We live near Harbor Market and it's a real go to for us in Sag, but the prepared food at Cavaniolas…read moreis spectacular, best in Sag. Recommend: Crab cakes Broccoli rabe MEATLOAF OMG what this is insane Meatballs Caprese salad Pretty much all the desserts Lobster salad ( note it is NINETY FIVE dollars a pound. Is this above the gold standard? It might be. It's outrageous but it's tasty.) They are also very nice here, significantly more so than the cheese shop next door. Still you can complete all your fancy shopping in one place at Cavaniolas.

Yum! If their panini…read moreare so good that you still enjoy them on a 95 degree day, you know they're doing something right. Wanted to spend a half day walking around Sag Harbor and was looking for a place to grab lunch to go. High quality ingredients and friendly staff that directed us to a good place nearby to sit and eat. We only ordered sandwiches but they had a variety of sweet and savory items ready to go, which would have made for a wonderful picnic had it been a bit cooler outside.

They call this place the most expensive grocery store in the hamptons but I must admit its great…read morequality and most of their food is delicious! The prices is not for your grocery run every week. Its those type of places where you get curious so you go and buy to see whats the hype is all about. I've tried a lot of food here. I've had their chicken fingers that cost around $35, lobster salad for $49.29, shrimp cocktail for $47.50 and a lot more. Cute ambiance and the store is not that big. I think if you're that curious then go and try it atleast once. The chicken fingers is not that good if you don't buy some sauce for it. I recommend buying their buffalo chicken balls instead. That one is pretty tasty.

Overpriced prepared foods market that unfortunately has delicious food. It's a pretty small space,…read moreso you may have to weave around people, but the selection is huge! There were SO many things I wanted to try, but the sticker shock reined me in. We opted for a crispy chicken lettuce wrap and chicken Caesar wrap. I was pleasantly surprised by both! But next time I'm probably gonna give in and try some of their baked goods as well. The only thing is I wish there were tables and chairs, but it's more of a grab and go place. We were lucky to find benches outside for a super quick meal

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

Amazing options for groceries and cooked food! Everything in the hamptons is so expensive and this…read moregrocery is no exception but compaired to all of them I feel like this one has a better price because you can still get a fair amount of food for less then $20. I mostly get some cooked stuff here like their fried chicken, shrimp, rice and more and it was delicious! Their grocery items is pretty expensive. I remember getting less than 10 items for $100+ already. Then again its the Hamptons. I really like that they also have space to eat outdoors. Staff are friendly and very helpful too. If you're visiting around here, this is a good place to grab some cooked stuff and bring it to the beach or picnic!

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

I thought the gentleman that helped us was so knowledgeable. He understood what types of cheeses we…read morelike and guided us.

We love the sandwiches but the people working here are so so rude. Everytime we come they are nasty…read moreto everyone in the store for now reason. After years of coming, we're not returning anymore - can't stand giving business to people who clearly hate their lives and their customers

Cute market with many items and options. Perishable and non perishable items like jarred foods,…read moreoils and spreads are available. Coffee menu looked good. There is a hand written menu on the wall but everything is pre-made in the showcase or refrigerated area. There are a few areas to eat there but most people I noticed got their food to go The falafel salad was very fresh and didn't taste like it was stale or old, always a worry when things are pre made. They say that everything is made fresh daily, and it showed. Perfect spot for a quick and easy meal or bite and with healthy options

Cute store with Korean flavors that caught our eye. We had bbq chicken which was okay. The reuben…read moremelt was big. You have to specify to them to make the food hot. They just did a quick toast om most of the food we purchased, which did not taste good until i asked them to make it hot. Took 1-2 mins. Would come back again to try some other items.

They had some of the best apple cider donuts and chocolate chip cookies I've ever had!read more

Country farm stand that grows their own apples, makes their own cider and has a massive amount of…read morepumpkins for the pumpkin visitors in fall. No dates on the cider but was reassured made each week and lasts three. So hoped to find a batch not past the week but no way to tell Nice place to stop plenty of things to try and bring where your headed.

Provisions Natural Health Food Store in Sag Harbor offers an extensive selection of health foods,…read moreincluding supplements, groceries, and prepared meals. The store features a dedicated section of organic produce, as well as a wide variety of gluten-free and dairy-free products. Customers can also enjoy a refreshing shake or sit-down meal on the premises.

I came into this store every day during my stay in Sag Harbor. Today, the shop was nearly empty and…read moreI ordered three of the same juices for my family. When I let the staff know they had made the wrong juice, I was treated with hostility, accused of being rude for simply clarifying my order, and banned from a store I had loyally supported all week. An older blonde woman - who I've ironically seen be unpleasant with customers all week - was irritated the moment I questioned the order. She snapped at me for inspecting it. When I explained how it red instead of green, she ordered me to taste it, then seemed annoyed when I told her it contained ingredients that weren't in what I had ordered. I tried to explain what I'd ordered and the substitution I'd made, but she and another brunette employee became increasingly hostile. As they all began bickering amongst themselves about what was in each juice on the menu, so I offered to write down my order to help - at which point the older blonde woman told me I was being rude and said to the other employees that she was "ready to fight me." Over kale and chard... at 9:30 a.m.? Her behavior was so disturbing I just walked away and sat down with my husband, mother, and my baby - all of whom had been watching all of this unfold in shock as we waited for the amended order. Then, while we were sitting quietly, she told me I was banned from the store. Both my husband and my mother - dumbfounded asked why clarifying a juice order warranted being banned. Her response? To my husband, she snapped, "What are you, the boyfriend?" and to my mother - who was with our baby - "I'm not speaking to you." And the manager? He didn't ask a single question or review video footage. He simply said he was going to stand by her wishes. The reality is, I'm just passing through. We were genuinely excited to stock up on some of the great products before heading home -- but now I'll just order everything online. And frankly, it's a shame. This kind of unnecessary hostility in customer service is exactly what drives people away from supporting small businesses.