Friendly and courteous. Willing to appraise what you have. I found the experience to be trustworthy.

Demeaning customer service, staff attitude is bad, offers low prices for selling coins, melt value not coin collector value.

Very rude tall guy with glasses tried to have my silver appraised told me that he didn't have to look at it and was very rude about it wouldn't recommend this place at all read more

Great professional service. (Note: This is NOT your reality TV's pawn shop.) Archie's has been in the neighborhood forever and their business longevity speaks for itself. I've been a coin collector for decades and I trust Archie's to give me the straight. (Yes, they will test all metal for you upon request--I also double check content with home tests. YCNBTC) Although the wonderful (and often opinionated) Art, and (equally opinionated) Carl, have both left this mortal coil, the tradition continues. Honest and knowledgable. Good pricing. Trustworthy. Recently, Joel helped me with a purchase and he was great! read more

I couldn't be happier with the service and professionalism of the staff at Archie's. They are very honest and efficient. Working with staff is a learning experience. They patiently explain why each coin or piece of jewelry is priced as it is. They also have a metal identifier scanner that eliminates any valuation mistakes. I highly recommend Archie's. read more

Nice selection of lovely coins and metal at a fair price. And believe me I know what this stuff, silver and gold, goes for. A fun stop in the neighborhood to buy metal thats in very nice condition. Low key pressure and good service. The best coin shop Ive seen within easy driving distance. A very decent selection of various coinage. Small but a good overall selection of American and foreign rounds, coins, and gold. read more

I brag in some silver antique heirlooms and the guy "Joe" immediately became hostile and refused to even look at my items for some reason I still don't know definitely wouldn't recommend stopping into Archie's read more

My husband first went to this family-owned store when he was a child. Recently he was asked to handle the family's silverware - some being from his great-grandfather. He wanted to compare prices around Chicago, but it ended up that Archie's gave the most value, by giving nearly $1000 more than its competitors. I went with him for this transaction. The store is clean and well merchandised, and the staff is very nice. There is easy parking in back. We would do business with them again! Steve, the owner, took care of us. read more

I called to make an appointment to bring in some gold items for sale. The people there were acting stupid in background, yelling things about a gun. I thanked the phone clerk & hung up. The thought of being in there with some value able items to sell from a personal collection, & something untoward happening is cringe worthy. read more

great ppl to do business with, and their checks are good as gold. thank you Archie I would highly recommend.

I came to this place to sell some gold and silver jewelry. I had previously gone to a place closer to my home. I decided to try another place to compare. First when I walked in I was greeted very nicely. I gave them the same jewelry I brought the day before to the place by my house. I was offered $500 more than the other place. I was pretty shocked to hear the price difference. After I found out I realized they must be good for the client because I found out they have been in business for 67 years at the same location. I have decided it's worth the extra drive to go to a place I trust. read more

10/10 reccomend. These guys are fair and knowledgable regarding all coins and bars. This is the only place I will do business with in Chicago due to the relationship and trust I have with them when buying or selling and gold or silver. Go to Archie's for the best deals in town and ask for Joel. read more

Had a very pleasant visit to Archie's coins. Clean and bright interior, very friendly and professional staff. Scored some silver bullion coins at bargain prices. read more

I sold some coins today and had a very good experience with Joel. He answered all questions and gave me a fair price. I will be back!

Appears to be under new ownership or management. Unfortunately not very friendly which is not a good start. Older guy with cap doesn't even smile or acknowledge customers. Very strange and off putting. Make certain they tell you the weight of gold if you're selling it to them. read more

This place is a GREAT coin shop! If you are a veteran in coin collecting or just starting to learn the basics this place is a perfect exception to all. They gave me the run down on silver and investing and also taught me about key dates. In general highly trusted workers and management. I went in there knowing nothing, Anyone could of scammed me but instead they show you important things to look out for. They also pay the best prices on silver and gold of any place around me! Definitely check them out even if you know nothing about precious metals or coin collecting because you might find your new hobby like me! :) read more

Archies WAS the best. That is when Carl and Art ran the business. Sadly, they passed and so has the nice atmosphere. There are no decent coins made available to customers. This has been the case the last couple years. Current is not interested in buying numismatic coins when I make them available and relies on bullion and scrap. So sad. read more

Just picked up an great silver money clip with a beautiful 1922 silver dollar!! See photo. Also got some more coins and a silver frog. Love this place!!! read more

See all

Honest and competitive that is all you can ask for in this business. Brought in a bag of my clients coin collection, all silver no key dates. The gent behind the counter counted the coins, his tally came out the same as mine. They don't pay spot price that is how they make their money, but if you need to sell quickly you can't do any better. They also have very good prices on Wheat pennies and Buffalo nickels. Many of the scummy pawn shops won't touch these. read more

