literally all they got) aren't any better than Grateful Bagel literally right across the street. $32 (that's including tip), for a coffee and three bagels is whacko I'm sorry. I also came at opening and these bagels should've tasted fresher. Probably won't come back tbh. Best thing I can say besides service is I forgot to take a picture and they were worthy of finishing lol. But definitely average at best. read more

Great bagels, rough counter experience. The bagel itself was excellent: a crisp outer bite with perfect chew, and a soft, well-made interior. No complaints there at all. I ordered it with scallion cream cheese. Good flavor, but way too much of it, enough that it overwhelmed the bagel. A lighter hand would let the bagel shine. My biggest gripe is the service. Everyone was friendly, but the staff asked "Is that all?" after every single element of my order: "I'd like a plain bagel." "Is that all?" "No, I'd like it toasted..." "Is that all?" "...with scallion cream cheese." "Is that all?" "No, I'd also like an everything bagel." "Is that all?" I hate this at fast food places, and I was surprised to run into it at a place like this. It makes you feel rushed, like you're holding up the line. Let customers finish their order. What's the rush? The bagels alone are worth coming back for, but the front of house could use some customer service training. It's a real turnoff. read more

I finally got to try Bonnie Bagels today! I'm came on their opening weekend and waited in a long line, but sadly they ran out of bagels. They gave me a free bagel card for my next visit, so I didn't leave too disappointed. I got back there today and thankfully got to try them! This is a really cute place! They have a great seating area in the outdoor, covered patio. The indoor area also has a small seating area. They have really cute merch and they also seem their cream cheese spreads and drinks! The service was friendly but definitely seemed a bit scattered. The person who took our order seemed to put our order in correctly, but then on receiving the order it was not correct. My wife asked for her bagel to be toasted and my bagel had the wrong spread on it. Also, the cashier didn't seem to have our name in or our pager number so they didn't call us when our order was done. It was weird. The bagels themselves are good and definitely worth the price! I had a sesame seed bagel with their caper dill spread. Honestly, the caper dill spread was the best part of the bagel experience. That spread was amazing. I'm not sure though that I will wait in a long line for bagels here again. I love the Grateful Bagel just around the block and they may not have a beautiful patio, but I never have to wait for 40 minutes for a bagel there. I will wait until things get a little calmed before coming back. read more

Bonnie Bagels - Menu - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Brand new bagel shop in town and decided to get there early to avoid lines and just before 730 it was already starting to get busy. Found it odd to only have one entry/exit as causes congestion when busy. Clean and sterile environment. Indoor and outdoor patio (located in parking lot) seating. Very cheery and friendly staff, welcoming and ready to take your order. Bonnie's offer a variety of bagel and spread options, with a few sandwich choices. They also have coffee (which I did not get), to-go spread and canned drinks. I got (and can only speak on)a GF everything bagel with vegan spread (almond base which was surprised by). GF bagel is on the thinner side, most definitely drier and chewy... (recommend only eating when warm) and would ask for extra cream cheese to counter dryness. Everything Flavor is there. read more

See all

I had the opportunity to attend their soft opening yesterday and boy was it a treat. At my 9-5 I work with many of the bakeries around the Bay Area so I am in the unique position of constantly taste-testing baked goods, which includes many bagels. Bonnie bagels tops the list easily, no exaggeration. The everything bagel was perfectly fluffy and chewy, the perfect size and perfectly fresh, with flavorful seasoning. The scallion cream cheese was excellent in terms of flavor and amount. I also tried an iced matcha with oat milk that was delicious, and I'm picky about my matcha. The service was great, you can tell the employees were working through some kinks (what else are soft openings for?) but every interaction was met with a smile. These people seem happy to be there and to care about the place they work. And speaking of the place- the indoor space was intimate but very clean and well-lit with natural lighting. The outdoor patio was cozy and bright and a great space to sit and enjoy a bagel with a friend. All in all, I'm very excited to be back when this place opens for real. read more

