Bottom Line: Fudge bacon brownie had serious heft, but came up short on namesake flavors or integrity/structure. Top Line: Picked up a Blue Horse fudge bacon brownie $6 at Brendyn's BBQ yesterday along with a meal, saving the brownie as a treat for today. So returned to Brendyn's this afternoon to get tea for eating the brownie. Brownie is seriously heavy!! Very, very moist beneath the layer of baby chocolate chips and extraordinarily tender of crumb. Too much so I found. The block of chocolate cake-like brownie crumbled into pieces as I tried to pick it up. I finally resorted to pinching off small wads of it to pop into my mouth. While being very moist with oil density, the flavor profile was about on par with a supermarket bakery brownie. Plenty of chocolate taste, but minimal (if any) bacon smokiness shining through. Fudge's buttery brown sugar sweetness or cream's richness were likewise AWOL. So I'd say this was a decent $2.50 brownie. But nowhere near justifying the $6 ticket price I paid to get it, in spite of its moistness. If I'm in the neighborhood of Blue Horse's sticks 'n bricks location I may hit them up for a cupcake or some such to see how that flies. But no more brownies from them for me. read more

Blue Horse Bakery - Fudge bacon brownie with a cup of Brendyn's BBQ ice tea. - Bakeries Near Me - Nacogdoches, Texas

See all

So four years later (2021 summer), my review remains the same. I actually placed an order for a cake, it looked very nice however it was really dry. I'm not sure why they made it so tall either, is that an "IN" thing? It was hard to cut and honestly didn't even fit a dessert plate LOL. I dunno maybe there's a way to cut that style. My request was last mintute but I don't really thing it would've been a big deal anyway because they had duplicates already on the table. It was okay, I wouldn't order it again though TBH. It's a cute bakery but there needs to be a few improvements on taste/texture. The coffee isn't that great either but there's not really a lot of options around. I know the next day after the Festival there was a coffee truck on the main square and that was GOOD! I can't remember the name of it but if there's a coffee truck in that area, they serve some BAD AS coffee! read more

Blue Horse Bakery - Lemon Blueberry - Bakeries Near Me - Nacogdoches, Texas

Blue Horse is such a blessing to Nacogdoches! They are SO friendly and really do great work. Flavors are amazing and I've never ever ever had less than a great experience at blue horse and I've been going there for 2 years! I needed a last minute birthday cake, and they made it happen! Side note: their chocolate cake pops are the best I've ever had. read more

I can appreciate the teamwork the staff shows when they are in a havoc, mistakes happen all the time. I really liked their blackberry cupcake, the frosting was light and not overly sweet. The breading was a little hard though when compared to the vanilla blueberry cupcake. The blueberry cupcake had moist breading but very very sweet frosting. I wasn't able to try their bacon and egg turnover until I got home. It has flaky breading which is nice but also very greasy!! The bacon was pretty hard. I think my only concern is that it's quite greasy but overall still very good! read more

See all

Cute little French country style bakery. You order at the counter, and they bring you your food at your table. I got the chicken salad sandwich, it was delicious. The croissant was flaky, and the chicken salad was creamy, with crunchy celery and sweet cranberries. I had a strawberry and cream cupcake, it was so good. Sweet cream frosting, on top of a light and fluffy strawberry cupcake. So many sweets to choose from! read more

Blue Horse Bakery - So many cupcakes to try! - Bakeries Near Me - Nacogdoches, Texas

This bakery is such a gem! Whitney did the cookies and cake for my baby shower last year and went above and beyond all of my expectations! This bakery creates beautiful works that are so delicious, I got so many compliments on everything and couldn't believe that I could afford something so special. The creativity in this small town bakery is absolutely unmatched, I also hired them to create custom cookies for my bachelorette party and I cannot wait to see what they come up with for my wedding next month. read more

See all

I can't tell you how amazing this girls cakes are!! She made the cake and cupcakes for my wedding and they were nothing short of magically delicious and the woman is a seriously an artist! I love her cakes so much and she's amazing to work with. Definitely worth checking out! You won't be disappointed. read more

Blue Horse Bakery - my beautiful wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Nacogdoches, Texas

See all

Blue Horse made a cake for a milestone celebration in our family. The cake was beautiful and everyone at our party said the cake tasted wonderful. There was some miscommunication about the flavor of the cake, so I did let them know that I did not get exactly what we ordered. They reached out to apologize and make it right for the next time we order. I appreciate that level of customer service! Thank you so much for making our day special! read more

Catered this today for work. Great tasting food. Lacking in portion size. If you charge $3.75 for chicken on a salad you should probably give more than 4 slivers of chicken. Other than that, great! read more

Have not tried their lunch yet but I stopped in and tried a cupcake and it was delicious!!! I was very impressed not to mention the bakery itself is very cute! read more

This is the most amazing bakery!! They made the cake for my friends wedding and EVERYONE was raving about it. I don't typically write reviews but I have to make an exception for this cake. The cake was beautiful and the baker did an amazing job matching it to the flowers and decor of the wedding. I don't know how they make it so pretty and so yummy at the same time when most pretty cakes taste like garbage. The blue horse cake tastes heavenly and I would buy a tub of the frosting to eat alone. They also made these pretty raspberry chocolate cupcakes I went back for thirds (no joke)! read more

The cutest little bakery right on the brick streets downtown! A great place to grab brunch or lunch with the girlfriends! Their cupcakes are delicious! It's one of my favorite places to pop in for a cold drink and sweet treat! Be sure and stop by this adorable shop! read more

Fantastic sweets and really cute old style bakery! The first time my daughter and I visited, we peered through the window (they had just closed) and the owner surprised us at the door and invited us in! We visited with her and she is just an awesome and smart young lady! I try to go by when visiting Nac from Waco to enjoy while in town and some to take home! They also have gluten free! read more

Awesome little place on a great backstreet in old downtown Nacogdoches. Wonderful treats and lunches!!!

Went on a Saturday at 1pm and ordered a salad with grilled chicken. My salad cake with no chicken & was covered in cheese, cranberries & nuts. It was decent as was my friend's half sandwich and soup. Not stellar nor was the service. It seems upscale until your beverage comes in a bottle. Could use some minor changes to appeal to the crowd that is likely to frequent for the prices. I wanted to try something for dessert, but it was a humid day & everything in the dessert case was sweating and looked less than appealing. read more