One of my most fond memories growing up was going to Archie's with my grandpa. Having started a coin collection with my grandpa at a young age, it was only inevitable that at some point we'd visit a coin store to look at all the old coins and maybe if I was lucky enough, get to buy one. Normally, my coins came from my grandpa's old jars of change he had saved for years, and all I had to do was sort through them and find the keepers, but once I received the Whitman folders for pennies for Christmas one year, it became clear that I needed a 1909 VDB (obtaining the S-VDB was out of the question even to this day!). This was back in 1992 or 93, and I remember the place being small, smelling of "old" (gotta love that), and being run by a very friendly man who happily assisted my grandpa and myself in our purchase of my first 1909-VDB. I hadn't been there in years, so about two years ago I stopped by for old times' sake. After being buzzed in, I was immediately taken aback at how much this little place had changed. It seemed obvious this place had turned into another one of those "Cash for Gold" places once they realized they couldn't make money off selling non-commodities like old pennies and stamps anymore. The only coins they had in the display case were gold coins or mint/commemorative big silver. They carried a decent selection of gold jewelry as well. There was a group of about 5 or 6 older men sitting around at a table toward the back of the store talking about the gold market, cheap customers, and overall speaking like sailors. When they saw me browsing, they all gave me the stink-eye. I didn't look like a client apparently, since no one came to ask if I needed anything. Eventually I asked if they carried coin flips and one man grudgingly got up and wallowed over to where he keeps his coin flips and tossed them on the counter. I ended up buying some, and then I returned about a year later and bought some more. That time, the place was full of shady-looking individuals trying to pawn off some jewelry to an employee. I rate this place a 2, for the readily available coin flips, and for the fact that they DO carry some antiques, albeit expensive. That's proof they're not just in it for the gold and silver, they still have a soft spot for old toy trucks and such. It is at least fun to look at. However, I do miss the old days where you'd walk in to such a store and be mesmerized by all the coins you wish you could have but could never afford (me as a kid). Though, I understand the situation and realize they would have never stayed in business in such a manner. By the way, I still have that '09 VDB. read more

DO NOT GO HERE, NOTHING BUT CROOKS! I wish I could give Archie's 0 stars, but I'll have to settle with 1 for this horrible place. I have been to most of the coin shops around the Chicagoland area purchasing gold and silver (bars and 90%) and this is by far the most UNTRUSTWORTHY shop! I went there the first time to purchase 1/2 oz of gold and $40 face of 90% silver (about $2000 total purchase) and I ended up getting shorted $.50 on the junk silver (roughly $15). They claimed the 1964 Kennedy rolls they gave me were unopened, but I noticed one of the rolls was a little lighter than the others. It wasn't enough for me to complain, so I let it go. I went there the second time recently and decided to give them one more chance and purchased $50 face of junk silver (about $1200) and the younger guy there said I'll just throw the halves in the coin counter and give them to you. He came back with a bag filled with halves and I stupidly trusted him. In my car, I decided to look through the coins and I found the sob shorted me $5.50 face, which is over $100! There was one '71 (which is worth it's face value of fifty cents) and eight 1965-70 halves (all of which are 40%, not 90%)! I should have learned the first time. Like they say: fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me. NEVER AGAIN! If you know what's good for you, go to the coin shop that's in Niles on Milwaukee, or the one in Morton Grove on Waukegan. Both are 100 times better than this scam shop! And never again will I purchase junk silver without being allowed to pick through the coins. UNBELIEVABLY BAD!!! read more

Went in today to look at coins. The staff went out of their way to be helpful and friendly to me, and gave me a great price on the coins I bought. VERY good value for my money - I will absolutely be going back, sooner rather than later! They were also very helpful and freely gave me their opinions about a couple of coins I brought in, even though I mentioned before they even looked at them that I was not looking to sell, merely to get their thoughts on grades and value. read more

Great place to sell off your old gold for cash. Friendly, helpful and courteous staff.

Archies has the best prices for gold in the entire city. I shopped around, and ended up coming back. They were nearly double most other places I went to. Don't waste your time Chitown, go to Archies! read more

Always go their to get some 90% silver. Premiums are a bit high but cheaper than other coinshops. I recommend this spot to serious investors. Their junk 90% isnt even junk! Got many au quality pieces. read more

I went to Archies to cash in on some silver i had stored away and I walked out with more $$ than I expected!! Great experience, friendly service....highly recommended!! read more

Just like the reviewer below stated, honest and competitive. Came here with some jewelry, after getting a horrible quote elsewhere. The kind gent busted out what looked like a radar gun. Confirmed to me the composition of the jewelry and quoted me a fantastic price. They also have a beautiful collection of porcelain pieces as well as exotic coins. Would refer anyone here. People need to post about their experiences here, I'm only the 4th one..... really??? Parking is on Leihigh next to the Fire Department, you just cut through the alley read more

Kinda far from the city but they are the best!! They bought my stuff that wasn't worth much and they were so courteous and explained everything. Exceptional customer service and they paid me more than anyone else offered. read more

