Ordered a 4-bone Prime Rib for Christmas. They separated the bones and trussed it together!! We…read morehave never cooked one before and were very excited!! This was a Choice cut and came out delicious!! Thanks guys!! You made this a great experience!!

We got catering trays for a graduation party: brisket, potato salad, coleslaw, baked beans,…read moreassorted individual bags of chips, and a vegetable tray. So delicious, great service. There were so many wonderful looking things in the shop-my only sadness is discovering this place as my kid is graduating and leaving Bloomington!

Wow! What an excellent stop!…read more On the advice of a friend, we stopped by to pick up some bacon. (Which they smoke themselves, and which is excellent.) Little did we know that this was a full-fledged butcher and lunch stand. So, after picking up twice as much bacon as we planned to, as well as a particularly piggish selection of sausage, we ordered a burger and some pulled pork and ate lunch right out on their porch! And then, when we got home, we smoked the sausage. Yum! Scobee's is now our go-to butcher -- and not a bad place to stop for lunch, either! (Note: They're on the South-West corner of the intersection of US-231 and US-36, just about 7 miles north of Greencastle. A bit hard to spot from the street, but they're right behind all the Amish construction stuff.)

They called us last minute to have us bring him in 6 days earlier than we'd scheduled. When called…read moreto let us know our meat was ready to pick up, we told them it would be Friday when we could get there and we were told that was fine. When I showed up Friday to pick up meat, nobody was there for the day as they apparently took off last minute to go to the festival! They did not offer anything to compensate for my wasted time and fuel. Plus, we received 15% less meat than we should have and they added fees that were not disclosed up front! Drive the extra 30+ minutes to GO ELSEWHERE! That way you won't waste your precious time and money, will get all your meat, and won't get fees snuck into your bill!

Service & selection is always top-notch! Old fashioned butcher shop combined with a cheese & meat…read moredeli case. They don't really make any sandwiches but can cut & slice meats to order and have some of the best prepped meatballs and frozen meats around. Just get back the Bison Italian Sausages, please! Next time you are prepping for a grill session I highly recommend Kincaid's, particularly the SoBro location on Illinois Street in the heart of Butler-Tarkington! Cheese & proteins awaits!

I don't know what they put in the marinade for their flank steak but I think it might be crack…read more That stuff is absolutely delicious. We generally get one every other week or so. Don't need to season it out it on the hot grill for a few minutes each side, slice and serve. The potatoes in the picture came from there too because I was running late and didn't have time to walk across the street. One of our favorite local businesses to support.

Employees are knowledgeable and helpful when making selections! Good product. Good location!read more

Always excellent! We're bought steaks many times & the quality never disappoints. This weekend…read moreit's ground chuck for burgers on the grill. Fantastic!

This is long -but it is that special. Please help me spread the word…read more This place is so understated and deceiving -in a good way! It looks like a meat packing house from the out-side. But when you step in, it's a homage to the art of meat preparation. The owner Steve is a gem. You can tell this is not only a quality business but also a passion project that he has continued from his father. My daughter is a recent Purdue graduate from '25 class. We are not local, but from NJ. She found this place as part of a local walk and stopped by to pick up a gift certificate to give as a thank you gift.. She noticed they do catering- and thank goodness!. We rented an Airbnb for her graduation so family can stay with us and had planned to have a caterer. But the caterer I booked 4 months prior to graduation cancelled on me one week prior to the event! I was left high and dry. My daughter remembered that Beutlers caters! Steve literally saved us when all others could not or would not. He was not only empathetic to our situation, but he made sure we had an amazing feast and thought of everything to ensure we had the celebration we envisioned. The food was so incredibly good. My family was raving about it all weekend long. Truly THE best pulled Pork and Beef brisket we've ever had. And for a family that doesn't even like beans, they couldn't stop eating it! So good, it should be illegal. We had leftovers for days. Best of all, Steve told me he prepped all the food himself. His TLC was evident. He made sure we had everything needed, even lovely serving baskets and lighters for sternos! My only regret is that my daughter graduated, and I have no known future opportunities to call on Steve again to work his magic. I hope this review gains traction. I'm on a mission to ensure that word gets out about this rare gem of a place and the incredible owner behind it all, Steve Beutler. Heartfelt thank you Steve.

Awesome service. Really nice people. Don't forget the cookies. From liver to steaks. Fat, bones…read moreand tenderloins. Lots of yummy meat must haves. Feed you and your pets. I love the decor also. Tin shed vibes.

Moody Butcher is a really clean and organized store with good quality products. The atmosphere…read morefeels upscale and well put together. However, it's definitely on the expensive side. Great for specialty items or occasional shopping, but probably not the most practical place for one person to shop weekly on a budget

Just happened to be driving by and we decided to stop in. Definitely a great idea because this…read moreplace is really nice! Lots of great sauces and snack charcuterie board type items. Really had such a great selection. The working area was very clean and organized. Friendly staff. Margaret was very nice and ready to help us offering in case we had questions. We live on other side of Indy but definitely coming back for other items in the future.

Bought a prime rib for our annual Christmas Eve dinner. It was excellent! Great flavor and really…read moretender. Great communication from them. They called to let me know it was ready and waited on us promptly when we picked it up. Definitely recommend!

Family-owned and family-run butchers have become a rarity in the age of corporate mega stores and…read morefactory meat production. If you are looking for first-rate quality, fresh from the farm cuts, personal service and very reasonable prices, Allen's campt be beat.

Knowledgeable staff alongside great product.D.n.R market is My go to for a great steak.read more

Honestly, one star is too many! Placed an order, confirmed the order but on the agreed upon day of…read morepick-up, the order wasn't there. They said it would be in three days later, which is after our party. They were rude and gave no F's that they didn't have our order. They said they didn't need our business instead of simply owning their mistake and offering suggestions or alternatives. So chaotic and unprofessional.

Been coming here since they opened. Never had anything that was not exceptional - quality is…read morealways amazing. Steaks are the best I've ever bought anywhere, period. Always prime quality. Pork and chicken are phenomenal too.

Received meat in november 2025. I have tried every cut and am disappointed. Hamburger is horrific…read moreeith large chunks of ?gristle. Steaks are tough. Was promised certain cuts and when picked up was informed that the person who bought the bigger part of cow wanted the better cuts. Hello, i paid for my meats too!! The owner is very personable and likeable but the meat is not very good. I really wanted to like this but....

I don't typically visit a butcher, and to be honest, they can be a little overwhelming if you're…read morenot familiar with the setup/process. The staff was very patient with me, helping me find what I was looking for and even making some suggestions. They had a great selection of quality meats and had a super cute little section of local goodies. They even had a customer appreciation charcuterie set up. I had a coupon so the price wasn't crazy but without it, I would definitely say they are on the high end. Like I said, I don't usually visit butcher shops so that might be pretty standard. If I find myself in need of a really nice cut of meat or something I can't find elsewhere, I'll definitely be back to Moodys!

Another bad experience with Moodys in Fishers. Walked in the Sunday before Christmas and ordered…read moresix ribeye cap steaks to be picked up at noon on Christmas Eve - a Wednesday (three days after Sunday). When I went in at 1 pm on Christmas Eve... they informed me they expected me to pick up the day before and had to throw away the meat "because the meat was three days old." If they had texted or called on Tuesday I would have picked it up. Won't shop there again.