Bonnie Bagels - Menu - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Salt Bagel, plain to go. Swung by during a soft opening event and was pleasantly surprised, this place has put a lot of thought and effort into their product and layout. Coffee looks great and the bagels are genuinely something not offered by any other places in town, or Sonoma county for that matter. I know there's been a lot of talk in town about a place opening so close to a local staple, but at least for now, Bonnie Bagel has the superior bagel (sorry locals, GB down the street is a shell of what they were pre covid, quality wise). This place has my vote! read more

Bonnie's Bagels in Sebastopol is so good! The egg and cheese bagel with bacon is awesome. The bagel itself is delicious, and everything tastes like it's made with care and high quality ingredients. Bacon and sausage are from a local butcher SoCo Meats. Aesthetics and ambiance are also on point. Definitely one of my favorite breakfast spots in the area. Highly recommend! read more

Bonnie Bagels - Everything bagel, bacon, egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Now that's a bagel! I was extremely skeptical but gave them a try. I've had bagels all over the world but this bagel is in a league of its own. It's literally perfect. read more

Fun bright space. Friendly service. Our order w multiple bagels and various schmears, all toasted, came up surprisingly quickly. Great bagels. The real deal. Chewy center and slightly crispy crust. Great flavor. Didn't love their caper & dill schmear, but I'll be back to try their other options. If you prefer east coast bagels to the more bread-like west coast version, these bagels fit the bill. Yummy. read more

Great bagels, menu, service, flowers and decor. Another great landmark in sebastopol's great food scene

I always thought NYers were full of it, a bagel is a bagel right? I saw the hype about Bonnie's and like the follower that I am, I just had to try. I feel like I just ate a completely different product than I'd ever had before. The one I had was still warm. It was so good it was unreal. Ok NYers, you win this one. And I may never be satisfied with any other bagels again! Also, go easy on the staff, they're making these BY HAND at an exponential rate with a huge demand. I watched a grown ass adult leave in a huff over their 3 bagel limit. They are doing their best and will only get better at meeting demand, be patient! read more

I'm originally from NY and this is the BEST gluten free bagel I've ever had. Tastes just like a regular bagel. A little slow their first week but the space is beautiful and the bagels and cappuccino are perfect. read more

Bonnie Bagels - Cappuccino - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Wow. They know how to make bagels right! I had a sourdough bagel with the scallion smear and it was the perfect amount of sourdough tang, crunch on the outside and chewy on the inside. It's nice to have more than one option to purchase in town. Very excited for this business! read more

Another west coast bagel place claiming to have east coast bagels. First of all the price is for sure West Coast! I bought sesame and an everything bagel to try. Plain, no spreads so that o could taste the bagel. Got excited when I first bit in because the chewy texture was there, but I was quickly disappointed. There was no flavor to this dough. All I could taste was a salty dough and the seeds. Grateful bagel still has my vote. I have attached a menu to a real east coast bagel place. Peep those prices! read more

delicious bagels! The bagels were so fresh they were literally still hot from the oven The texture and crunch of these east coast inspired bagels was amazing- and surely a refreshing change to the doughy California bagels. The seating and atmosphere is also super cute. Well done! read more

These are California bagels. They are good! But think about it...are bagels known as an "east coast" thing or a New York metro thing? Also, if someone from the east coast is making bagels in California, do they have any kind of history making bagels in New York metro orrrrr are they actually transplants who wouldn't try to compete on the actual east coast? Also, are bagels shops known for having factory made "diner" mugs that have been branded by opening day and cost $25 per? That said, this place is genuinely about BAGELS, not a sandwich shop using round bread like the neighboring business. The people working the counter wonderful. The shop is a pleasant place to sit for a while. And Bonnie's is about as good as it gets for California bagels! We'll be back! read more

