We just arrived home from a week's vacation, split between the Apostle Island National Lakeshore and Madeline Island. We stayed at Big Bay during our time on the island, and it's a quality state park.
The Good: It's clean, well-kept, and there's plenty of brush and trees in between each site to give it that secluded feel I want when I'm camping. Plenty of good hiking with some phenomenal views. Check out the Point trail if you're looking for a lakeside hike, or the Lagoon trail if you're looking to explore the depths of the park.
The Bad: There aren't any sites on or near the water, but the bay makes up for it. Also, there really wasn't a great place on our site to pitch the tent. Much of the site was packed with gravel and we ended up putting our tent on the very edge, close to the driveway. Also, the wood sold at the park isn't quite dry enough. We thought maybe it had something to do with the fact that we were on an island where the wood probably never gets very dry, or doesn't have enough time to cure in order to keep up with demand.
The Best: Big Bay itself. The beach is huge and the water is picturesque, and it seems there's always a nice breeze. Go there at the right time of year (mid-July to the end of summer) and you can swim. I won't lie, it's cold...we are talking about an island on Lake Superior (the boss). We threw our frisbee and read books for hours. You can rent kayaks or paddleboards and take them around the bay, too. We had just gotten off of a 4 day kayak excursion around the islands, so we just watched. It really is a beautiful place.
I know nothing about the Town Park, which is another place to camp on Madeline. Therefore I have nothing to compare Big Bay State Park to. I had a pleasant (but not mind-blowing) experience and would absolutely camp here again. read more