Really good pizza and calzone; nonexistent customer service. I can't tell you how many times I've gone to this establishment and been the only person to speak. No greeting, no interaction, and no thank you. If you insist on letting teenagers be the customer facing representative of your business provide them with these three essentials: training, expectations, and accountability. read more

Both the service and the food were just amazing. Their pizza is so juicy cheesy and delicious. There ambiance was over the top. I would go here every day if I could, it is the bomb. read more

Just moved here from Colorado and tried this place for the first time. Never been a pizza lover so got the wings, however got talked into a Hawaiian pizza (love you Hawaiian islands (Maui)). LET....ME...TELL....YOU!!!!! I AM NOW AN "ALL AMERICAN PIZZA" FAN!!!! This is such a distinct flavor and I LOVE IT!!!! The wings....MELT IN YOUR MOUTH! And again, a very distinct and mild flavor! I will however try the well done wings next time, simply because I'm not a fan of the chicken skin being soft. THANK YOU for making me an ALL AMERICAN PIZZA LOVER!! read more

See all

We love our local All American Pizza! We usually call in our orders, but on-line ordering is available. You can walk in to pick up your order or go through the drive-thru. "The Works" is our favorite, and lately we have been requesting Canadian Bacon added. So yummy! This is our go-to place for great service, accurate orders, and quick response! read more

Good pizza and calzone every time Quick enough 15 minutes and you can go through drive through read more

Order on line... Food was very good and was hot upon picking up at the drive thru... staff was really friendly.. Ordered 4 pizzas and was ready when stated on confirmation email. read more

Great calzone! Pizza didn't disappoint either! 1st time ordering from here. Could have offered Parmesan. Wanted a garden salad, not paying $6. read more

I don't know why this place has bad reviews! I guess it goes along with every other food place in Bethany having opposite reviews. The "good" places suck and the "bad" places are good! I live a mile away and was kind of nervous at first that their pizza was so cheap. Now that I've had it, idk why anyone goes anywhere else for fast pizza! They have super delicious homemade ranch too. Who can pass that up?! One time they even gave me a free pizza (it was late at night) cause someone didn't come pick it up. I'll keep going here for as long as I live here. I recommend a thin crust pizza. Omg. So good. read more

Best Pizza Ever.Nice People,And Sure Does Put Alot of Great Toppings.I'm a Food Inspecter at My Job.This Place Should Get 10 Stars!!! Yummm.

Really good pizza with good prices. The people at the Bethany location are super nice!

The thin crust is amazing! We tried the pepperoni and jalapeño. We tried the cheese bread which was pretty good I wasn't a fan of the calzone but it was decent. read more

He donated pizza owner is very nice we got robbed for our pizza he's basically a god(good at fortnite) gets hella pu$$y. Every shorty that walks in is basically in love with him, he never juju on that beat read more

I always have a great experience here. It takes a little longer then other places but it's always fresh and delicious.

I'm a first time customer of All American Pizza. After getting so mad at Pizza Hut and swearing to never use them again all American pizza sets right beside my work so I called me in a pizza let me say bravo it is absolutely delicious. I will definitely be getting my pizzas from here from now on read more

Great lunch special! 3 toppings and a drink for $4.99. Sweet! I only wish I lived a little closer to All American. I went to the Bethany location. read more

Such good pizza. The cheese is excellent, you definitely can taste the difference it makes. Owner and employees have always been kind at the Bethany location. Great specials as well. read more

Good food and a good price. Usually call in a take out order and it's ready in about 10 minutes. It's pretty no-frills and they don't have wings but the chicken Alfredo pizza is wonderful. read more

Just like a Family own business, friendly and fast!! Thank you for outstanding customer service and good HOT Pizza!

Very good value. And I like the pizza a lot too. Pretty close to Little Caesar's prices with a much better product

First I want to say that we love the pizza here. Great pizza for a great price. That being said, the Bethany store on Rockwell & NW 23rd needs some customer service training. Every time we call in the employees are rude and act if we are disturbing them. Tonight we got the same attitude and when we went to pick up our pizza we figured out what we disturbed...their time scrolling on their cell phones. read more

Pizza is always good, employees are always nice. Large pizza for $5.99!!! Try the calzone and breadsticks they are unbelievable.

Good pizza, good price. I really wish the Bethany location would get cinnamon bread, though!

I was not impressed with the rude service. The employee had no ppl skills and a trained monkey could do a better job. I'd rather pay more and go somewhere else. read more

Pizza is good, but I always have to put it in the oven when I get home, to get the bottom of the crust done to my liking . Top of the crust is fine, but the bottom is always underooked at this location. Not sure why, because the other locations don't seem to have this problem. Everything else is good though read more

Worst experience ever! I will never step foot in that restaurant again. I called ahead, asked for a manager, told them that 4 of the last 5 times I got pizza, the dough was not fully cooked. They told me they would make it extra cooked and it would be ready in 15 minutes. 30 minutes later they handed me a pizza with the dough gooey and the pizza was a mess. Instead of APOLOGIZING for the error the "manager" argued that it was put through twice. I'm sorry but I really don't care how many times you put a pizza through an oven that is obviously not at the right temperature. It's still NOT FULLY COOKED! I'm done. Last chance taken and EPIC FAIL. You all suck. read more

First and last time for me to go to this location! The pizza good. However, the customer service was horrible! Not a good feeling to be laughed at!!!!! Sorry I'm not as perfect as you! read more