I bought an expensive pizza it looked good but then l noticed that it taste burnt.When l looked underneath it was all black, burnt. I brought it back to the counter, two of the guys looked at it and said that it was supposed to be that way. I thought different, l've never had a pizza that looked that way. So l just took it back to eat the rest but couldn't enjoy it with that terrible burnt taste. I remember going there years ago in 2019, it was all brothers working there at the time and the food was great. Another time a few weeks before getting this pizza l had the lasagna, l noticed that it wasn't at all the way it used to be. What a disappointment after spending so much money there. When l realized that they changed the name of the restaurant, had new owners it explained why the food wasn't the same. I'll never go back. read more

I got take out. My order was wrong (maybe b/c of a language barrier) but the Caesar salad was ok. Not much lettuce & mostly croutons. The Turkey club was disappointing. It was on a dry wrap. I think I was told my choice for a turkey club sandwich was a wrap or Syrian pocket ? No toast ? Anyway, it was edible. I would give my order a 6.5 out of 10. read more

Don't use a credit card here, they have been charging me 49.19 15 separate times in the last 2 weeks. Be aware!!! read more

American Pizza & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Wareham, Massachusetts

I am sorry to say that my pizza from American pizza was less than subpar. Do not get the thick dough as it is too chewy and thick. Sorry guys the pizzas looked good and that is the end of this story. read more

Food , period ‼‼‼ greasy pizza & the chicken , just yuck. Sorry but honest . They want the same money as most places but Santoros in Wareham/Onset is awesome, fast service & AWESOME PIZZA .. read more

I see some rough reviews on here, but I only have great things to say. They deliver all over town, always friendly, and food is always solid. Chicken parm sub is always a go to. Their pizza never disappoints, and the double cheeseburger dinner is an absolute steal for the price. Highly recommend read more

DO NOT bother signing up for the VIP program. The redemption never seems to get on the order even though the VIP profile shows it redeemed. I show the redemption to the man who filled my order and he said he would take care of it next time. I'll update my review if he does, but I'm reasonably sure that was a brush off. The food is actually decent, so if you're not bothered by deceptive business practices, I would say go ahead and give them a try. read more

Great pizza subs Not the easiest place to place an order though. Down side they pack the hot and cold food together. So if you don't mind a warm salad you are good to go. read more

Awesome food and a amazing delivery service :) I'm super satisfied ;D I been ordering there for a while now and everything taste really great read more

I used to love their Greek salads, loaded with different veggies, etc,,but the last 2 have been a disappointment, largely iceberg lettuce 1 cherry tomato, olives, and some feta,,, the pita bread is still delish however, and I've heard the pizzas have gotten better too... read more

Ordered delivery for the first time. Buffalo chicken calzone was soggy and greasy. Might have been better if ordered well done? I ordered a toasted bourbon chicken sub. Chicken didn't have much flavor. Bread was not toasted. Overall that was ok. I won't be ordering here again. read more

Although I have had one good experience with this place it took 3 to decide never to get food here again. I was on hold for over 5 minutes why I didn't hang up is a good question. Then the food was delivered over 1:15 mins later. I was originally told 45 on the phone. Finally it came and after the deliver guy leaves I open the box to find the pizza crust on one side and the toppings on the other side of the box. Making this worse all the crust was mush so I couldn't just pile it back together and move on with life. I didn't bother to call and complain because I simply will not be getting food here again. As I stated I had one good experience in which I picked up a steak and cheese sub and it was good. I have also picked up a sub that was kind of disgusting and didn't eat more then half before giving up. Stay away if you can, if not check your deliveries before the guy leaves. If you get take out order simple stuff. read more

American Pizza & Grill - #fml - Pizza Near Me - Wareham, Massachusetts

Do not order! Especially for delivery. The food is alright, basic pizza place food. The potato's skins are weird just potato's cut in half with cheese and bacon. The pizza is greasy but ok if you ask for it well done. The salads are pretty gross. My biggest issue is they are the only place who delivers to my home in Middleboro, every time we order delivery our order is messed up. A couple times they brought us the missing items. Today however they told us to come pick it up. If I order and pay for delivery then why would I want to or have the means to go pick food up. So since I was not going to pack my kids up and drag them out at 7pm I made them food at home, after paying for dinner. read more