I'm confused is this a Pawn Shop or Coin Shop. I popped in over a few times over the years and bought some Key Date Coins and a Baseball card. I know what the prices are and they made a few bucks on the deal but i was ok with that the price always goes up over the years. Now I go in their and the place is dim lit and there are a bunch of guys sitting toward the back of the place talking about the price of Gold and Silver and how much money they made and soon as they saw me in an ear shot of them they hushed up. I honestly did not recognize anyone in their. Being in the location they are at I would imagine they get some High-End stuff coming in their and to the uneducated Buyer or Seller they will make some good money. A dear friend of mine also mentioned to me the Feds raided the place a couple of times. I always wondered don't you need back ground checks to work in these type of establishments? Either-way I'm not going back. Have a nice New Year Everyone! read more

I FINALLY decided to sell some gold. A few weeks ago, I took some things to a jeweler who has completed repairs for me for at least fifteen years, and whom I trust implicitly. I didn't bother to check around, although an alarm should have gone off in my head when he said that his offer was good for only one day. A few days later, I gathered up some more items and visited Archie's first. I was impressed by the fact that the gentleman immediately notified me that one of the bands was platinum rather than 14K. He made me an offer for everything, and there was no pressure. I then drove to my jeweler to see what he would offer. Needless to say, his offer was significantly less. The next day, I drove back to Archie's with my bag of goodies. I was greeted, and my items were weighed again. The same offer as the previous day was made, and needless to say, this time I accepted it! I mentioned that I was impressed with their honesty regarding that platinum, and was merely told "We want you to be happy"! So, I was, and I am. I'll be back and would definitely refer others. read more

Best price I was offered on a gold ring by 30%. I don't know if I'm a special case or got lucky somehow, but they brought the most competitive offer by a long shot. read more

Outstanding, knowledgeable group of guys. Fair and honest assessment of your goods and they give you cash right there. If you have questions about other stuff you've got, they'll give you their time and expertise. I will definitely go backc. read more

I went to some other gold selling place before going to Archie's, and was offered $8 for my 1oz. silver dollar!!! Archie's gave me the current spot price of my silver. I will never go anywhere else again. I'm glad to see that they are expanding the business. Friendly, knowledgeable, and fair people. read more

archies is a great coin shop to go to. they always have very nice coins for sale at fair prices. the shop itself is very pleasant to be in, having been remodeled in the last couple of years. the nicest thing about archies is their employees. especially mentioning art, who is a gem. they treat you with respect and are very nice to deal with. this is one of the greatest coins shops in the chicagoland area to buy from read more

I have been going to Archies for over 20 years, you cannot get better prices along with a very knowledgeable staff. Always willing to help and give you the best price possible for your items. I have sent so many people in, they have always come out happy. read more

I went into this location with my boyfriend (from Italy who speak no English) to buy a small gold coin. The first time we went into the store I asked the price for the gold coin and the elderly man looked at the younger fatter guy told us that the coin was going for 195$ for a tenth. I said we would be back. The market closed at 1277.00$ for an ounce so basically they were gaining a 67$ profit. The normal price would have been 140-155$ when i looked online. I am not saying that this elderly man and fatter guy are crooks but I am saying that they are not running an honest business I read another review that they gave bad prices to women before so maybe it was because I was a woman, maybe it was because I was translating into Italian for my boyfriend (tourist/foreign) or maybe it was because I was young but either way they were trying to take advantage of me and over-charge me a considerable amount. Regardless the following day we went into the store and there was a middle-aged tall thin gentleman working - I asked him the price without saying i was in there the day before and he said it was going for 155$. We ended up buying the coin because my boyfriend was going back to Italy the following day. But I ADVISE ALL especially women to know what you are talking about before going in because if they think they can they will take advantage of you. To me thats not a great business and despite the 50+ years in business I find that their model of business is a little skeptical - In essence the older guy and fat guy will try to run games with you so no matter who is working make sure you know prices and realize you will pay a 15-20% premium and 5-6% for the business that is normal anything more than that they are talking advantage of you. Cheers - I will not return to this place. read more

These guys don't know anything about coins. I went there a little while back to purchase some gold and this was one of my first buys, I didn't know the difference between one gold coin and the next. I saw a small coin, quarter ounce, and asked if it was pure gold. The guy took it out, look at it under his magnifying glass, and said, "Yeah, it looks like it". I purchased it and took it home and recently I decided to research it some more only to find out it was a 90% alloy, not pure!!! At least I didn't get ripped off since the amount of gold is the same, but if this guy can't tell the difference between a pure gold and alloy coin, that's pretty pathetic. This is a coin shop. This is their business. They better know the difference between coins, and it's not like this was an uncommon coin. It took me two minutes of googling to figure this out. I'd stay away from this place. read more

I drove from the South side to Archie's to take my sister to sell her old gold jewelry. She got way more than she expected! I was really impressed with how nice the staff was with me asking questions. I recommend Archie's to anyone who wants to sell their valuables. read more

Great place!! Always honest, always fair. Have been coming here for many years and will continue to return!

I went to this place four times. The first two times I was able to get coins at a reasonable price (fair market value) the third and fourth time it seems like they reached desperation and wanted to charge a lot more than the competitors. I will not buy from these guys nor refer anyone to them again. read more