We always stop at Grand Traverse Pie Company when we travel through Terre Haute. It is my favorite…read moreplace. Wonderful pies. Always take one home. Their BLT sandwich is loaded with bacon. Their quiche is always available in several flavors. Friendly and helpful staff.

OMG the best pie ever! Had the apple with pecans and caramel and it did not disappoint. Also had a…read moregrilled chicken baked potato which was delicious, good to know not only their pie is great!

It was overpriced and not worth the visit or the money. I'd go to Subway any day of the week…read moreinstead.

Pros: Brought food out to our table instead of asking us to…read morepick up at counter Delicious cheesesteak Easy parking at strip mall Cons: Floor is really sticky Tea was over brewed and had a cloudy haze to it Fries aren't crispy Pro tip: Grab a cookie to go; they are yummy

Great stop for dinner on our road trip…read more - - - - - - - - August, 2026 Visit We went on a road trip, from Missouri to Michigan, for a family event and Terre Haute provided the right place to stop for food at dinner time. Our son nicely picked McAllister's Deli. My wonderful wife and I split a salad; the kids filled up nicely. We were able to stretch our legs and relax a bit and then... back on the road. Good service, clean, nice and friendly staff. Thanks, McAllister's!

Food is always fresh. Order the Choose 2 and get a nice spread of items between salad, soup,…read moresandwiches, wraps, etc. it's generally a very clean restaurant and seating is very comfortable. Music is lively coming thru the ceiling speakers. They are very quick and efficient. Nice servers!! A friend/colleague and her sister joined our table. Luckily, they made me aware a free drink could be had since its teacher appreciation week! 1/2 cut might be a new favorite. It's brewed very well. The wrap that one of them had was very tasty and palatable. The lettuce is frilly and fun. The spud Max was devoured very easily. Mcallister's is always a good choice for fresh hot and cold food. Do it!!

I ordered the Italian. First time customer. Great value for the money! Clean store. Employee was…read morefriendly and the order was made fast and fresh cut. Worth every penny!

Excellent tuna sub. I had hesitated to give the Terre Haute store a try due to some negative…read morereviews. My experience was great, friendly staff, clean prep area and service with a smile. I will definitely be back

Husband and I shared a Rueben sub and medium fries. Next time we'll just get small fries. Best…read moreRueben we've had in a long time. Will definitely be going back!

I called to place an order for three sandwiches and was sent to a voice mail which said to leave a…read morename and phone message to be called back, My husband was at a local grocery store and would be picking up the order when it was ready. I called at least 6 times and left 2 messages but got nowhere, so I called my husband to see what he wanted to do. He called back and said he had gotten through and I was to call them and place the order. I did so with a boy who sounded as if I were bothering him. My husband arrived home with the three sandwiches and passed them around. My daughter was to have had a philly cheesesteak on wheat bread and received white bread. I was to receive a philly cheese steak with lettuce. tomatoes ,onions and mayo and my husband was to have a philly cheese steak with everything except hot peppers. Neither of our sandwiches was correct. By this time, we were all frustrated. I called the store to complain to the manager and was told by the same bored silly employee, or possibly another, that she was in the bathroom. I told him I would wait. A girl came to the phone and identified herself as the supervisor, Zaid Jabur. I told her I simply wanted to express my dissatisfaction and when she had no apology or explanation, I asked for a contact email or phone number for her superior. She said she could not give this information out. I told her I did not want the order corrected or credited to our account, neither of which she had offered to do. I simply told her that I would not be returning to this store again and would be contacting someone about this poor service. The worst thing about this whole experience was the bad taste it left in my mouth. It was like dealing with silly teenagers who could not care less about the customer, the business , or the ruining of a dining experience ; worse yet, it was as if these jejune little nincompoops who work at this store were snickering behind their hands at having gotten away with doing as little as they could to do a poor job. If I did speak to the store owner - Zaid Jabur ( who is listed in this website as the supervisor and owner,) then he/she needs to rethink his/her career choice. I will be telling this tale and advising people that if they want good food, good service, or good manners, then Penn Station East in Terre Haute is not the place to go.

Service was top notch and the sandwiches were amazing! I would definitely recommend trying a hot…read morepressed. Fantastic!

This spot is great for a quick grab and go lunch or dinner. I was in the area for work at an…read moreawkward time of day, and was glad to find Roly Poly to be open and serving the perfect lunch/dinner option for me. I was super impressed with the number of vegetarian options they offer - a true rarity when it comes to your typical sandwich joints. The customer service was great, and the employees helped me make my selection (as I can never seem to make up my mind...ever). Food came out fast and tasted great. Highly recommend for a quick, affordable, and delicious stop!

This is what $15 gets you. They should feel embarrassed. Not sure how Jimmy John's is still in…read morebusiness. What a joke.

Manager was rude. Would not honor coupon for side. It did not state on back no premium sides. They…read moreneed to change this

Love this locally owned restaurant Freshest food around you…read morecan't go wrong The absolute best salads, chicken salad, soups I go there every time I go to Terre Haute and really friendly

You can easily miss Gingersnaps if you're not familiar with the Christian bookstore it's connected…read moreto! It's in the back so it's a perfect place to eat and read when looking to relax. The food is pretty good and the staff is very friendly, will most likely be back since it's close to home!

Not really a fan of this location. This staff here always seems agitated. The bacon is disgusting…read moreyet charge me almost $4 for raw bacon. I forgot to add cheese to my sandwich on a mobile order and told them as soon as I got to the drive thru. They refused to put the cheese on my sandwich even after offering to pay for it at the window. They also told me I could come get new bacon for my sandwich when I called then acted mad that I didn't bring the sandwich with raw bacon on it back. I just asked for the bacon and not the sandwich and they came off like I was stealing. I felt uncomfortable because I just wanted edible food. The food is alright, but doesn't seem fresh compared to the other location.

I ordered delivery and it took 35 minutes to arrive. On top of this my wrap had next to nothing…read moreinside and the wrap itself was stale. The only thing edible about this whole meal was the prepackaged chips. This is a huge disappointment as I typically LOVE jimmy johns. I will never order from here again.

The food was okay. My sandwich was drowning in sauce. My bf did not like his soup and mine just…read moretasted like it came out of a can. It was $33 for my boyfriend and I to eat. Which in my opinion is too expensive for a place like that(getting your own food, drinks, and cleaning up afterwards). The lady that took our order was not friendly and seemed annoyed for no reason. They don't have crackers for your soup either. The environment was okay.

If there was a option to give a lower rating I would. Over priced and everything I had I was not a…read morebig fan of. $33 to eat for two. The service is that of a typical fast food establishment. The dining room was setup better than average. I got a cheese steak sandwich and a cup of chili. I was not pleased with either. The cheese steak was very sweet tasting almost like it was coated in sugar. The chili did not have a very desirable taste at all, no macoroni which I do prefer. I also asked for crackers and was told they don't carry any.