Best cheese pull I've ever experienced in my life and I'm from Buffalo NY! Bri was our server. We have had her both times we have went(party of 6, 3 kids and one of them has ASD). She is ALWAYS so kind and accommodating! We hadn't been there for a couple weeks and she remembered us! I HIGHLY recommend adding Ricotta to your pizza, and trying their beer nuggets! We are making this our weekly family dinner spot! (Also, they have TONS of deals and specials!!!) read more

Local spot cooking up fresh Chicago style pizza and classic entrees. Salad and garlic bread included with entree at an extremely reasonable price. Conveniently located in Target plaza, plenty of parking and with about 15 tables inside. This place is in a plaza strip doesn't look like much outside but warm and inviting inside. Huge takeout business too. Staff is friendly and understaffed so be patient. One server when we got there handling six tables inside, one table outside plus answering the phones taking takeout orders, plus checking those takeouts at the register. I was feeling sorry for her and almost wanted to help out when one of the cooks came out to help the server fill her drink orders. All this and it was only 4:00 pm on the day before Christmas. Server was super friendly, experienced and calm. Clearly a seasoned veteran who knew being kind, calm, and focused was the key. Customers were all patient and plenty of thanks were heard throughout the dining room. When the huge pies came out, or the dishes were served, I clearly understood why this spot is a gem and all the locals know it. I actually got enough leftovers for another full meal! The appetizers are discounted during Happy Hour. The marinara is delicious. The mozzarella entree is fresh, piping hot and gooey just the way you want it. The Happy Hour buy one get one drinks are outstanding, 3 to 6 pm daily. The wine pour is generous and the wide beer selection is iced cold. No need for a beer glass. We loved it and completely understand the perfect Yelp scores. Saved this spot for our future visits in the area. read more

Baked - House salad and what's left of our Fried Mozzarella! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Everything was good, but beware they base tip on the total after tax instead of subtotal. In addition, the charge a fee to use a card, including debit card. read more

I find myself to be difficult to get five stars, I don't give out as many as 4, and luckily more than the bottom 3 combined. But enough about me, this is about our trip to Baked in The Forum in Fort Myers. We will trade to try good pizza and a 26 minute drive is worth the shot to find what looked like something good. So this Friday, we called in an order. Friendly phone staff, had me add more to my pizzas because, it's included. We got a thin crust, nice crispy bottom and edge, sauce was really good, thick, you can taste garlic and olive oil and a nice cheese blend. the pan was a deep dish with a regular pizza not a gargantuan amount of cheese hiding under the sauce. Look, I am sure their deep dish is good, but we tried the pan, and it seems different. Great dough (I think it's a different dough from the thin, but that would be crazy. both loaded with toppings, got home still hot, crispy, if this pizza reheats well, its one to beat. read more

Baked - Thin crust, sausage, meatball and onion - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

If you want good Italian food that won't break your budget then this is your place. They have a special running daily - their Happy Hour is well worth the price and surprisingly they have a rather large craft beer selection. The servers are hopping back and forth with food and drinks so you won't be left hungry or thirsty. The selection of dishes is wide from pasta dishes to appetizers, sandwiches and more!! The family casual atmosphere brings in all sorts of folks to this location - they have a pretty steady take out as well. But the main reason to visit here is the amount of food you get for the money. I ordered the Eggplant Parmigiana with Penne pasta and their meat sauce which all I can say is the meat sauce stands on its own as a dish!! There were chunks of meatballs and sausage with a not too heavy sauce done very well and tasty. Whatever you are craving Italian wise you will find here - but don't expect or be disappointed if you don't eat everything on your plate because the leftovers are the what you will be having afterwards that heats up well!! For a nice low key casual dining experience with food you will enjoy while there and then later at home that won't burn through your wallet this is your go to place!!! read more

Baked - Beer Wall - Be sure to ask server about different selections as not all are on the menu - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Decent pie with really good ingredients, but a little too thick a crust for me. Tasty though...

Food is fresh;only premium ingredients Portions are more than enough for 2 people A small house or Cesar salad is generous enough for people and then some Pizza crusts are amazing Deep and Pans have a "high-rise condo crust" that keep all customers coming back; some since the soft opening 7 years ago ! Everything offered on the menu is equally as delicious and generously portioned Presentation will make you want to take a photo ! read more

See all

Great food. We each ordered a different deep dish pizza as we wanted plenty left over. We had the beer nuggets which are deep fried but so, so tasty! Service was good. The name recently changed to Baked. read more

Baked - Front of the restaurant. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Our favorite pizza. Probably not for everyone. We get the deep dish which has lots of tomato sauce and cheese and is incredibly heavy. The taste is to die for! We love it! read more

It is okay. Nothing special. Dough is bland. I do believe use good quality ingredients though. Definitely the best chicago style deep dish i have had in this area read more

This place is now under a new name. Baked a Chicago pizzeria. Check out my review under Baked. It is still the same place and menu just new name. read more