American is my least favorite independent pizza/sub shop in MA. Most seem to be roughly the same with only Greek vs. Italian difference in selection and how the pizza is made. American is Greek (which I usually prefer), yet they are the only one I've truly disliked. I am disappointed more than half of the time - both for the food and the service. Embarrassingly, they continue to get some of my business because the location is very convenient to me. Many days I am too tired or busy to drive to Wareham center (the next nearest independent pizza place) for better food. If you are equal distance or driving by anything else in your travels; I'd recommend going to that other place. American's menu even stole pictures of CiCi's Pizza. Look at the main photo on the menu, and you'll notice CiCi's logo in the window lol. The pizza is OK while hot. At most places, I order enough for pizza the next day, but something about their pizza makes for really bad reheated or cold pizza. Their pizza is the only one I throw away when it gets cold. They seem to use low-quality ingredients in most of their subs and pizza, which may be the reason. On the other hand; one thing that always seems tasty is the fried chicken - as strips or in a sub or salad. Their pita bread is also good (thick and fresh), but their garlic bread is very skimpy and stale. The fried haddock is pretty good for a pizza place as well. Overall it is just sub-par food in a category of food I usually find to be a treat. There is nothing good to say about the service. It's one of those places where you are made to feel like an inconvenience for ordering or picking up food. Your satisfaction with service or food is not a priority. There is no close competition, so they will keep getting business. They seem to be very aware of this. You need to know the menu very well, because they will ask if you'd like something made a certain way and charge you extra with no mention of additional charges. If you order the pasta dishes, know that an $8.99 dish can easily cost $15 when you pick it up if you don't fully understand the person on the phone (which is often the case). Do you want it baked? What kind of meat do you want in your meat lasagna? It sounds like these are options, but they are add-ons. $2 to bake it, a few dollars for ground sausage... ends up costing more than sitting down at a nice restaurant.. However, the accidental $15 version of their lasagna is tasty. The $9 version is not. read more

Pizza was ok. We had two slices. My mom had a veal sub that had two slices of cheese and a cold, not even toasted sub roll. We were fine with the food bc we wanted something quick as we were in a rush. However, worst part was the counter lady. She did not say hello. We said "hi how are you" to which she didn't say a word. Took our order and we tipped her $1.50. She did not say thank you or even recognize that we tipped...she never once said thank you or your welcome when we asked for things. Horrible, horrible customer service. We were honestly scared to ask for anything else other than the Mayo (we asked for it on the sub and it wasn't on it), parm. Cheese, and napkins. read more

The big question: Is it better than Marcs? I ask: Why compare? Why not just enjoy both? The are across town from each other and they each have good to offer. Less than a quarter mile from my house, i frequent this place so i know all the ins and outs. Dont bother getting anything but pizza (and the occasional sub) I get the BBQ chicken pizza with red onion and have them add bacon. Get a side of bleu cheese and get it to go because the atmosphere sucks and you really dont wanna see anyone you know. Dont forget to get the romano cheese and pile it on the pizza....thats really the best part. They said they import it from Italy and grate it fresh daily and it tastes like they are telling the truth man. RED FLAG: When you call in to order, you might get someone with a foreign accent and they will be very difficult to understand. You might get frustrated and just start saying "yes" while they are repeating your order even if you dont know what they are saying. Be careful with this as it may result in a grab bag pizza...and who wants that? read more

I had their pizza delivered a few times to where I worked in Wareham. I never really cared for it. But all I've tried is their pizza. It was very flat, and very thin. The cheese was slimey. I've had much better elsewhere. read more

Stopped by around 3:00 pm yesterday for a late lunch. I got a steak tip sub with mushrooms, onion and peppers with cheese. My wife got a steak bomb. We were the only ones in the place other than the 4 workers. My tips were over cooked and the vegetables were under cooked. The cheese was not melted and the roll wasn't toasted. Maybe I should have asked for the roll to be toasted but the menu called it a grinder and I thought that was sop. My wife hated her steak bomb and said there were hardly any vegetables on it and what was there tasted almost raw. I used the bathroom and it was a mess, the trash was overflowing and there were shredded paper products all over the floor that looked like they had been there a while. It felt dirty and disgusting. As I sat down my wife said look at the floor in this place, does anyone sweep or mop it ever. I looked up and observed two of the 4 workers texting or playing on there phones. I wanted to say to them how about any of you cleaning this place instead of texting. I was pretty sure that one of the people present was the owner as everyone was older and it looked like a family type run restaurant. Honestly I would never eat there again because I once read that you can always tell how clean a restaurant is by the condition of its bathroom. Management knows the public is going to see that bathroom and if they don't care enough to keep it clean than what does the kitchen look like when they know you can't see it. read more

American Pizza & Grill - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Wareham, Massachusetts

Ordered a Cheese Lover's pizza which is supposed to be a blend of 5 cheeses. Apparently an acceptable cheese is Velveeta or Cheez Whiz or something with a very bright color and gooey texture. It had to be scooped off since we were so hungry and didn't feel like going back. Never never again. read more

