We were tucked in a nice cozy booth to celebrate a birthday! The birthday boys lobster came out over cooked but also cold. They did apologize and compensate us. The restaurant was full yet service was still great! read more

See all

20 years of birthdays, anniversaries and special occasions as our favorite restaurant. We think we are done. $750-$1,200 for dinner and : (3) bad steaks in a row. Plus chose a steak special that was just horrible. Last night $50 for average Risotto. $69 for a special sushi plate that was not artful - actually THROWN on the plate and very very average and tiny sashimi. Just terrible. Lime Chilean Sea Bass - ugh. Sides so small now that you get about 2-3 tablespoons of mashed potatoes, Mac and Cheese and Bock Choy. Dessert for my 18 year old after $770 was a donut with whipped cream! LOL WHEN you see the rating on Yelp at 3.8 you can see how far they've fallen from 2006. Two waiters cared about nothing. Not worth it. read more

The reason I am leaving this review is because the size of the steak for the price charged is absolutely ridiculous. The prices have gone up in Blackstone and the service and food quality has gone way down over the last five years.$70 for a fillet with four slices is crazy Work. I have no problem paying for food, but this was just robbery. The sides were tiny and very disappointing for the price. Not impressed. The bill was $330 for 2 tiny steaks, 4 slices each steak, tiny side a mashed, some diner style hash browns and Brussels. I can promise you I'll make better steaks and sides in my grill at home. Rip off. read more

Came here as a party of 8 for a fun get together. One of our group is a regular so we left the ordering to him. First of all, who would have thought that a steakhouse would have a strong sushi game! The rolls were delicious and had a great variety. We ordered half east coast and west coast oysters and they were fresh and delicious and accompanied by all the accoutrements. We ordered two kinds of steaks to share. They even provide a hot stone for people who want their meat cooked more done can get a little extra cook on it. We also ordered the sea bass - looked good but I was too busy eating the steaks! Service was excellent and very attentive. Cocktails were very strong and we had the wine flowing. They even use a large decanter to pour into the glasses all the way at the far end of the table. But note - you're paying for every bit of the elevated experience. read more

See all

Filet was cooked perfectly and had the addition of truffle butter. We also enjoyed appetizers of west coast oysters, crab cake, Korean hot dog, sliders. Large group so took way longer than anticipated but server was nice & knowledgeable. Wish I knew which Cabernet I had, it was excellent! Ambiance in the main dining room is gorgeous, however with our large party we were seated in the side room which was dark & felt crowded with a surprising amount of foot traffic. read more

See all

Eh. Expensive. Just ok. Server was good. Sushi is just ok as well it's very dark space, kids running around. Bill was 400 without tip and had kids screaming in my ear and running around the table. It's becoming the same thing over and over again at LI restaurants. read more

I love coming here! The service is always excellent. I usually order the filet mignon, however today I ordered the Blackstone supreme sushi roll and it was giving an 8/10 because the wagu tasted a bit overcooked. Aside from that, their steaks tastes incredible!! read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Blackstone supreme sushi roll - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

See all

Nice spacious place with great friendly service. We enjoyed the porterhouse steak for two with creamed spinach, Mac and cheese and French fries. Valet parking. Will be back. read more

See all

I had an incredible dining experience here. While the food was excellent, the service was even better. Shoutout to Jory and his team! Jory is attentive, kind, and thorough. He and the chefs care about the quality and integrity of the food. Blackstone is the kind of place that you come to celebrate big, whether it's for a couple or a group. Dining here was a great way to start the new year! read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Tropical catch of the day - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

We had our Thanksgiving dinner at Blackstone. It was pretty crowded, they pretty much stuffed us together. It was not intimate at all. I could hear conversations on both sides. They do have valet parking, but no coat check. The Thanksgiving dinner special was ok, nothing special. The homemade pumpkin pie was ok. My husband got the T-bone steak and the crème brûlée. I finished it off with an espresso martini. read more

