Bar Liberty was our last dinner in Melbourne, and we showed up a bit early as our flight was in the evening, and we didn't want to cut it too close on timing. Even though our original reservation was later, we walked in as soon as it opened at 5 PM, and we were able to get seated right away, with the caveat that we needed to be done by 7 PM given the existing reservations. The entrance of Bar Liberty can be easy to miss - as well as the shop itself; the sign on Johnston has a graffiti-styled 'LIBERTY' scrawled over a sign denoting the location of a taqueria, and the actual entrance is on the side road across from a gorgeous graffiti mural. Once you step in, this wine bar has a bit of a feel of a diner mixed in with a bar. It's a little retro chic, which is sort of how I felt about a lot of places while we wandered through Fitzroy, but I like the unpretentious nature of the spot, and I did like the old-fashioned sign that had various inspirations for the restaurant listed one by one (nice to recognize some American influences on it). Service was good; we went with the tasting menu, but the dishes were brought out at a nice pace that balanced enjoying the meal with our need to vacate the table at a certain time. There's a good selection of wines, but we stuck with individual drinks, and I do have to say my cocktails were quite delicious, as well as being memorable for how they were served - the mixing was done and bottled into a small jar, which was then poured in the glass at the table. I suppose that's a very precise way to ensure the drinks come out as they should!
One can order a la carte here if desired, but we ended up going with the tasting menu (chef's choice), as there were plenty of things that looked good, and we decided to pass the buck on making the hard choices. That said, of the 6-7 courses we got, I don't think there's one I can say that I did not enjoy wholeheartedly. The mussel dip on a very thin potato chip was a nice, relatively light way to start out, and the sourdough bread served to share with the table was quite hearty and very well-prepared. Next up were two tartares - a very delicious fresh trout tartare served with a generous topping of snap peas on top; overall, this was a very fresh and fulfilling dish that is one of the best seafood tartares I've had. The beef tartare was also quite good, and it is one of the few spots we have been to that also gave the beef a light sear on one side, giving it a bit of the crispiness (and appearance) you would find on a burger. Definitely unique, and if anything, cooking it a bit brings out a little bit more of the flavor as well. The pasta was a cacio e pepe; I really enjoyed the pasta preparation - properly al dente - and I enjoyed the generous loads of freshly cracked black pepper, but the salt could have been dialed back a smidge. Still quite good nonetheless, particularly for a spot not professing to be focused primarily on Italian cuisine. The main was the excellent flank steak, which was cooked to perfection - each slice of steak basically shredded itself - and the fried potatoes it came with were fried just the right amount, and the mayo gave it a bit more of flavorful (if fatty) finish without being too dense. The meal closed out with the yogurt ice cream and watermelon granita, with the latter being presented very much like the tartares earlier in the meal - so underneath the ice cream. A nice, summery way to close out dinner.
I really enjoyed the ambiance of Bar Liberty, but I also enjoyed the excellence and casualness of the food that was served here. At A$60 per person, I definitely felt like we got a bargain given how good the food was (although we made it up on the drinks a little - the cocktails aren't that cheap). Nonetheless, on a relative basis, this was definitely the best dinner we had in Melbourne, and I wouldn't hesitate to come back and visit next time I am around this part of the world. read more