I love amato's. The waiters are always super friendly and quick. I came here with my sister and we ordered the penne pizza, honey mustard chicken pizza, and the chicken parm pizza. My favorite is the penne pasta. It's like a vodka type of sauce with pieces of pork and it's delicious. The honey mustard chicken pizza is always a hit and I think the perfect amount of honey mustard. My sister enjoyed the chicken parm pizza and was sad to not be able to finish it. Overall, great variety of pizzas and reasonably priced! read more

Amato's Pizza - Penne pizza, honey mustard chicken pizza, chicken parm pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

When you walk in you're greeted immediately, which is nice. We had a bigger party but we were seen right away and service was great! The menu is packed with all kinds of Italian delights but I was pizza'd out, so I ordered a cheesesteak. I got the one that said it was on garlic bread but this turned out to not be accurate, so that's where they lost one star . The sandwich had a thick garlic sauce on it which was almost like toum. The other star was lost because while we were all eating a cockroach crawled under our tables, which, you know, is gross. read more

See all

We come here for the Tuscany salad packed with grilled chicken, shrimp, peppers, walnuts and if you want craisons and olives! The house dressing is light and good! We especially like the cozy neighborhood vibes and totally welcoming and warm HALEY! She has a delightful and hospitable personality! A very bubbly, energetic and enthusiastic customer service oriented team player! Thanks HALEY for making us feel at home! read more

Amato's Pizza - Tuscany salad - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

See all

Was just coming home and I felt like a hoagie and I stopped here , not where I normally go but it was close and snowing ,so I bought a hoagie, it was think I will be going back there !! read more

Buffalo chicken pizza that was overcooked, even the chicken was dry,barely any Bleu cheese essentially it was cardboard with cheese ,a little bit of dried chicken and very little Bleu cheese. They've been going down hill for a while. Couldn't even eat 1 piece it went into the trash where it belongs. read more

Absolutely wonderful. Was greeted immediately, staff was extremely attentive. Order came quick. Ordered the boneless and bone in wings 10/10, the cheese fries portion was HUGE get a small for sure !!! Calamari was good as well. read more

Amato's Pizza - Boneless Wings - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

See all

Little local pizza place, open til 11 pm. Stopped in not long before closing. There were only a few kinds of pizzas and offered by the slice at that hour. But I got the Amato's Pizza which is their name for what NJ'ans call a grandma pie. Even if it might have been sitting for a while, it was pretty tasty. They also list desserts on the menu that you couldn't take a peek at them because they were not out on display. I got a cheesecake which I'm going to try later. (edited to add: because the desserts are not on display, I discovered when I opened the sealed package the next day, that the "New York cheesecake" had goopy raspberry jelly all over it. I would have picked something else! So ask them to show you the desserts before you try to order something, even if the folks at the counter are confused about where they are and have to ask someone in the kitchen!) But I'm pretty pleased with this local place and I am enjoying my Amato's pie slices! read more

Amato's Pizza - Amato's Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

See all

When the "Amato" Brothers oned the place They had the BEST PIZZA in Levittown, NY state(neices&Nephew) and Florida (Brother) all were always looking for there 1st days visits because AMATO's PIZZA was the first meal down here. But NOT NOW!! NEW OWENERS should learn how to make a good pie before they try to sell them. Not enough extras when ordig them,canned mushrooms, put dabe of sauce on top of cheese in places to look like Pepperoni,till You got home. Want money up front so the pizza your handed can not be refused because of badly made Pie. The New owners had a gold mine there and turned it in a coal mine. Does only one know where I can find a GREAT N.Y. PIZZA??? I have been trying pizzas all around and can not find any pie 1/2 as good as My good old Guys. Miss You all. Your well done Pie Person (1 S&M and an 1 extra cheese cheese,please.cheryl PS .Best of everything to You and Your family. read more