A bagel in Coolidge Corner cost twenty-five cents in 1981. I grew up on Coolidge Street in Brookline, Massachusetts, a few blocks up from Kupel's on Harvard Street, in a neighborhood where it would not have occurred to anybody to call a bagel a specialty item. Bruegger's came later, and there were others on nearly every corner. Those bagels were cheap, and they were also built on bromated flour and food coloring and a preservative list nobody read, because that is what commercial baking was then. That twenty-five-cent bagel is the one people keep holding up next to Bonnie Bagels, and the two are not the same object. Before Bonnie opened, that end of South Main was a cracked parking lot you drove past on the way to somewhere else. The Mexican place next door is now getting customers it never had. There is parking, there are people of every age going in and out, and the corner has stopped being a thing you drive through. Food you buy instead of making comes down to three things: the product, where you eat it, and the person who hands it across the counter. Anyone with a kitchen and a free Saturday can boil bagels, cure lox and whip cream cheese, and a few people genuinely should. Everybody else is paying for all three. The place is bright and spare, which is the right setting for a piece of chewy bread with something fatty on it and a black coffee to send you out the door. Bold signage, strong color, a branding style that lands as quirky and professional at the same time. The outdoor seating is small and gets sun, sheltered enough to work on the grayest Sebastopol morning. When the line runs down to the parking lot, and it does, the workflow holds. They have a crew of new kids and an owner who is plainly there around the clock. My order gets repeated back to me. It comes out fast, for here or to go, and when something has gone sideways they have owned it at the counter and fixed it while I stood there. The bagel is fermented, boiled and baked, on unbromated flour, and the crust that comes off that process is a different material from the inside of it. American baking mostly abandoned that distinction decades ago in favor of a pale gut-ball of bread, wrapped in plastic and sold the next day. You can buy a bagel at Safeway and at Fircrest and at Starbucks, and there is no shortage of baked goods in this town, between Retrograde and the Red Bird pastries they bring in. Grateful Bagel has been twenty doors up the same block for years and has earned every one of its regulars. A town this size can carry two. I have eaten Wise Sons and Daily Driver and most of what the Bay Area puts out, with Coolidge Corner to measure all of it against. Bonnie wins. None of this is cheap and nobody has claimed it was. Unbromated flour costs more, fermentation costs time, a kettle costs a person, and Sonoma County payroll starts before five in the morning. For what actually reaches the counter I think the number is a bargain, and I have bought enough food in this county to have a view. Get there at seven and the air still holds last night's cold. Inside it smells like Sebastopol in late summer, the flowers at the end of their run or something like that, mixed with whatever it is bagels smell like while they are being boiled and baked, and black coffee coming up through all of it. The espresso grinder going the whole time. Dogs tied up outside, clippers coming off a season, techies carrying laptops they will not open, mothers on the school run, farmers, men in work boots with dry concrete on them, and old-timers who have been coming since the second week. To anybody who has decided the price is an outrage, please stay away. The line is long enough, and it is going to get worse as the rest of the Bay Area works this out. There is always a cheaper and faster bagel somewhere else, and I would take it as a kindness if you went and got one. read more

Went on a Friday morning. It was pretty busy at the service is pretty fast. Staff was super friendly and nice. Definitely is a little bit pricey but over the quality of the food. I think it was pretty good. It's super cute place. I love the colors of. I love the vintage field. It was pretty cold so we took everything to go. Otherwise we would've stayed and had breakfast on the little patio that they have definitely will be coming back again. read more

See all

I picked up bagels this morning on their first official day open. I grew up in Los Angeles eating great bagels. Having lived in Northern California for many decades now, I lost hope of having a "real bagel" ever again. Bonnie Bagels are the real deal. They have a perfect outside crust and are chewy on the inside. The flavor is perfect. These bagels may not be for everyone, because they are not soft and fluffy, like so many "bagels" nowadays. But they are absolutely delicious. I am so glad to have this wonderful, locally owned business here in Sebastopol. read more

Boiled bagels. Crispy on the outside soft on the inside. Interesting, clean aesthetic inside. read more