See all

Thank you for making my surprise party absolutely amazing! Everything was perfect from start to finish. The manager, Dodo, always goes above and beyond to accommodate and ensure everything runs smoothly. The food was delicious, and the private room was the perfect setting for my birthday celebration. We always request Zorn and Gab when we visit, and they never disappoint--they're both fantastic! Stephanie also helped out the night of the party and was incredible. The attentiveness and positive energy really added to the experience. A big thank you from me to all of you! I highly recommend this place to everyone. You truly made our dinner experience unforgettable. read more

See all

Blackstone Steakhouse was the venue of choice for my friend's wedding reception and it was really nice. The service was good and the food was delicious, very filling. I had cesear salad for starter, the filet mignon w/ mashed potatoes as the main course (a sauce chimichurri or something could have accompanied it though), and NY cheesecake for dessert. I forgot the name if the Martini I ordered but it was blue and good, haha. It was a nice time! read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

We enjoyed a wonderful lunch with excellent service. Each staff member was friendly, attentive and accommodating. The steaks were cook perfectly with a nice crust, the shrimp and string bean salad was a nice starter and the sides, asparagus and mashed potatoes were delicious, enough for 3 people. The ambiance in the side room was very comfortable. read more

See all

The moment I entered this restaurant I knew it would be very average. I was greeted by a poorly dressed staff member. The restaurant is very old, dark and stuffy. I had the fillet mignon. It was very average. I also had the shrimp cocktail. The shrimp tasted like they were previously frozen. This is a very expensive restaurant without the great food. read more

Blackstone has always been a consistently great restaurant. Since you always have two servers serving your table you never need to try to find anyone to assist you, plenty of happy servers are everywhere. The food is always fresh from sushi to steak, the menu can be overwhelming since there are tons and tons of items from appetizers to salads to fish selections to raw bar items to steaks to imported steaks to desserts, get the picture. You'll need time to review it all before a server comes over to mention specials and mess up your dining plan. There are also special cocktails and an extensive wine list. With so many items you must be thinking they can't get it right but amazingly they do. You clearly pay for what you get because like any great steak house it's not cheap to eat here but give it a try you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Enjoyed a family meal recently, with my family for my youngest daughter's . Great time, great meals, greatconversation, as usual. Enjoyed our individual meals and the mussels and scallops appetizer. Nice wine for myself and various martinis for my wife and daughter's. 5th time there and will return SOON read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

Nice ambiance, great decor and service - our server John Z was amazing! But the food - I was not so thrilled with. Lobster bisque was delicious, wish we had some bread. A $140 steak was pretty small and tasted good but not amazing. The entire sea bass dish lacked color and was completely overpowered by coconut, purple yam could have been softer and the cucumber salad did not belong on that plate at all. The sides were not bad . The cheesecake was very smooth, but that chocolate cake was the star of the entire meal - utter perfection. This was quite an expensive dinner and overall just an okay experience. read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

Let me first start with it's a very busy restaurant. Service becomes a challenge when wait staff is not focused. The food came out slow not as hot as I would hope for.i ordered the filet mignon , medium rare, not medium well. Dry no flavor. We had to order butter sauce to fix this $9.00 we had ten people dining with us so maybe it would be a good idea for a restaurant of this caliber to have someone overseeing the food leaving the kitchen.My wife ordered sushi crab and lobster, dry no dipping sauce. She finally had duck sauce sent over, not a great choice for sushi , she has celiac . $1440 dollars for a meal seems like a good price for a meal that I left hungry. Robert Delman Port Jefferson ny read more

Always a great time when we go to this more upscale long island steakhouse, owned by Anthony scotto. Been here a bunch of times and always have a solid meal accompanied by some great drinks. The bar is a nice spot to start for a cocktail which features a huge wine list and some top shelf whiskey and bourbon. Food wise there's so many good options. The wageu Sliders, sushi, and lobster bisque are usually our go to's. The wedge salad is also a nice starter. Main course wise the meat options are always top notch, with the lamb chops being my new favorite. The Australian tomahawk is also nice if your splitting a meal and don't mind shelling out some extra cash. Service is always terrific and the waiters are very knowledgeable of the menu and wine offerings. Overall if your looking for a higher class meal on long island I'd recommend. read more