My son and I recently had a great experience at Amato's. Parking was easily found in the strip mall parking lot. The inside was clean, brightly lit, looked new and inviting. The long service counter had several slice pies nicely organized behind glass. From our table, they had a TV close by tuned in to the Phillies to help keep us company. Our server was friendly, checked up on us a lot and was on top of cleaning up her area. We ordered a fresh plain cheese pizza well done and it came out pretty quickly. The center was undercooked which led to quite a bit of flopping. We had to wait for it to cool down a bit more so the slices would firm up a bit and the cheese wouldn't be so runny. Once we dove in though we found it to have a perfect sauce/cheese ratio, sweet n seasoned sauce, cheese tasty/little sweet with a crispy crust. I had Amato's a long long time ago and I don't remember it being this good. Most of the diners at other tables were getting deep dish pizza and some pasta dishes. They all looked delicious. We included Amato's in a recent trip trying out multiple pizza shops in the area and my son and I both agreed that Amato's was a toss up with a couple other shops for best pizza around this area of Bucks County. The only bummer was we forgot our left over slices at the table, but hey it gives us another reason for a return trip! Thanks guys! read more

Amato's Pizza - Plain pizza well done -perfect sauce/cheese ratio, sweet n seasoned sauce, cheese tasty/little sweet. Floppy, but had a crispy crust. - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

See all

The Tomatoes Pies are my favorite! Will drive further for that! Their menu is awesome!

I went with my mom to Amato's for lunch one day and had SUCH a good "Orange Salad". The portions were very generous and actually fed me for 2 meals. My mom and I got a side of fries too, and they were super generous with those as well. The chicken in the salad tasted high quality and the orange that was in there tasted very fresh as well. Our waitress was really nice and food got served very quickly. Overall it was a really pleasant surprise, I liked it and would definitely come back again. My mom loved her food too. read more

See all

Man. Amato's makes a great pie. I went over my besties yesterday in Fairless Hills yesterday and ordered 2 large. 1 pepperoni and the other, sausage and bacon. Absolutely delicious. When I'm in levittown pa, this place is tops read more

Grew up on this place, always slaps at a great value. They've added delivery and are open earlier/later these days, great changes

Great pizza- coming back from Texas this was the first thing we wanted- a Jersey pie and that's exactly what we got- it was hot- perfect

I absolutely love the family who owns this establishment. They are kind and it shows. My husband and I come often and get the salads. They are the absolute best salads. The pizzas are great as well. Overall never change amatos!! read more

10/10 Service!! The employees are super nice, they all enjoy working and they are all good people! The food is amazing too, its fresh, tasty and very hot!!! The portions are pretty big and the princess are quite cheap! The place looks nice too! I love this place, 10/10 read more

Decent quality pizza from an unassuming store. I appreciate the wide selection of pizza by the slice. Definitely hit the spot after sesame place. read more

cheesesteak was mid $14 down the drain pizza was good tho I even asked if the cheesesteak was any good of course they will say it is but still read more

Amato's has been a family favorite for MANY years now! Our next door neighbor (when I lived in Levittown, PA as a kid) worked there when she was in high school and would always bring us Amato's pizzas when she came home after her shift! We ALWAYS looked forward to it!! The pizza pies are consistently awesome with plenty of toppings and perfect crust! Nowadays when I visit the folks, we'll either order and pick up delicious Strombolis, Chicken Parm and pizza OR use a delivery service like Slice to deliver from Fairless Hills to Levittown. The ONLY thing that I would wish is that Amato's had their OWN delivery drivers instead of having to pay extra to use a 3rd party delivery service. But the quality of the food makes up for the added cost. read more

Service was very good. I like the cheese it was very tasty. All around a very good pizza I take mine home and crisp it up in a frying pan comes out great read more

Yuk! We ordered eggplant rollantini and got an order of cheese. Cheese is expensive, eggplant isn't so why so much cheese? Not a fan anymore. read more

