Out of business. The food at tikka is better no loss. Great location hopefully a new restaurant will take its place. read more

May 12, 2024 - 3 for dinner : Take Out. This will be an abbreviated review because did not order, their menu and ordering process is fairly complicated and diverse, and I know we will be back for a more organized and accurate accounting of the foods ordered and the details. They have been open for over a year, and we live less than a mile away? WHO KNEW?? All four dishes were very good. However we each go in different directions in terms of tastes, spice severity, and then composition of sauces and flavors. spicey cauliflower and the tofu dish I got were very nice to my liking. My wife liked here chicken dish and my daughter like HER chicken dish. In the end there were multiple favorites and then the 2nd and third place were "sides" . Great job, not too expensive, counter service was prompt, fst, and the order we placed 5 hours previous was ready (not cold or even warm) and was perfect when I got it home. read more

See all

Delivery by DoorDash was fast and efficient - everything arrived hot and fresh. The C21. Butter Chicken was stupendous! I ordered it mild but it still had a bit of heat that built up over the meal. The Fish Biriyani was very, very good but even ordered mild was quite spicy. The B02. Garlic Naan was excellent too. There were some excellent sauces that were included - none seemed spicy, just very flavorful. One container of white rice was included but I'm not sure which entree it came with. read more

Delicious delicious delicious what a great restaurant the portions were enormous more than enough for 2 people. The service was good , our waidress was patient and explained everything that we needed to know. The ambiance, the vibe, was very relaxing. The restaurant was very clean, and we will definitely be back read more

See all

My wife and I really enjoy Indian food, and at the Bay Leaf the cuisine is excellent. I wish I had taken more pictures but I barely got one: Cauliflower Manchurian. I already had eaten a bite when my wife reminded me that I usually take pictures. My apologies, but the food was so good I didn't want to stop for pictures. I started with the Cauliflower Manchurian and I had to keep reminding myself I was eating cauliflower, otherwise I would have thought it was some sort of meat. The appetizer serving was so large it could be taken for an entrée. For entrees my wife ordered the Jalfrezi - Balti with beef, and I ordered the Mango Curry with lamb. She enjoyed her order as it was spicy and just a bit hot. My Mango Cuddy was terrific and just slightly sweet. The accompanying rice was light and was perfect for mixing with the entrees. We ordered the garlic naan which was just right for dipping. To drink, we enjoyed bottles of Indian beer which we poured into frosted mugs. This restaurant is not just an Osprey jewel but a Sarasota jewel, you should not overlook it. read more

Bay Leaf Osprey - Cauliflower - Indian Near Me - Osprey, Florida

We ordered 2 different chicken dishes. One was great; the other had very dry overcooked chicken. Oddly, there was no one there when I went in to pick up food at dinner time. There are too many wonderful restaurants in the area, so we won't be back. read more

Wow! This place is amazing! Friendly waiters and staff! The food is so delicious! Very flavorful! read more

Bay Leaf Osprey - Chicken Tikka, paneer (cheese) Tikka, fragrant basmati rice, rice pudding and beans - Indian Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Had their lunch special with the lamb vindaloo. The boss had her usual chicken Tikka masala. Bit our lunches were very good. The lamb vindaloo was flavorful and of course spicy. The papas wasn't as crisp as I like. The samosa was tasty as well as the naan. The chicken Tikka masala was also flavorful and the boss liked it Service was very good and the place is quite large. Overall, if you want a solid place for Indian food, this place will do well for you. read more

The best Indian food I have ever had... I've had a lot. The staff are awesome and authentic and eager to help make sure my allergy requests were paid attention to. I was impressed with the nice lighting and comfortable seats we sat in and they had a nice silent cooking channel playing on the wall to enjoy while hanging out. And the food was brought out super fast less than 15 minutes for everything. read more

