1-Star Review - Dishonest Sales Practices at Auto Select I purchased a used car from Auto Select in early February 2026, and the experience has been extremely disappointing. The salesperson, Steve, assured me the vehicle had a clean Carfax and no accident history. That was completely false. After noticing some issues once the car was cleaned, I took it to my local body shop. They immediately pointed out signs of previous damage on the rear side fender, passenger door, and front right fender. The repairs were clearly done privately and never claimed, which explains why nothing appeared on the Carfax. Once I looked closer, the problems were obvious: * Uneven paint * Rust at the bottom of the door * Missing clips on the front fender There is no way the dealership didn't know about this. When I confronted Steve, he gave me the typical runaround and avoided taking any responsibility. I strongly recommend avoiding Auto Select, or at the very least, having any vehicle inspected by both a mechanic and a body shop before buying. This dealership is not transparent, and my experience shows they are willing to mislead customers. read more

Bought a 2011 BMW 3 Series from these guys couple of weeks ago. Dealt with Justin there. Amazing experience, Justin was very straight forward and open to all the questions I asked regarding the car I was interested in. I requested to get the car inspected by Parkview BMW and they did not hesitate to get that done. Overall great experience and very happy with my purchase. read more

Auto Select - 2011 BMW 3 Series at Auto Select. - Car Dealers Near Me - Scarborough, Ontario

This guy STEVE sold me a car for 13k I paid up in full like a idiot. Sold me a used veloster WITH A CLEAN CAR PROOF. well done Steve you guys are masters of selling cars that have been in accidents. Looks like I'm not the first one for you. I put my faith and life savings in auto select only to have a car that has 100% in fact been in a accident. Please, I hope I can help others. BEWARE. No one cares you grew up in the same town as anyone famous. Bravo. Sleep well STEVE. read more

Unfortunately, I was short on time and bought my car here without carefully researching. I told them I'm living in the states and I had a day or two to decide. ( big mistake) The car had something like 18km so I thought it would be reliable. They also said it was inspected by a parkview bmw and it had a clean accident record and they even showed me some papers indicating no accident history(most likely fake) I even took it to the parkview bmw and someone there confirmed that it was legit. (probably their friend) I'm pretty sure they had some inside scam deal going on. As soon as I got back to the U.S, I started having issues with engine noise, and my windshield wiper rain sensor was malfunctioning and wipers bouncing and knocking while in use. I went to my local bmw dealer in Cherry Hill NJ and they said I had to get my engine head replaced, piston rings, and connecting rods replaced. It was like a 8-9 USD to fix!. I told them this was a new car with a clean accident history and they said the wind shield was previously broken and replaced incorrectly saying it was in an accident. They showed me the car's logo missing on the windshield indicating it was aftermarket, and the chassis being slightly off. These guys not only lied to me, but I got completely robbed on my financing contract. They quoted me a much high APR then my bank did and on top of that I somehow ended up paying 60% more than the original quoted price for the vehicle. Also they used a money loaner that went by the name TD, but it wasn't TDBank because the actual tdbank had no record of my financing. All together, I ended losing more than a 110k to finance and fix this lemon. Fortunately I found you on Yelp, and I can finally tell somebody about this, even though it is so many years later. I hope this review saves a lot of people's money! If any lawyers see this please contact me. read more