Amato's Pizza - Cheese, cheese, and more cheese with a touch of eggplant. - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania

My friend and I wanted to try out a new local pizza shop and I'm happy we stumbled upon this place! Delivery was fast and food was good. Ordered a small taco pizza, garlic bread chicken cheesecake, and curly fries. Ordering the garlic bread chicken cheesesteak was a no brainer and I'm so happy it tasted just as good as i had imagined. Rather than giving us just a few fries with our order the restaurant gave us...an ENTIRE bag of curly fries (major points)!!!!! Would order from here again! read more

See all

Back in the area and had to stop at Amato's for a PIZZA STEAK SANDWICH (3/5) and a slice of SICILIAN PIZZA (2/5). We sat outside, and service was very good. Overall, however, lunch was very disappointing. read more

Great food !! Service and staff excellent nice lunch spot ! Great amount of food nice variety of pizza pies to choose from Place comfortable . read more

My sister suggested this pizza place to eat for lunch since it was rated so highly on Yelp. But for some reason everytime someone suggests a new place for me to try, I don't have the same great experience they have (it never fails). So we went with a group of 3 adults and 3 children (6 and 7 years old). We had to order at the counter, then wait to be seated, which to me was a little weird, cause I am used to being seated by someone right away, or ordering and finding your own seats. Okay so other than that they have a nice display of flavors of pizza, they have taco pizza, cheesesteak and cheese fries pizza, which I have never seen before. I went with a large cheese pizza to be on the safe side for the kids, and slice of cheesesteak pizza and an order of cheese fries. The cheese pizza tasted good and the kids really enjoyed it. The cheesesteak pizza was too soggy and I didn't like the way it tasted, definitely not worth 4 dollars a slice. I tried my friend's taco pizza, it was an interesting idea but wasn't a fan of it either, then I tried the bbq chicken pizza my sister had and it was okay. I just had better pizza places and prob would make the trip back to this place again. read more

See all

This place was very good, but new management completely destroyed it. I ate here for 40 years, and last night was the last time I ever will. The food that used to be great, is now average at best, but the worst part are the workers. They're very rude, and clearly do not know how to run a business. The former owner would be so sad to see what it has turned into. Last night, I ordered personal pizza. The girl told me $13.78, which is already a crazy price for a tiny 1-person pizza, but on top of that, they had the nerve to charge me more, for using my debit card, without even telling me! I told them all to F off, that they ruined the place, and that I'll never be back. It's really unfortunate, but screw those people. Don't let the old reviews fool you. They are no longer relevant. read more

I got a Cheesesteak with the works. $8.80. I like this Cheesesteak. But I wish the extras, or in this case The Works, spent more time on the grill with the meat. The extras were nice big flavorful pieces but they overpower the rest of the sandwich a little. I think if they had spent more time on the grill with the meat getting to know each other and blending flavors this would have been a lot better cheesesteak. The roll was standard. The roll had a tough time holding everything together for my still pictures. Okay amount of cheese but I wish it was melted through the whole cheesesteak. read more

See all

Stopped by Amatos for dinner. We were looking forward to it, they have good food. We waited 17 minutes for the "server" to acknowledge our presence but still not wait on us! Granted it was not the usual server, but 17 mins in a pizza place with 7 tables? We walked out! Likely to never return. Rude , ignorant and on a Saturday night. read more

Been going here since I was 2 years old, an I am now 47. Still the best pizza and cheesesteaks to be had. When my friends come to visit from anywhere outside of the area and want a "Philly cheesesteak," I tell them I won't be taking them to the trashy tourist trap cheesesteak spots in the city, but rather a place right in he burbs that puts to shame any cheesesteak in Philly itself. Side note- It's funny to me how many people with one or two star reviews of Amato's mention that everything is always great, EXCEPT for this ONE TIME, and then they leave a review on that one experience vs any of the dozens of other great ones prior. People are weird and like to complain. read more