See all

This place is tucked away inside a strip mall, and if you were driving along on 41 and didn't know about it you would probably miss it. However, if you're in Osprey, don't miss it. The inside smells of delicious Indian spice, and there was an Indian family just getting seated, which I usually take as a good sign. The interior has some Indian touches, but is lovely and modern, instead of other competitors who tend to go with dark carved wood that makes the place less inviting/dark. I first ordered paneer pakoras. I never had paneer pakoras, I usually get a vegetable pakora but they didn't seem to have that on the menu, so I went with paneer. Paneer is a kind of relatively mild cheese, and these pakoras had a crispy outside; the inside was like a firm tofu. It was served with three sauces, a mint, an onion, and a tamarind sauce, and each was flavorful and delicious. I found myself rationing the pakoras and trying to figure out which sauce I wanted to end with. I also ordered the Chicken Vindaloo. I asked for "spicy," and it had a very nice bite to it, but not unbearable (although I'm Thai, and my definition of "hot" might be way different than yours). It does make me wonder how hot the phaal is though. Otherwise, a delicious if unsurprising vindaloo. I also ordered garlic naan, and that too was excellent, although I love naan; if I wasn't alone I'd have ordered one for myself and one for my dinner companion. I want to say I got four good sized pieces, but I'm not sure. It was perfect for me though. Overall, I don't really think of Osprey for any kind of ethnic food, so that makes Bay Leaf a real find, and you absolutely should go. read more

See all

Amazing food! Kind and humble service. I refuse to eat with my coat on because they want to save money on heat. The food is pricey so unless they get a fireplace in there, I'm good, I'll go to Turmeric and make the drive to eat in warmth. read more

This is a happy story. My wife, daughter, and I are in Sarasota and wanted good Indian cuisine, for which Tikka in Venice (about 20 minutes away) was first choice. But the problem there was that they're so good that a long wait is inevitable during peak times. (Reservations aren't accepted.) So Plan B: We were aware of Bay Leaf in Osprey, about half as far from our place, and reviews were good, but when we tried to visit them for the first time a couple of months ago they were inexplicably closed with no indication why or whether it was temporary. Thus, our hopes were not high when we bailed on Tikka. Not much to lose, though, since we'd have to pass Bay Leaf's location on our way back to Sarasota. We got to Bay Leaf and, hooray, they were open, and not even crowded on a Thursday evening. We were seated immediately. For starters we ordered Paneer Pakora and Masala Papad. We had never had the first item before, knew only that paneer means some kind of cheese. Well, it arrived with the usual accompanying mint and tamarind and onion sauces, and my daughter couldn't stop raving about it. I liked it, too. The papad is what other Indian places call papadam, a garbanzo and lentil-based fried thin crisp bread. This was obviously fresh-made and came with what the restaurant calls masala, which I would've called Indian bruschetta--it was wonderful. We had some masala left after the papad was gone and I had it later with the excellent plain naan that we ordered with our dinner. Very, very good. My wife ordered her favorite Indian dish, chicken tikka massala and pronounced it excellent. She also ordered chicken with korma (creamy cashew) sauce, and this too was good. My daughter got the chicken with coconut cream curry sauce and liked it very much. I went for the fish nirvana (salmon in a coconut cream and kerala curry sauce), and it was fantastic. Can't wait to enjoy the leftovers, which I will because wife and daughter are both averse to fish. (That's fine, more for me.) I also had the chicken biriyani, which came with a raita sauce. This was a lot of food, and we knew we'd be taking it away with us at the end. Just had some of the biriyani for lunch, and it's first class. Service was good. Various servers brought things to us throughout the meal, and there wasn't much of a language barrier, though the staff are plainly from the subcontinent. I believe in commending outfits that do what they're supposed to well, and Bay Leaf absolutely qualifies. We'll be going back for more soon. read more

Didn't enjoy it, sorry. I have been eating Indian food since I was a child, I am From the UK where Indian restaurants are on every corner. This did not taste authentic at all. The colors of both curries we ordered were even weird. Sorry we will not return. read more

Authentic Indian Cuisine! Great Ambience and friendly staff. Doesn't get any better. Give them a try and you will not regret it. read more

Delicious food. Nice atmosphere. Great music. Good service. The food though, it's delicious and pretty reasonable.