DON'T EVER BUY A CAR FROM AUTO SELECT!! I went through 2 weeks of complete BS and anxiety as a result of a recent purchase of a 2015 Mercedes C300 that required more than $7000 in repairs (most of which were luckily covered under the remaining factory warranty) after I drove it off their lot - which they should have done prior to putting the car out on their lot - at Mercedes' expense - instead of passing on the aggravation to their customer!! Although they offered to look at the car and 'take care of it' when I expressed my concern with the issues I was having after driving off their lot, they were offering to take it only to their own places so 'they could have control over the repairs' - even though anything not covered under the remaining factory warranty was my problem to pay for. These guys were no different than the shady used car salesmen you see and hear about in the movies. Wanting nothing to do with these guys and their dealership after a few calls to them where I got a defensive attitude (post purchase) re: repairing my car, I decided to take matters into my own hands through a family member who works for Mercedes who fully inspected my car and made the necessary repairs to it. (My bad for trusting these guys and not having the car inspected PRIOR to actually purchasing it!) Not only did these guys lie to me about a number of things: 1. Extended Warranty from Mercedes - they were adamant that I could purchase one from Mercedes when I expressed concern over having to buy their 3rd party warranty they were selling. After making many calls to Mercedes as well as going through my family member who is a Mercedes employee, I found out that I was in fact NOT able to purchase a Mercedes extended warranty. How as a used car dealership business owner of 20+years do you not know this???? I even asked one of the brothers to call Mercedes and confirm for me that I could buy from there and I was told "I don't have time to call around". 2. The break parts they used to service the car as part of the safety check were after-market parts (confirmed by Mercedes) - even though they specifically told me twice that they weren't. I now have to deal with squeaking breaks until they wear out and have to be replaced again. 3. Tires - new (not the greatest) and I was told 4 of them were run flats. It turns out only 2 of them are. 4. I was told the car (stone chips, etc) would be touched up prior to me picking up the car. They weren't. I stood and watched one of the brothers touch everything up before I drove it off their lot - and even then they weren't done properly. Aside from all the BS that went along with this expensive purchase, the car was meticulous inside when I picked it up and even smelled like new (even though Mercedes had to replace the driver's seat bottom because the leather was splitting and also replaced the cheap velcro substitutes on the back seat pockets that Auto Select had installed). If you're in the market for a used luxury car (BMW, Mercedes, Lexus, etc), do yourself a favor and spend the extra few thousand dollars to buy a pre-owned certified vehicle directly from the actual dealership where you can buy their extended warranty for peace of mind!! Don't give these guys a penny of your hard-earned money for an overpriced used car!! Lesson learned the hard way. read more

As a former C-suite exec, am quite familiar with credit and lending models. With plenty of cash on hand for a healthy down payment yet a temporairly low FICO score, called this place to explore options for subprime financing on a new car deal. After looking at my credit report, Justin called back and proceeded to sarcastically lecture me about "how banks will see me" and more or less scolded me for having a low FICO at the moment. Then insisted they could not do a deal without a cosigner. Seriously? Thanks but no thanks Justin, some of us already know "how banks see us"...Why do they hold themselves out as able to work with "good, new or bad credit" if the approach is to bait and switch clients in to making -their- financing easier with a cosigner? If I wasn't looking for a dealer capable of placing a subprime contract would never have called them in the first place. I believe they have limited lending relationships and their reps are there to push you to do what is easiest for them, not the client. Thumbs down for deceptive advertising, and rude condesending sales rep. AVOID!!! read more

TERRIBLE. DO NOT GO HERE. First of all, I drove 1 hr from downtown Toronto in bumper to bumper traffic to get there before they closed.... On the phone it sounded like if I was going to be after 5 that I should just come another day. I have been car shopping for over 1 month and they had my top 2 cars. I was going to buy a vehicle, but that was not enough for them. I got there and really liked the cars but when I asked if I could do a test drive, it was first, which vehicle can i really afford, then it was can i guarantee to make a conditional offer before being allowed to test drive. This is an over 20K purchase and I have to guarantee to make an offer right after? I said I had to talk to my husband before I could make any deals...and i got "does you husband even know your here" WTF. What does it matter? If I liked the car I would have bought it the next day, I just needed to get home and talk about it. So i explained that I have been to many dealerships and actually did 2 other test drives that day with no hassle. I am OFFENDED that 1. I had to explain that i could afford the car, do they know that people stretch there budgets when they love something? 2. That the only way to get a test drive is to guarantee a offer right after. THIS IS crazy in my mind. Customer service at this place has to be the last thing on their mind. I would never buy a car at this place... go anywhere else and you'll get better service and wont leave feeling like shit. read more

I went in to see a Infiniti M37. I met with Justin and all was going well until the price neg. We came to a number which was fine, i was not set in buying as of yet but asked how he came to that number as i was trading in my car. He broke it down for me price+tax-car trade. I said that's not right, it should be price-trade in+tax. So if he's willing be shaddy right of the bat not sure what else he's hiding. I did not buy the car, Hopefully his co workers are not like this. read more