I do not understand seeing people at Pot Belly instead of this place. This is easily one of the best sandwiches I have had. I had their signature Huxley. Switched out the horseradish for garlic mustard. I will be back whenever in NYC, I even want to come back again later today for another! read more

ALIDORO - Like the gold wrapper, nice touch - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Manhattan, NY - from its original shop in SoHo, Alidoro has expanded to several locations around NYC (five in Manhattan, one in Queens/LIC), and this one is in the food hall of the Moynihan Train Hall (aka the fancier Penn Station). I've toured my way around much of the sandwich menu, and what differentiates these chi-chi New York-Italian sandwiches from the average deli is the quality of the ingredients: the fresh baked artisanal breads that you can customize with your sandwich, well-sourced meats & cheeses, and house-made spreads that add a touch of sophistication. So far my favorites are the Giovanni (ham & provolone with pesto cream), Gothamist (prosciutto & burrata), and Fratelli (porchetta & mozzarella). I don't find them all to be bangers and some taste pretty mid for the somewhat upscale price, but they're always fresh and always solid, and obviously I like them enough to be a repeat customer. This is a great and convenient spot to grab a sandwich before you board your train! read more

See all

We tried their sandwiches on our way to a concert at madison square. Its great for quick bite after or before a show or game! The sandwiches are decent. A lil bit over priced for what you get but still good if you wanna save time. read more

I love a good sandwich, so I wanted sooo much to love Alidoro... the sandwiches here tout a lot of LEGIT-sounding ingredients and toppings. But the two sandwiches we got were a mixed bag. The prosciutto was without question the saltiest I've ever had. Even paired with mild burrata, the sandwich was inedible. We both tried it and then agreed the only salvation was to pick off the meat to throw in the trash. The pre-set sandwiches on the menu are all spicy. If that's not your jam, you'll have to order a build-your-own, which is probably the better option anyway. If you want a very flavorful but not too spicy or salty meat, get the porchetta. read more

ALIDORO - Big sandwich on focaccia sitting on a 15" laptop. Don't get anything with prosciutto -- it's WAAAY too salty here. - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

For a food spot in Moynihan, Alidoro comes pretty close to its storefront superiors in NYC. I've always adored their sandwiches, when coming to work in the office post-COVID.(#1) I arrived at 1pm on a Wednesday evening and found it fairly quick too. That's a rarity compared to the storefront superiors(#2) and even Chopt nearby. I found the Mona Lisa (made HOT) on the menu. Only difference between now and a few years ago is that smoked mozzarella doesn't exist on any of the menus anymore, but at least I got fresh mozzarella. I decided to get the sandwich on a ciabatta bread(#3). Honestly, while the portion size doesn't match up to the storefront, it was pretty close. It felt nostalgic too. At least now I have a place to return to when transiting through Moynihan in the future. __________________________________________________________________________________ #1) fortunately and unfortunately, the post-COVID in-office visits ceased after July 2022. #2) yes, I'm talking about you, Bryant Park location #3) that was a nostalgic moment way back when #4) I'm paying homage to my former CM Jando (who probably still reads my reviews on the rare occasion even though he's in TX!) read more

ALIDORO - Mona Lisa (get it hot) - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Got the Giovanni sandwich, which was delicious. These sandwiches come at a premium price (around $20), but I think it's worth it for its premium ingredients and eating half of one is pretty filling in itself. read more

This time at the station I decided to try something new. I was pleasantly surprised I am very glad I stopped here. The young lady at the front was very helpful and nice. She answered all my questions with a smile and added some good tips. After i placed my order i received a pager so i could go pick up some other things while i waited. That is much better than just standing waiting to hear your name called. I ordered two sandwiches the Turkey BLT and the Pinocchio. Both were tasty but by far the Pinocchio was a tasty and filling. I do recommend read more

See all

These are some of the best sandwiches in NYC. My usual is The Gothamist: prosciutto, burrata, sun-dried tomato paste, lemon basil pesto $18. The perfect meal for a long Amtrak ride. read more

ALIDORO - The Gothamist, prosciutto, burrata, basil pesto, sun dried tomato past - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This takeout stall located in Penn Station sell superb sandwiches. Service is not so good, but the product is excellent (I requested the black garlic mustard the side and they forgot it, and servers were bored and seemed stoned). The sando was superb: flavorful rare roastbeef is perfectly seasoned and served warm with melted cheese and mushrooms. The truffle aioli is delicious but a tad more would be nice. The semolina roll was fresh and perfectly balanced between its ceisp outer shell and pillowy soft inside. $20 is very high, but such is life in a city with crippling taxes. read more