It's the best I've had since London. This place is the real deal. Had a lamb dish. There's a lot of chicken on the menu. Not hard to find something good. Must go. read more

Had an amazing Indian meal. We love Indian food and this is by far the best we have found in the Sarasota area. Reasonable priced, good service, great value for money. We had samosas, chicken tikka Marsala, chicken butter Marsala, naan and raita. Everything was excellent, chicken was tender, juicy and plentiful. Spice levels were great, my husband asked for Indian spicy and it did not disappoint. Will 100% be back, now our go-to Indian. read more

See all

One of the best Indian restaurants Ive been to in Florida. Location is a bit farther away from everything else but everything else makes up for it. The restaurant itself is very spacious, clean, and has a nice ambiance. The service is amazing, very nice hosts and servers. Their lunch thali offers an incredible value, for $15 you get to pick a chicken entree, rice, naan, papad, samosa, chole, and a dessert. I had to take some to go because I couldn't finish it all. Their butter chicken was some of the best Ive had, not just some plain chicken in tomato sauce, it was actually veey flavorful and the chicken was well marinated. They also have buffet on weekends which I will be coming back to try. Definitely recommend! read more

Bay Leaf Osprey - BUTTER MASALA Chicken Thali - Indian Near Me - Osprey, Florida

THIS PLACE IS AMAZING GOOD!! This was our first visit after passing by this place, often. The service was great. The place was very clean. Nice ambiance. I had the Lamb Vindaloo and my mother had the Madras Masala curry with lamb. We also had Peshwari Naan and some spring rolls. Everything was cooked perfectly! If we could give more that 5 stars we would. This place just opened in January. The restaurant was empty when we walked in because it was around 5:30. Things started to pick up by 6:30pm. There were many takeout orders. But this place is really great for dine-in and more people need to know about this spot ... headed by Indian chef Ravi K. read more

Bay Leaf Indian restaurant - What a fabulous experience. Always loved ordering and take out but never experienced the restaurant - glad we did. Ambiance is pleasant, spacious and clean. Large booths and tables. Loved the Indian music in the back ground. Amazing flavors; we were a table of 6, we all ordered different stews with variety of sauces, Tandoor chicken, etc... we were all impressed. There is a great selection of Gluten free & vegan, along with quality service. Professional and attentive staff. Looking forward to returning many many more times...Highly recommend:) read more

First visit, won't be my last. 3 meals from mild to spicy. Food was outstanding. Flavors were so very good. Our server , Vinny, was friendly,great sense of humor, very attentive. . Others stopped to check on food and service. Highly recommend you try this relatively new place. read more

I almost don't want to say how great this place is or it'll be hard to get into . For years we have been going to the Indian Restaurant in Bird Bay plaza , Venice . In fact went there over the last weekend. It's always so crowded , seats are close to each other ,no booths to sit in . Sure the food is good , but service lacks on most visits , don't have a smile on their faces and almost never ask you how your meal is. So I go to my nail girl and she tells me about this amazing restaurant called Bayleaf Osprey. I've passed almost every day. Well we finally went this evening . I'm gonna share the secret . This place is fantastic. Greeted right away . Seating is spacious , tables round table style fir large groups . Plenty of booths and space . Very best, clean and tidy. Service is excellent. Had the Cauliflower Manchurian. The difference between Bay Leaf and the other restaurant. Your not just eating a plate of fried cauliflower. This has presentation , cabbage, cauliflower is in nice bite size pieces and fresh crisp peppers and onions . We got everything medium heat . Was perfect . Their menu is very thorough. Explaining the sauces and spice level. Lots of vegan veggie options . Great assortment of meats. Lamb, goat . Chicken , beef n tofu salmon and other seafoods . We got butter chicken Masala and coconut curry chicken Masala. Each comes with its own bowl of rice . I recommend getting a few appetizers and sharing one entree, because it's more than enough for two . We did each get our own so we could share and have leftovers for lunch . We also got garlic naan bread which was perfect for dipping into the sauces . Some of the best restaurants are in these strip malls. It's easy to pass by . I have no doubt word of mouth will keep this restaurant very busy . read more

Food was delicious and complex, reasonably priced, and the service fantastic. Worth seeking out

Great service even better food can't wait to dine there again. Chicken tandoori was the best.

Food was good for the majority of our party, but others were hesitant, fearing curry and/or heat. For curry, you choose your protein (lamb, beef, veg, tofu, fish, goat--yes goat. So you know this place is authentic. ) and type of curry dish: masala, butter, bindaloo, jalfrezi, nirvana. Red peppers indicate heat level and we were asked if we wanted ours mild, spicy, or hot--even if there were no peppers on the menu. Good call. For the spice averse, order tandori items or even lamb chops but our friends didn't order tandori and didn't like the lamb chops. Guess Indian cuisine is not to their liking, which is OK. I give them credit for trying. For me, I'll be back. As for the wine, we ordered the more expensive Pinot noir. Awful! Switched to Merlot. Better. Much better. I like this place. Good for groups. read more

Wonderful lunch, pleasant staff, beautiful room. And they serve TOFU!!! Which was fantastic and a real treat.