Visited with my son and had an excellent experience. Steaks were excellent quality and cooked perfectly, and the pork belly bao bun starter was very good. Service was great as well, we are looking forward to our next visit. read more

My husband and I loved Blackstones...so when we saw the happy hour special at the bar we thought we would try it...after all its the next to last Sunday of the summer. We'll dont go to the Sunday happy hour unless you are a " regular" expect. To be ignored. My husband and I leave 100 dollar tips up and down the eastern seaboard...but not tonight. We were treated poorly is an understatement. ALLIE was not all that and treated us poorly. Think twice wont go back terrible.... read more

Came here for my husband's birthday with friends and i am in love with their service and good food. It was an early dinner so it was nice and quiet. Christopher was very accommodating. Our first steak was unfortunately overcooked but the manager and the staff were attentive and made it right to order. The steak show was great and we had a great time overall. read more

See all

Service is excellent, servers are accommodating and friendly. Alcoholic bevs are yummy and strong I love the way they prepare the crab cakes ! read more

See all

Had a nice evening for our anniversary. Wished we were sat in a more nice area. The new back area is not worth it for that money. For that money, you want to be in a great spot, even by fireplace. It was super dark where we sat but not even good lighting where I could say Romantic. The wine selection was very good. We enjoyed a nice red and the cuts of meat were spot on, well cooked. Loved my filet! It's been a while since we've been here. Our waiter was attentive. Would like to go to the bar for apps and sushi next time. read more

See all

Blackstone offers a high-end dining experience with elegant decor, attentive service, and a menu featuring prime steaks, seafood, and sushi. Highlights include the porterhouse steak and crème brûlée. It's a popular spot for special occasions, though some reviewers mention inconsistent food quality and high prices. A classy choice for steak lovers on Long Island. The olive oil that u get at the table is phenomenal. read more

3.5 Blackstone Steakhouse was pretty much like any other steakhouse and unfortunately, the experience didn't match the ambiance. The service was great and attentive and server and assistant made sure our large group was taken care of. What didn't live up to the hype was the taste of the food. Everything looked good but the taste left something to be desired, pretty much mediocre but the service was great so a 3.5! read more

See all

The old saying you get what you pay for rings true. What a delicious meal. T-bone steak, cooked perfectly. Brussel sprouts, mashed potatoes, deserts- all great. The service was just as good as the food. Is it pricey? Yes. Worth every penny. read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

See all

The food is delicious and the ambiance is trendy. The service is a 5 out of 5. It's expensive.

I'm a regular at this restaurant. I go there for their consistent high quality steaks and for my wife their assortment of fresh fish dishes, Ambience could be better but this is a steakhouse @, Johnny V is my asked for waiter if available. He paces the dinner and remembers your likes and needs. read more

My husband and I went here as we waited to attend a wedding the next day the porterhouse with the Summer ale with mashed potatoes was delicious. The service was wonderful. It was just too dark in the restaurant. We preferred seating near the window. read more

Service was top notch. Food quality was excellent. Spend hours there dining. Been here several times and I'm never disappointed. read more

See all

It's a very pretty place...the ambience is nice for a steakhouse. However, my T-bone steak wasn't what I envisioned. It was very tender...a bit too tender so that it almost didn't feel like steak. The taste was fairly non-existent. You know when you get a really good piece of steak and you do that "Wow...this is so good!" eye roll? Well, I couldn't do it. I wouldn't send it back because it was perfectly cooked and I just couldn't put my finger on what was wrong. My nephew, sitting next to me, got a beautiful looking filet mignon on the bone. Cooked to,perfection. He said it was tasteless. So, that's my experience. Seems others really like it as it was pretty crowded. Maybe it was just me... read more