Sorry but the take out Pasta Fajole soup was terrible.. red liquid with canellini beans and mushy pencil points no flavor at all. I ordered 2 meatballs that were sliced in half sitting in a few spoons of watery sauce. The meatballs had so little meat they seemed to be mostly breadcrumbs. Definitely disappointing for my first and last visit. read more

Just phenomenal. We're in Langhorne on vacation with 3 kids under 5. Our first night here we decided to go with something "simple" because we had spent the day driving and didn't want to think too much. Pizza works for all of us. We chose Amato's because they had the best reviews on DoorDash. We're from Boston so we weren't expecting to be knocked out of our shoes by some plain cheese pizza, but oh, were we wrong. Large cheese pizza. 10/10. Best pizza I've ever had. The kids agreed as well, and they're difficult to please. We vowed to try something new each night the rest of the time we're here. Tonight me and my husband got Indian food for us, and Amato's again for the kids (they all but demanded it). I still ended up having a couple slices while waiting for our Indian food to arrive. Seriously, just get it. read more

Disappointing pizza. The pizza (sauce & cheese) lacked any flavor. The staff were friendly but unfortunately I won't go back.

Excellent service. Food came out hot and yummy. The portions were so large that everyone took some of their dinner home.

Good food . Nice staff . Clean. Very good penne pasta pizza. Quick orders . Definitely a favorite read more

The whole staff is so friendly, from the waitress/cashier to the guys behind the counter! The food is amazing! Yesterday I had the taco pizza, incredible! My hubby and I love to just stop in and eat or grab take out, it's always fast and hot! read more

There's an old saying "pizza is like s&$ even when it's not good it's still pretty good " whoever said that has not tried amatos. Lived in the area most of my life and came back to visit family so we thought we'd finally try it. never tried this place. Pizza was some of the floppiest pizza I've ever had. The flavor was missing , and I mean that literally. Cheese had no bite , sauce had no flavor. Ordered cheesesteaks , again ... zero flavor. I've never had more bland uninspired food. We had a bunch of left over pizza and I've never in my life thrown away leftover pizza. But I made an exception in this case it was that flavorless and floppy. Usually I'll give a place the benefit of the doubt and give them a 2nd chance but this was bad enough to just forget about all together. I only gave 2 stars because the staff was very nice and the restaurant was very very clean. The food however was tasteless and borderline terrible. read more

Fast delivery. Delicious chicken Alfredo. Reasonable prices. I would try them again soon!

The food was PHENOMENAL!!! A lot of places often make their food excessively oily, but Amato's Pizza nailed it! For appetizers, I ordered the Mac and Cheese Balls and Mozzarella Sticks. Both were warm and cheesy and came with steaming marinara sauce! The wait staff was friendly and the environment was welcoming and familial. Definitely my new favorite pizza place. They just earned themselves a lifetime customer!!! read more

Spectacular pizza!!! The special pizzas are amazing The taco pizza is aaaaamazing You definitely can NOT go wrong with Amato's pizza read more

Ok how long can a pizza place review be? Not long lol. Sunday night in the mood for a pizza and wanted to go to Acqua Farina in Newtown, but when I called them it went to a fax machine. So my GF recommend Amato's pizza in Fairless Hills. When we arrived there was plenty of parking and walked inside to a nice clean place with about 10 tables. We sat down and ordered the large Taco Pizza. As we were waiting, drones of people came in for take out and the phone was nonstop. Our pizza came and it was simply beautiful. When I bit into it, the crust was perfect the steak, cheese and ranch dressing complimented each other at just the right amount. The lettuce and tomato were crispy and fresh. Not gonna lie here people, I give this pizza a straight up 5 star and glad we did not go to Acqua's. Great job to Amato's hands down one of the best fresh and tasting pies I have had in a long time. This place is a BYOB and the large pie was $21. Well worth it. I will return. read more

Amato's Pizza - Taco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania