Cancel

Open app

Search

Allstate Insurance Agent: Peter Damato

3.0 (2 reviews)
Open • 9:00 am - 6:00 pm

Allstate Insurance Agent: Peter Damato Insurance Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Allstate Insurance Agent: Peter Damato

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Jay E.
1
59
21

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Allstate Insurance Agent: Peter Damato

You might also consider

DeNapoli Associates Inc- Nationwide Insurance

DeNapoli Associates Inc- Nationwide Insurance

(2 reviews)

The best agency around. I have been insured by the DeNapoli associates for my whole driving career…read more Michael is very knowledgeable. He's always only one phone call away. Very helpful and cheerful when you speak to him and he always has the answer to any question I may have. Feel in very good hands having them insure me. Would highly recommend this agency to anyone looking to be insured through a family friendly and customer oriented company. THE BEST!

After almost 30 years of being a customer of Luke DeNapoli Nationwide Ins. Agency, I had my auto…read moreins lapse, without the ability to be reinstated. I had to shop new auto ins., and eventually had to pay double due to having the lapse. The reason it lapsed? Every month I had my (then trusted) insurance agents make the payment on my behalf, using the stored method of payment I gave them. Apparently one particular month, they used a two year old debit card (which account was closed over a year and 1/2 ago) to make the payment, rather than the method they had used consistently for over a year 1/2! They left me a voicemail saying my pymt was declined, and after getting the message that night I called the bank the next day (because I did not see why it would be declined). Never would I imagine the reason it was declined was due to them putting through payment on a very old card. Of course this was on a Friday when I spoke to the bank, and when the agency was open again it was Monday, two days too late for the timely payment and my policy lapsed. I then called Nationwide HQ and told them of the situation. After I was told that all it would take was a call from the Agency to say that it was their error, I called Luke DeNapoli right away, and was told that they would call HQ. After following up minutes later with HQ, I was then blindsided by them telling HQ that it was NOT their fault. And HQ said that no matter what, the word of the agent is what they go by, and even if the Agency called again to try to reverse/correct what they said, HQ goes by what they initially say and what is done is done. My insurance was cancelled for good. They would not write me another policy (it is their policy that it must be a year after a lapse) and because the whole ordeal took 5 days to straighten out, I had insurance lapse for 5 days. This cost me $75 per day for the lapse with NYS DMV, it also cost me double for a new policy with a new ins company, due to having a lapse in coverage. They cost me hundreds of dollar at that point, and hundreds per year going forward. I also looking into changing my home owners insurance policy, of course because of the auto ins situation, but also because my parents (also long time customers) had been charged more than double they found out for their HO Ins. I went from paying $2642 per year with Nationwide to $1460 per year with Geico. I didnt change earlier because every time I asked my agents why my insurance went from $1200 with my first home to $2642 with my new one (same Sq Ftg) they said because the rates are increasing, I have claims, there are hardly and companies writing HO Ins on LI any more...things of that nature. I was scared! Now, after being screwed by them (again, after almost 30 yrs of being a customer, and most of my family members too!), I am so glad I changed to Geico. I have nothing against Nationwide per say, it is Luke DeNapoli, and his son Michael that took over, that I have the BIGGEST problem with. What personal, kind, trusting service for such a small community as East Northport. I will never understand why they did not defend the truth, that it was their error, not only to be honest but to save a customer of almost 30 years! What the heck did a loyal customer like myself do to deserve being screwed by this lousy agency??? Luke...sorry your son Michael will be running all of your hard-earned business right out the door...if he continues to be an A** to his customers. Shop around everyone! They are way over-priced I am now sadly finding out....and I guess in the end they did me a favor by screwing me....at least I am paying a lot less now!

Allstate Insurance Agent: Peter Damato - insurance - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...