We stopped into this newly acquired previously a breakfast place on a Sunday around 1 pm. It was fairly full. Largely with India people who were catching up and enjoying the food. No one was at the door- but someone said- find a table- and so we did! Asked for a menu- but was told it was a buffet, unless we preferred a menu. So we were game and decided to try the buffet. The food offerings were not in warmers but in a pan. A nice selection- but haphazardly arranged- rice in the middle- sauces first, naan next? But we continued - the food itself ranged from good- to very good, and not so good dessert! But we didn't come from dessert. We were not directed in anyway, nor told the price. Which was $25.00 each.(no drink). I think next time I would order off the menu, just for the way the buffet food was offered- and not very warm. But I will go again. It was tasty! read more

The only Indian cuisine I've found in the Sarasota area that is ACTUALLY spicy when you request spicy. I like when it makes you cry/burns your lips, and they're able to make that happen if you want. I can't wait to dine in there so it's fresh right off the oven. I've only ever ordered via ubereats. It's been 50000 stars every time I order from them. So if you like good Indian - GO HERE TRUST ME! read more

PLEASE please stay ! There have been 2 restaurants in that location since I've lived here but you know what they say: 3rd time's a charm. Dinner was delightful & delicious; our server was charming, knowledgable & informative, plus patient with my many questions. Sadly I forgot to take a picture - I was too hungry & dove right in. I had coconut masala with vegetables, served with rice & of course I ordered Naan. Nice presentation, good portion & so flavorful. Definitely will be on my 'need to return soon' list. There is no weekend buffet but there is a lunch special. Easy to find, plenty of parking, & decor is clean, fresh, & comfy. I can't wait to go back. read more

Tasty food. Traditional Indian food. Well priced and good proportions. Nice restaurant lots of room to sit. read more

Spectacular Indian food a mile from our home in Osprey. Delicious curries and Nan breads to dink up all the sauces. Seafood and vegetables were great! Look forward to returning soon! read more

Food is excellent. Fresh colorful tasty. Service is excellent our waiter Sajin was very attentive, professional, polite, pleasant and he made our visit so enjoyable. First time here... we live in North Port but will come back here many times. It's worth the drive. Much success to this restaurant in the future. Oh bathrooms very clean. read more

Wowwww!!! We go to Indian restaurants every place we travel. We put this restaurant up at the top only with one other restaurant that we went to in New Zealand. We ordered 3 different curries: Saag (spinach dip with chicken), Butter chicken masala, and the Mango coconut curry. All 3 dishes were full of flavor. The prices were fair. This place is definitely worth returning to and spending money on. I one hundred percent recommend. We will absolutely come back the next time we are on the west coast of Florida. If you are looking for authentic Indian cuisine, and you're looking for flavor, this is the spot to come. read more

I had take out from here, Chicken Curry, and it was the worse I have ever had. I asked for medium spicy and it was below mild. It was not tasty and it was a waste of my money. I will never go there again. read more

If you love Indian food, this is the place to go. Went there with friends last night. After sharing some spring rolls for an appetizer, we had the tandoori chicken, chicken, tiki masala, and lamb saag. All foods were served with white rice. It was excellent all around. I also noticed that the place is getting busier. It's being discovered. I also offer takeout. read more

No air conditioner, hot and humid. Poor service- food came so late.. water was served after appetizer. Could not enjoy food in sweat.

Consistently awesome. We get the saag paneer, kadai eggplant, butter chicken, mango chutney and onion naan. It is all delicious. We love Indian food and we're thrilled that Bay Leaf opened in Osprey. If you're craving excellent Indian food, this is the place. read more

This place is friendly & clean. The food was hot, plentiful, and tasty. Our server was kind & helpful. We will be back

Delicious tasty traditional Indian flavors. We love their vegan options. We had the madras masala and the saag both super flavorful and the basmati is so fluffy-how rice should be cooked.. Wish it had more Indian decor and maybe more wine by the glass options. Service was friendly and pleasant. read more

Excellent food. Vegan/vegetarian options. Attentive service and relaxed atmosphere. Will be coming back!