ALIDORO - Perfectly seasoned rare roast beef - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Grabbed sandwiches to-go a few times now, on the road to Albany for work. Alidoro is my go-to at Moynihan station. Yes, even on a 8:30am train. Bc I save this delicious sando til I get to the boonies with no good food options; I get to feast on my giant Alyssa... makes one miss NYC very much. Always a short line, at the early hours... order, and pick up less than 10 mins. Delicious focaccia bread. Ladies are nice and packs the sandwich well. $18-19, good price for a giant sandwich that could easily be 2 meals for me. lol read more

ALIDORO - Found it - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Overall rating: 2 Price: $18.50 It is so annoying that I intended to go to Maman right next door & I thought to come here instead to try something new. I ordered the Giovanni and there was only 1 person ahead of me. But the wait maybe took 20 or so minutes. When I ate the sandwich it was not good. Subway is better. I didn't taste any pesto like the ingredients suggest & when I went back to get more - the staff gave me a weird look. They ended up giving me a side and I realized it indeed is not pesto. It's barely pesto mayo. I was so unhappy with the sandwich I went next door and got another sandwich at Maman instead. Do not recommend. read more

See all

Have been wanting to try Alidoro for quite some time but didn't realize they had one at the Moynihan Train Station! There's a lot of sandwich options - once you choose your filling, you can select how you want your sandwich prepared (cold or hot) and the type of bread (ciabatta, seeded, whole grain, focaccia). I got the Alidoro cold with focaccia - I would say I'd get the focaccia warm but it helped balance out the hot peppers and hot spread. I've also tried the La Primavera hot with the seeded bread - really love the bread choice but the filling was a bit lacking. Nice to know they have meat lovers and vegetarian options - you can also create your own. read more

ALIDORO - Alidoro cold on focaccia - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered a sandwich the "La Primavera" and they seemed to be so particular about my order, including whether or not I wanted to pickle.about my order, including whether or not I wanted pickle. I took my time and ordered everything that I wanted, including a pickle.I took my time and ordered everything that I wanted, including a pickle. The sandwich that showed up was not the sandwich I ordered except a name only. Some of the extra things that I paid for not there and guess what else... no pickle. So it seems you can't trust a restaurant to use a delivery service because they will charge you extra and never deliver what you pay for. Because it's so hard to return a sandwich after it's been delivered. read more

Wow this place is extremely underrated. This was by far the best italian sandwich I've had in NYC (so far). I got the Fratelli because it was the most expensive item on the menu and it sure had a great ROI - the bread was nice and oily while the meat and spread was packed in perfect proportions. Can't comment much on the service or the ambiance but the food was amazing. read more

ALIDORO - Fratelli - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Sitting in the Moynihan Food Hall, Alidoro is known throughout the city for its sandwiches. Coming here only for the breakfast sandwich, it didn't quite hit the spot for me. That said, coffee works well, the ladies at the cash register were very nice and on point. Taste: 3/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 4/5 Value for money: 3/5 The breakfast sandwich I had: 1) the Maria, the bread was a bit crusty and overly toasted, making me wish I had a brioche bun instead that would have a sweetness to pair with the salty. Coffee is not overly priced versus other areas! read more

Quite possibly some of the best images I've ever eaten in my life. I wanted a hot summer sandwich, but it was not out yet, so I took a little spin on it, and even after myself, the Ivy. It has mortadella whipped ricotta hot honey pesto on focaccia bread, literally, my dream Chef AC really hooked it up for me! My friend got the il sole which was spicy but equally as delicious. There was some type of spicy jam on it. I don't know, but it was a fantastic and the bread out of this world. You guys have to give them a shot at any of their locations! I personally prefer the ambience of the train station myself read more

ALIDORO - The ivy aka HSS on top of il sole - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I keep coming back to this ALIDORO whenever I can! Workers combine expertise with friendly service. Tasty food arrived with a smile. The food exceeded what I imagined. Here's to culinary satisfaction! read more

I wasn't sure if the Alidoro inside Moynihan Train Hall would be as good as the other locations, but my sandwich was delicious! The line moves quickly and my sandwich was ready in a few minutes. There's seating in the adjacent dining hall, but I took my sandwich to go. I ordered the Giovanni; it was so filling, packed with ham, provolone, pesto cream, hot spread, onion, and Arugala. The pesto cream was the best part and added so much flavor. I'll definitely grab lunch here again before my travels! read more

used to love this place when moynihan first opened but it seems they've fallen off. i usually go there when i have time to kill before a train but this time i ordered ahead since i had limited time. they forgot most of what i ordered on the sandwich, 3.50 for burrata, 1.50 for arugula, and .75 for a pickle on the side. the sandwich was literally just prosciutto and sauce. that is extremely unacceptable after paying almost $30 for a sandwich. never got any refund for the items I paid for and didn't get and there was no communication from staff about why those items were missing. read more

