This place smelt like Rot and the service was extremely RUDE as if they could not be bothered. I would go to Market Basket before going in this smelly place again. This place has gone down hill. read more

My brother picked up some salmon and shrimps a couple of days ago and I cannot stress how fresh this seafood was!!! Definitely a place to check out if you want QUALITY seafood ! read more

I needed some haddock today. Our go to place is normally Cherry Street Market but that is closed. I went to SeaWitch but they had no haddock. I then googled north shore seafood markets and thought I'd try a new place, C&C Lobster in Peabody. The owner seemed really nice but the place was filthy and I had to leave. I then drove to Andy's Seafood. Spotless place. Like night and day from C&C Lobster. The haddock looked beautiful. The lady who waited on me was superb. We just finished our dinner, the haddock that I stuffed with crab. I am so happy with this place and will be back for sure. read more

Dear Wife, Dinner tonight comes with a story. I bought this wonderful piece of salmon at Andy's. We've lived near here for over 20 years. I'd never gone in before. After paying Town Fair Tire nothing to repair my tire (nail in tread) I figured I would stop next door for a nice piece of fish. I met the owner. He seems like a very nice guy. I asked him if this shop had been here forever. He said that he started working in the shop with his folks when he was six. So for him it is forever. He's about our age, so you know what I mean. He asked if I wanted my salmon thick or thin. How much do I want? Skin on or off (On of course, for the flavor.) He rounded the weight down. He rounded the change up (5.00 instead of 4.50). Smiles, hand shakes. Hey, it's worth a little extra to support a local family business, right? I hope that you like this salmon, because I'll be back. Love, Husband read more

Andy's seafood has been THE place to go for seafood. I have been going here for years every time I want a nice pice of fish or when my husband wants a nice lobster. The fish is VERY good and clean, always fresh. The women who usually waits on me is so sweet and the owner puts a lot of work into his business. I will never buy seafood anywhere else no matter the convince. I take seafood seriously, so so does Andy's. Family owned since the 70's! Can't beat a mom and pop shops. Definitely recommend. read more

See all

For one, the seafood here is merely okay. There is very little selection, then on top of that, they only accept cash, no credit cards. I go here occasionally but it's not my first choice. I go either to Rowand's in Beverly, Patriot Lobster in Salem (which is really a wholesaler), or if I want the largest selection, Cherry Street Fish Market. But the main reason I'm posting is that I drove by today, 12/12/12, and on their large sign, which highlights specials, it said "King Obama Crab Legs". Is that really necessary?!? You may not agree with our President's policies, but calling him names does not speak well of you. Chances are, using the term "King" also tells me you only watch Fox News, which is the only channel that refers to him as "king" or "the anointed one." In any case, you can have your opinion, but is it also necessary to call anyone names publicly? And doing it to your buying customers, some of whom may not only not share the same views, is not going to help you stay in business. You can count on me that not only will I not return again, but will let everyone I know about the sign. And don't confuse this with "freedom of speech" issues as the latter only refers to citizens versus government imposition. Public protests against businesses do not fall into the 1st amendment rights category. read more

Smelled like rotten fish. We went in and out in about 5 minutes. Perhaps once a great fish market?

I was very surprised the last time I went into Andy's. It has gone downhill...big time. The staff seemed bothered to wait on me.... prices high and quality low. As another reviewer commented, I did notice the huge sign about "King Obama" on their billboard. Highly unprofessional- leave your politics out of your retail business. read more

I have bought fresh fish here that is as good and as fresh as any you will find, I have also bought fish here that was not as fresh as it could have been. At close to fifteen dollars per pound for haddock I expect more consistrency in the quality of the product. read more

I have been making Lobster pie for 10 years for X mas eve. I used to buy my Lobster meat at Burlington and then Reading but they both Closed. Since I work in Saugus I thought I would give Andy's Seafood a try. The woman that took my order by phone was very pleasant and helpful. My order was ready for me as promised on Monday at noon. While preparing it I commented on how nice and clean the meat was. NO roe or other yucky stuff that other shops have slipped in. After cooking my Lobster pie it was totally delicious. Nice big pieces of tender & sweet lobster. Not only did I just place an order for New Years but I was so impressed that i signed up just to write this review. Unlike others have done, they did not price gouge for the holiday. Try them.. You wont be disapointed. read more

I have been an Andy's customer for about 15 years and can honestly say I have had top notch fish each and every time. Just got a big order for Christmas Eve for the Feast of the Seven Fishes, and more for Christmas Day. Everyone raved about my dishes, as they do each year :) I won't go anywhere else for my fish....I know it will be fresh and delicious. read more

I don't know what Tony N is talking about. This is a retail store and if he didn't like the smell of fish 1 day off of the boat he shouldn't have sat at the counter for 5 minutes. I have known the owners (father and son) since the shop opened. It has been the same fish market for 30 years. They always have the freshest fish and many loyal customers. If you want quality, this is the place to go to. read more