American Pizza & Grill - This is what was removed from the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wareham, Massachusetts

See all

Real pizza, great! I've been to many pizza shops and none of them have good pizza. This place has the pizza I like. Haven't had a problem yet. read more

Food is decent. But always rude. I live close by. Typically order from here monthly. At one time so much that I signed up for their "rewards program". When I cashed in my "reward" they made me feel like I was stealing from them. Asked me to print it out, even though it was sent thru a text. I printed it out per asked. It turned so uncomfortable that I went to my car to retrieve my phone to prove I wasn't pulling one over. All and all not a great experience. Don't sign up for the "reward program". They will make u feel like shit and 5 people will come over and stare at you... read more

We have ordered take out meals, several time from American Pizza. The phone call's have been quick (never on hold), and the meals are ready whithin the given time, and the meals themselves are great! read more

Face it, it's a pizza joint. The place itself is pretty typical. Rating a pizza place on its ambiance, though, isnt generally helpful though. The pizza is really what matters- but that was actually pretty mediocre too. Nothing bad, exactly, but nothing especially great, either. Their prices are unremarkable, and the best item that I've tried is actually their steak sub. All in all, it's not a great pizza place- but it's fine if you're looking for somewhere pretty cheap to lunch. read more

I've been a faithful customer of American Pizza for about three years settling for sub par food because it was convenient and one of only places to deliver to my house. Had my last experience there today and would recommend anyone to drive the extra few miles to another pizza shop. Went there to pick up an order after work and here are the reasons for my generous 1 star rating. First, the bathrooms were filthy and the cook was sweeping what looked like a weeks worth of dust off the floor. I ordered a tuna salad and overpaid the $10 for it because I was hungry and didn't want to cook after a long days work. The tuna was inedible and soured. I called to make them aware of the issue and they offered me nothing more than I will let the cook know. Now keep in mind they have a loyalty program attached to my phone number so they would be able to see I have spent several hundred if not thousands of dollars there over the years. They could of at least offered a different meal or coupon for future purchase. But nothing. Again stay away from this place unless you want over priced soured food. Drive the extra few miles to Wareham House of Pizza or Santoros. read more

Had a friend of mine introduce me to this place. Their pizza is great! Now anytime I am in the carver area I crave this pizza. Their specialty pizza's are really good and tasty. They have no issue doing with special request orders and they have always been friendly. read more

I'm surprised to read all these negative reviews. During the summer I often stop by to get a Greek salad with chicken. It's always delicious and the bread is amazing. Can't say I've ever called in an order, got deliver or had their pizza. read more

Rude staff, bad pizza. All there is to say. Take your headphones out and put your phone down when interacting with a customer. Pizza was mushy and soggy and greasy. read more

Had a chicken Cobb salad today. It was fresh and crisp, I went with Greek dressing which was also good. I called in my order and picked it up. It was ready in under the 10 min they quoted. No complaints. read more

We don't even live here anymore and we still crave this place. Their pita bread is awesome and their bbq chicken pizza is the best. Come on people, it's pizza not fine dining. Everyone complains about something but no one speaks up if it's good. read more

This Place Call American Pizza doesn't deserved any stars because this place is one number It's a "0". But I've give them 1 , the food I ate was so bad I can't believe I've given this place so many chances and every time they feel miserable from there subs, to there wraps like Melanzana(eggplant,fresh mozzarella,fresh basil,tomatoes,w/a balsamic vinaigrette) Wrap know trust me if they just took away the fried eggplant this wrap would be fantastic because adding in that grease over fried eggplant and that's all u taste and It's All-ful it took away the fresh taste of the mozzarella and the basil what shame. And then there dessert pizza the chocolate Hawaiian and oreo pizza first they don't take the time to make a gramcracker crust or a chocolate expecially the oreo pizza but they put on a very hard thin crust that has a 78% chance of breaking or teeth. Now when I ordered the Chocolate Hawaiian it sound good (Cherries,Pineapples,my guess sweet cheese, and chocolate small chocolate chunks sounds good yes on paper or web site but when u get it and u open it and u see a big heep of.ham on it Blah. Could u imagen ham on a dessert I called them up and said what the hell and the answer was because the word Hawaiian in there so had to know it had be like the Hawaiian pizza ham&pineapples. So what u are really buying is a Hawaiian pizza w/ham,pineapples covered with cherries, sweet or regular cheese all with watery melted chocolate so if Ur high or the woman u love is having Ur babe I still say stay away because of the crust . The Chocolate Hawaiian has (HAM). The Banana Foster CheeseCake, Double Chocolate Brownies bites, NY-CheeseCake bites They all sound fantastic and the do and the should but once more the deep fried them so much the come out put-a-ful and Banana Foster I'm sorry. American Pizza listen to these reviews and with some small changes Ur stars will start to grow to 5 but that's up to u as they say the ball in your court. read more