Baked - Entrance - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Glad we tried Buddy's out since true Chicago cooking locally has become limited in the past few years. We had a thin crust sausage pizza which was perfectly crispy, garlic bread, beers, soda & enjoyed an Italian beef with fries. Unfortunately did not enjoy the fries it might be time to change out the oil, but this will not deter us from returning. Average seating, service good and not a long wait for food to get to table. read more

Third time here. Something changed...my pizza had almost no cheese they took it back and remade it and still very little cheese and VERY LITTLE toppings maybe two olives on a slice. Hubbys was good deep dish but the couple we were with ordered deep dish sausage and jalapeños and it came with no sausage! They brought out sausage to put on the top! Not sure if I'll go back now. I will say the beef sandwiches are awesome! read more

We are excited to have a Chicago Pizzeria in Fort Myers. We watched the installation of Buddyz sign in November and noticed a sign they will open on December 5, 2019. Went there a week later about 11:30 AM but it is not open. They are open only from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM until the kitchen staff are fully settle down with their operation. Went in today around 5:30 PM and the place is full with 2 or 3 waiting for their take-out order. That is a good sign! They did some renovation from the old Il Forno. Gone are booths and take-out counter. Now there are 5 huge TVs so you won't miss any sports actions! A heated cabinet for take-out order and cashier is by the front door now! A much better utilization of space than the old layout! The staff is incredibly friendly. Buddyz specialized with Chicago Pizza with good selection of salads, sandwiches, appetizers and pasta limited to spaghetti and Mostaccioli! There are wine and beers available! This is our first time here so we ordered local draft beer High 5 IPA and a thin crust 'The Mag Mile' pizza pie with sausage, green peppers, onion and mushrooms. The pie is perfectly baked with the right amount of cheese. My wife was eying the Italian Beef Sandwich on the next table and wanted for her next visit. Meanwhile I was checking if any table ordered any beer nuggets or toasted ravioli. Will be back for more and perhaps the deep dish pizza! read more

See all

Good pizza. Service was ok server was knowledgeable with the menu. Place was clean and the prices were excellent super reasonable. read more

See all

Deep Dish pizza was quite good, in a laid back atmosphere. The half off appetizer happy hour is a great deal, and you can eat a whole meal of different varieties of deep fried cheese and carbs for not too much money. On the afternoon we went for happy hour, the temperature had dipped below 70 degrees earlier, so god for forbid anyone would want to be outside in such harrowing weather, so we had to ask to be able to sit outside. The manager was kind enough to set up a table for us though. read more

Outstanding !! We are originally from Chicago and our search is finally over. We have lived in Fort Myers for 8yr and your pizza is excellent We will be back Do you also televise the Bears games? read more

Smaller spot with some outdoor seating near The Forum. Ordered a Chicago deep dish pizza (10 inch) and also had truffle fries as an app. Good and filling! Definitely plan to return. This was my first time have Chicago deep dish, so I didn't have much to compare it to. My partner said it was "very close to" what he's had in Chicago. Check it out if you're in the area and craving some pizza! read more

Baked - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

They have a really good online ordering system. Everything was ready on time, pick up was smooth, nice employees. The pizza: (this was my first time having Chicago style pizza) Sears Tower Chicago Style: I felt sick after eating 2 slices. This is an incredibly dense, physically heavy culinary endeavor. The problem with the thick and thin crust pizza is the toppings would not stick to the crust, possibly because of the condensation from being in the box. I was expecting more sauce less bread. I wish I enjoyed this more it looked so good! Mag Mile thin crust: the crust at Buddyz definitely has a different taste to it unlike most pizzas, kind of more salty. I could see some people being a fan of it but I was not. We experienced this pizza as average with good toppings and no stomach problems read more

So youz wanna Chicago pizza in Florida?? Look NO further! Excellent pie! Superb calamari! GREAT service! After we ate we waited for the rain to stop (not) and one of the 'Buddyz' (bossman) came by and chatted. This is the first time in SW Florida this has happened...this guy KNOWS. Very pleasant! ( a lot more pleasant than the RUDE customers behind us trying to play lord n master over the poor 16 yr old waitress...that kinda rude is just sooo out of line) Treat yourself....you deserve a GREAT pie and some GREAT appetizers! (1/2 off 3-5 except the calamari) read more

Baked - Sears Tower deep dish. My husband is contemplating the attack plan. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

My first visit to this Chicago deep dish pizza place today for lunch. I've never had Chicago-style pizza before so I didn't know what to expect. It was just ok for me. Since this was a first for me, I have nothing to compare it to, but just mediocre. read more

Baked - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Excellent pizza made by Max. He put his all into his work. It shows when he makes pizza. Ever time I come in the restaurant manager Henry alway greets me. Great hospitality!! Max make me pizza just the way I like and always remember me. Great staff highly recommend eating here. The new name is Chicago Baked delicious food the Chicago Way!!! read more