See all

Top of the list! If you're looking for a premier steakhouse look no further. Premier cuts, professional and attentive service and eloquent decor, Blackstone competes with the very top NYC steakhouses and delivers an ultimate steakhouse experience. Everything from the extensive -and fresh - sushi to start to the mouth watering steaks hit the spot. Highly recommended for the VERY special occasions. read more

Haven't been to Blackstone in a long time, several years ago. Amazing friends chose Blackstone and while it wouldn't have been my first choice, I put on a smile. My steak 'measuring stick' is Peter Lugers, and I was just there last night, so I was properly tuned to give Blackstone an objective comparison. I have to say, the porterhouse was better. It was aged better, much less moisture, with much stronger savory and glutamine flavor. Add that flavor to the creamy, oily fatty acids coating your mouth, and you're going to eat this steak even if you didn't want any. The cut was thicker, charred & seasoned, and seemed more generous, with stellar marbling. Round out the menu with sushi, extensive starters & sides to choose from, and a raw bar, in a huge beautiful dining room - I have to say Blackstone is an amazing steakhouse. Unfortunately service had a slip at the end of the meal. Our table of eight was ignored during the entire desert service when things were needed and we wanted to leave to watch the Super Bowl. Our server was gone, they sent in the closer to finish desert, and he fumbled in the fourth quarter. The manager was tapped in, by me, and he sent whoever the server was, and he acknowledged the situation and at least took care of the coffees (which is what we needed help with). read more

See all

The service from start to finish was pleasant. Perfect ambiance for a business dinner. This restaurant seems to draw in patrons from everywhere (business, family, small groups of friends, birthdays). I had the daily special pasta which was Squid Ink pasta with Lobster in a Burrata cheese sauce. It was served in an appetizer portion, so our server recommended a salad to start. It was perfect! Will definitely revisit this restaurant whenever I'm in town. read more

Blackstone Steakhouse - Squid Ink Pasta with Lobster (Special) - Steakhouses Near Me - Melville, New York

See all

Packed on a wednesday night. Food was average at best. The steak had decent flavor but was tough. The salmon was flaky and cooked well. The creamed spinach wasn't my favorite either. Seems like the place to be though so maybe it was an off night. They have valet parking as well. read more

I usually sit in the bar area which is generally lively without being too crazy. Bartenders are friendly! My only complaint is that is is way too dark inside . They used to have curtains open by the bar but now it's like a vampires den and very hard to see anything ! Esp in summer , it's nice to have some windows open and light . read more

Came to Blackstone for dinner and it was amazing . Ambiance was nice - our server Chris was excellent.. he knew the menu and did some recommendations- I almost was going to not have the tuna tartar and I am so glad I ordered it . The eel was fresh . Steak was cooked perfectly and sides were not exceptional but they were not the worst ... I come to NY a few times throughout the year and would definitely come back for some more sushi ! This place is a must try !!! Thank you Blackstone for a wonderful dinner read more

See all

Dropped by Blackstone Steakhouse for a birthday celebration. The reservation process was very straightforward. Even though it was the holidays, we made a same day reservation through open table. Upon arriving, the place was packed full of families and dining. The service was phenomenal. Tons of waiters who were super friendly and helpful. No complains on the food. I would not say my favorite steakhouse on Long Island but it's one of the top ones. The Wagyu special was a hit with the show but a little bit on the pricey side. Overall it was a lovely dining experience but a bit high on the budget. I would say it's perfect for a special occasion. Make sure to mention any events and they give a nice treat for dessert! read more

See all

Took a friend out for dinner Sunday July 6 at 5 pm. Nice ambiance, clean and a friendly staff. Place was slow probably because of the holiday weekend which was good for us. Had a chopped salad to start was fresh and good ordered bone in ribeye, marinated skirt steak, Brussels sprouts and mashed potatoes for sides. Sides were good , skirt steak cooked to much and ribeye came out burnt well well done no flavor. For a supposedly high end steak house we were disappointed and wouldn't recommend. read more

See all