I've been staying at The Inn for nearly 20 years. I feel as if Pat and Lori have become friends…read moreduring that time.
The only reason I don't give The Inn a five-star rating (because I love it enough to, personally) is that I realize I'm biased. So in fairness, here are the pros and cons.
Pros: Wonderful, historical home that has been in the innkeeper's family since it was built.
The ambiance to go with it! Antiques everywhere, interesting bits and pieces of the history of the island, cozy rooms with air conditioning or fans as you prefer, and windows that open. A view of the lake from the front, and more privacy from the rear of the house.
Check out the reading nook on the second floor.
Free Wi-fi.
Continental Breakfast.
You can put a small amount of perishable food in the fridge/freezer but not a whole lot, as the innkeepers live in the house.
Lovely gardens, which Pat tends; especially his dahlias! Wait until you see them. Some are huge. You'll see. hummingbirds for sure!
The front porch, which faces the lake, with a view of Cedar Point. You could see bald eagles, cormorants, geese, ducks, ospreys, and if you're there at the right time. Baltimore oriels, loons, and much more.
Pat is knowledgable about the wildlife of the island, and will, for a small fee, take visitors to see unique features such as the Alvar. In season you can attend bird bandings -- ever seen a saw whet owl?
Did I mention Lori's epic brownies, that she makes most afternoons? Yum!
There is a private beach, but it's down some pretty steep stairs and rocky. But once down there, the water is very pleasant.
Watch for endangered Lake Erie water snakes. Harmless, but they can startle you.
You might find beach glass or pottery sherds from shipwrecks!
Great conversations can be had here, and friendships made.
The Inn was freshly painted this year and looks wonderful!
Cons: The steps to the second floor are very steep, so if that's a problem, book one of the two first floor rooms.
You'll share the bathrooms with other guests. I don't mind, but I know some people do, so keep that in mind, too.
Kelley's Island is possibly my favorite place in the world, and The Inn one of my favorite places, too. In my heart, this is a five star stay, but it meets with my personal standards. It's a very old house, so if you're someone who wants everything new and shiny, probably not your place. But if you love atmosphere, excellent conversation, old books, antiques, front porch sitting, and the sound of the lake lulling you to sleep, it's for you!