Bonnie Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

I really wanted to like this place. It's so sad that they spent so much money and effort on the aesthetic of the building and nothing on the bagel recipes. Terrible bagels, it tastes like they came out of a package. Sandwiches are tiny for the big price. Our experience was also super mid. Customer service was mid and they got our order wrong. Why pay astronomical prices for something we can make at home that comes out even better?! read more

We shared an egg and cheese on an onion bagel and the open faced salmon on an everything bagel and I was pretty blown away. Extremely picky on bagels, lots of time in New York, and I'm genuinely impressed. Whatever sauce they put on the egg and cheese was unbelievably good. The long lines at opening sure seem justified! Be back soon. read more

Great food and variety! I highly recommend. Clean, friendly staff, nice outdoor seating.

I stopped by here with a group of Scouts on the way to hike the Lost Coast Trail. Having seen them plan their own menus, I can tell you they're a bunch of picky eaters! We made lox and bagels at the trailhead. It was a treat to watch their eyes widen as they tasted fresh, authentic bagels for the first time. Half of us had plain bagels, and the other half had "everything" bagels. To a person, they raved about the texture and flavor. The dill and green onion schmears were a hit as well. On the way home to SF, the boys asked if we could stop by again, but it was late in the day, and Bonnie's was closed. Any future trips that bring us within reasonable driving distance of Sebastopol will definitely include a side trip for Bagels! read more

Bonnie Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Loved it! Fresh, flavorful and honestly the best bagel sandwich I've had. We will definitely be back

Nice Modern new set up, however, be aware that you will stand in line and will pay for a limit of two Loose bagels when you come to the front then get a buzzer in your hand and wait for your bagels. I was not aware of that. Wanted to have six bagels for three people could not get even an exception for a third bagel. :( will not go here again, luckily, on the other side of the post office is a bagel store that has been there for 20 years and they took care of me - I am grateful for now. Even met the guy again who was in line with me at Bonnie and came from Santa Rosa and had the same disappointment... read more

Absolutely delicious and thrilled to have a bagel spot of this caliber in Sebastopol. Loved my in store order and then my freshly toasted bagels at home. So crispy!!! And the best mocha I've ever had. Not super sweet yet high end chocolate. I'll be back for sure. So happy you're here! And I still love Grateful bagel for its own reasons! We can have two bagel shops! read more

Ok!! We had a great lunch here today. The toasted bagel with salmon shmere was tasty. We will definitely come back. Great addition to Sebastopol! read more

I finally had the chance to try Bonnie bagel today. It was busy, but the employees were very pleasant and handled the line efficiently. The interior of the shop was spotless. The bagels and cream cheese spreads (plain and scallion) I bought were fantastic! It's nice to have such a wonderful bagel shop in Sonoma County. read more

Tried Bonnie Bagels last week. I was very excited with the news of the opening of a New York style bagel shop. Sorry to report the bagels we got were soft and did not resemble New York bagels. Could have gotten Safeway bagels and paid a lot less. Very disappointed. read more

Wait times here are way too long - about 30 mins for one bagel. Unacceptable, it's spreading something on a piece of bread

Good texture not enough salt? The flavor was flat. They are just starting so there is room to improve. If you go for lunch- they close at noon?? It's a bit wonky. Nice looking remodel. We are hoping they improve. At the moment we like Grossman's better read more

I'm originally from New York so I was excited for the opening. I will give them time to work on the recipe and try them again down the road. For now..these aren't at all like NY- East coast bagels. These are very small and what should be a crispy outside was chewy. The inside was as well. I really was hoping to be wowed. I hope they tweak the recipe soon. read more

Came in and waited about 15 min in line and another 15 to get our order as it was very busy. I ordered an everything bagel with smoked salmon cream cheese, capers, and cucumber to go. When I got to my destination and began eating I realized it was plain cream cheese and an abundance of capers. The bagel was pretty small in size as well. I did like the crust on the bagel but that was about it. read more