First off the service here is slow and takes an hour for delivery and I only live down the street 2nd going into this place you are greeted not everytime but sometime they are rude and kinda just eh whatever about their jobs read more

Worst place to order on line pizza from. I ordered online and accidentally ordered ricotta cheese on a pizza. I called right away after I realized I made a mistake. They said we can't change the order. I order pizza there weekly. Will not be returning. read more

Last night was my first and last visit here. There was an extensive menu, but we settled on an old stand-by, something we figured you can't screw up. We were wrong. We ordered a "large roast beef sub" for dining in. The person who took our order had zero personality, and could barely muster the energy to engage us in light-hearted conversation. And he didn't ask/offer if we wanted the bread toasted. My friend and I got a table at the front by the window, waited and the sub arrived soon after. The order was for a large roast beef sub, provolone cheese, tomatoes, peppers, onions, and extra mayonnaise. We received a large very doughy sub roll, two slices of American cheese, a small amount of mayonnaise - by no reasonable person's standards could it be considered "extra", and TWO pathetic slices of nearly raw "roast beef". At $7.99 this was hardly a value for my money, and, if anything, the quality and presentation was insulting to me. VERY DISAPPOINTING! DO yourself a favor, AVOID this place at all costs. I cannot speak for the rest of the menu, nor to the personalities of other employees, but based on this singular experience, my recommendation is 1-star. If I could give less I would. I am on or near the Cape for business or pleasure often, and know a lot of people in the area. I will never go there again, and will never recommend anyone to them. In the same strip mall is a Dunkin' Donuts, and while I am not a fan of DD's menu offerings in general, a week old donut is more appetizing than this sub was. read more

Was going to Santoros for long time. Then they switched their cheeses to what looked like plastic after it got warm. Switched to Rose And Vickis down the street. Sauce somewhat bland, and bit pricy for just Pizza. Switched then to Nick's in Mattapoisett. Lasagna was awesome. Pizza bottoms always burned. Ordered two oven grinders and they were also burned on the bottoms to point of not being able to chew thru it. Their large Pizza about the size of most shops medium...... Discovered American Pizza & Grill. Further past where we live. Pizza reminds me of the old New York Syle Pizza. They sell by the slice ( HUGE ) and the menu there is very broad. Excellent crust, toppings plentyfull and had great flavor. Will be trying other items on their menu :) read more

Really bad pizza, and their delivery service is not dependable. We ordered delivery last night. 2 large pizzas. The voice on the phone (friendly, which is why they got two stars) knew our neighborhood, and told us 35 to 45 minutes. Great! The pizza arrived an hour and fifteen minutes later. Cold. I was surprised by the lack of flavor. Even salt and pepper didn't help. I pulled back the cheese, and found almost no tomato sauce whatsoever. I have given them a few chances, and have been disappointed. I will not be tempted again. Try Plane Janes at the Plymouth airport for consistently good pizza. Only drawback is that they don't deliver. read more

We absolutely love this place! Food is always delicious and hot when we get delivery. They make special orders like bacon egg and cheese subs and pizzas! Their peta pockets are made in house and are one of the most amazing peta pocket I've encountered! Definitely worth a try! we love you here in carver get delivery at least 2-3 times a week kudos to you! One more thing the price point is perfect for the portion you get. read more

I would normally call and complain like in the old days but I know that calling and the yelp review won't change or do anything for me other than let me rant lol...so ya my steak tips were over cooked I asked 4 times for medium rare and got guess what.....well done.plus they were attached to a paper plate in the Styrofoam container and had some nice hot packets of ketchup in there. salad wasn't to bad and at least the fries were alright so that's the only reason I put 2 stars read more

I happen to like the pizza from American. The prices are fair and they are fast. I'm not going to say the negative reviewers are wrong, I respect their opinion and I'm sure they were not happy. For me, I never think twice about ordering from American. read more

Great pizza, the crust is thin and crispy. If you like it that way, this is your place. I can't spea kto their delivery service, I always pick up- but they are quick and courteous. But if you're looking for a place to sit and eat and enjoy the ambiance, there are better places in town. It's a little bright and stripmall-like for my taste. read more

Took an hour and fifteen minutes for delivery one mile down the street. Thought I was saving time at work by not driving. Delivery charge was twice what I expected and salad price was different from website. Pizza had been reheated, recooked, or re-something. Tough and tasteless. Could not find salad dressing because it was wrapped up with my Syrian bread which I did not open until I was just about done. Will not patronize them again. read more