Three people in our party all with different orders: chicken parm sandwich, meatball sandwich & Italian beef. Everyone agreed that their food was good, even as leftovers the following day it still tasted good. The bread that was used for the sandwiches was not as thick and tough as most places so that was a pleasant surprise. We will definitely keep this on our list to revisit next time we are in the area! read more

Highly recommended and met my expectations as I had a craving. Meets up to the true Chicago deep dish pizza standard. This is a very dense pizza and not for someone who is calorie counting. Very filling. The highly recommend this restaurant. I was not a fan of the calamari, otherwise definitely a restaurant I would return to. read more

Baked - Front of Buddyz - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Was promptly greeted an seated. Jose my server made his recommendation of the roast beef with mozzarella cheese sandwich. Looking at the menu I knew he wasn't stacking the ticket. The sandwich was great the bear was cold and the service exceptional. Quick easy delicious a five star win! read more

Baked - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

The derp dish pizza is the best we've ever had. The check out process is a little weird. Couldn't make proper change. It's better to pay with a card. I can't say enough about the pizza and the friendliness of the employees. Great place read more

Baked - The best pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Ordered the 10"deep dish water tower and 10" thin crust the loop. Fresh ingredients. Lots of garlic for the Loop. Very tasty. Loved the sauce for the deep dish good consistency and it covered for whole pizza. Friendly staff. We will be back! read more

See all

Awesome food! We are from Chicago and their food is just like home to us! Pizza is so good, we order once a week. LOL! We just tried their sandwiches for the first time and again, they knocked it out of the park!! read more

Baked - Meatball sandwich with fries and Italian beef with onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

I just moved to the area and thought I would try this place. Great food and great environment. I asked for recommendations and our server Ki gave us nothing but excellent choices. She described everything perfectly. We will be visiting every week now and asking for her she was an awesome server. read more

Worst experience I have ever had with a restaurant. I Placed a delivery order on Door Dash. The order state pending confirmation for 20 minutes. After the wait I called the restaurant to ask if they were still accepting orders to find my self listening to two men unable to figure out how to use the phone, who ultimately hung up minutes later. Frustrated with the experience, I called back to be greeted by a rude woman who continued to cut me off stating they did not accept delivery orders via door dash. While I tried to explain they may be the victims of a scam, I was interrupted once more with a blatant "WE ARE NOT ON DOORDASH" and then once again hung up on. I sought to simply order a pizza which eventually lead to a rather kind act of informing them of a scam, only to be treated with absolute disrespect. The food may be good (I wouldn't know). But I can say one thing, this company does not care about their customers. read more

This is a 2 part review. Plain and simple the deep dish pizza and thin crust are delicious. You must try this place. You will not be let down. I cannot however say the same thing about their customer service. I ordered delivery and not only did they get my order wrong, they made me pay for my replacement. This is negligable and abhorrent behavior from any establishment in my opinion. Not to mention the delivery driver literally ran off ignoring my concerns. With that in mind, do not bother ordering delivery from them. Play it safe and hold them accountable in person for their incompetence. read more

2nd time ordering & we are completely hooked!!! There's enough food for a few meals. We have no need to look any further for our new pizza place!! AMAZING & I would give it 20 stars if I could read more

See all

Deep pan Pizza was absolutely delicious and even though they were crowded we got seated right away. We also tried the appetizer of Mussels which were also great loved the s read more

Very happy with this place. Ordered the Sears Tower 14" Deep Dish to go. It was a 30 minute pickup time which is great for a deep dish pizza. The pizza was absolutely delicious. I think it stands up to other deep dish places in Chicago. Would 100% recommend. read more

Baked - Sears Tower 14" Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

So the good part is that the food is great. The service is also awesome. Two people to serve a full restaurant and they were working hard. People were being super impatient both in house and for takeout. Downright rude. I get it, they were backed up and understaffed. That being said, they were hustling and doing their best to keep up. Maybe bring retired it's hard to remember a time when you worked so lighten up. The food was hot ,fresh and priced right. We waited about 45 minutes for pizza which was a long time but everyone was trying. Maybe an off night? read more

Buddy is a small Chicago-themed pizza place. They have excellent food, especially the deep dish. Service was a little slow and they could use more seating, however, it's small so be prepared for a wait on a weekend. read more

Solid pizza. It's my go-to when wanting Chicago style in Fort Myers. Pretty good effort on some of the Chicago-style sandwiches too.

Great service and pizza is fantastic. I've been 2 times now and everyone has had great recommendations.

Traveling for work and tried this place on a whim. The staff was lovely, the portion sizes huge and the outdoor seating very pleasant. By far my fave was the Grant Park Pizza - excellent flavor. read more

See all

Best pizza in the area! They have thin crust as well as Chicago style and pan pizza. The toppings are fresh and delicious. Trust me, it's worth the drive from Babcock Ranch in lieu of the competition. Only a 15-minute drive. Service was fast and friendly!! read more