ALIDORO - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Note: Make sure you have time before you order, the item takes a wait while to pickup. They are famous for their sandwiches though on this day, I wanted a snack since I didn't eat lunch. I was debating between a sandwich and bombolinis (4 for $7). As it's 3PM, I won't be able to eat a whole sandwich and did not want to carry the leftover in the rain. I decided to get the bombolinis. Since I didn't specify the flavor, the employee ordered 4 pastry cream ones (the other flavor is chocolate hazelnut). I received the buzzer and when it was ready, the buzzer buzzed. Another employee gave me my food at the pickup window. The snack hit the spot and satisfy my hunger. Have to try the sandwiches next time. read more

See all

Had a pretty mediocre breakfast sandwich from here for about $8. I had the Carlo with egg, porchetta, and Parmesan. It was neither sizeable nor outstanding, but it did hit the spot. The porchetta was really tasty but it was overpowered by a passive egg patty that the teeny tiny bun could barely hold. They have quite a few egg sandwiches on the menu for breakfast, all of which with similar combinations of egg/meat/cheese. Honestly for the price I expected something at least 50% larger even given the location. Edit: I just saw another Yelper's pic of the same sandwich that's easily 2x the size of the one I got! What happened this AM?? With that said, the woman working was lovely and I do think they're more known for their lunch sandwiches, so I would consider trying it again. Just really didn't blow me away for breakfast. read more

ALIDORO - Tiny tiny little breakfast sandwich ($8) - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Yesterday was my first time in the new Moynihan Train Hall and I was so impressed with the options at the Food Hall! I was looking for something quick that I could bring on the train with me and the sandwich options looked great at Alidoro! They have cold and warm sandwich options, as well as breakfast sandwiches served before 11. They also have a full coffee/tea bar. I went with the Gothamist sandwich, which is a cold sandwich with prosciutto, burrata, sun dried tomato paste, and lemon basil pesto. You can pick any bread to put it on and I went with the Whole Grain baguette. They give you a buzzer so you know when your order is ready. Mine was ready so quickly, which was great since I didn't have a ton of time before my train. The sandwich was HUGE and definitely big enough for two meals. This would be great for a long train ride. The flavor of the sandwich was PERFECTION. I loved the creamy burrata mixed with the prosciutto and spreads. You can tell they use really high quality ingredients. This is not your average sandwich spot and I'm already dreaming about getting their sandwich again! read more

ALIDORO - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Another Alidoro just opened in the Moynihan Train Station food hall, a major win for anybody traveling through this area. Grabbing a sandwich here for a long train ride is now the smartest possible move to start your trip. The sandwiches remain amazing throughout their rapid expansion, so try anything for a satisfying meal (serving breakfast here too). read more

See all

Best sandwiches in the Rockefeller Center area. The breads are superb and the sandwiches feel inventive and different. My favorite had a lemonish ricotta that was to die for. Highly recommend! read more

Stopped in for a sandwich before the train when there was no line. It's pricey but the portion was decent. At 2pm they had all their ovens off for cleaning so no hot sandwiches were available which was kind of bizarre because half the sandwiches are hot. I went with the spicy sandwich cold then and my fiancé got a turkey sandwich. I'll say both the seeded and the ciabatta bread were hard. We asked for the balsamic vinaigrette on the side and they forgot it but did include napkins at least. Not a bad spot but pricey and takes like 15 minutes so be careful if you are in a rush. read more

Whoever's idea it was to put speck in a soft roll breakfast egg sandwich shouldn't be allowed to make sandwiches anymore. It's not diced up or anything, just one big slab of meat you can't bite through. So you either eat it in one bite or struggle through it. Not something a person on the go should have to deal with. Plus $8 for a can of cold brew coffee, not even nitro. This was from the Moynihan Food Hall Alidoro location, which doesn't have its own Yelp page. I'm not slagging the entire food hall for this terrible sandwich and overpriced coffee. Just you, Alidoro. read more

We got the Enzo and Alidoro and both were delicious. Lots of heat to both of them with is exactly what we were looking for. The ciabatta bread was perfect and what I plan on getting all my sandwiches on in the future. The only reason I removed a star is because this was very pricey at $17 a sandwich. read more

ALIDORO - Alidoro on Ciabatta - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Sitting on an Amtrak train right now discovering that they gave me a completely different sandwich than the one I ordered...no possibility even to go back and get this correct. Somebody probably has the one I ordered, and is as disappointed as I am! read more

We eagerly searched for the best Italian sandwich shop in New York City (according to the Infatuation) and were surprised to come across Alidoro in the Moynihan train terminal. I typically don't associate train halls with quality food, so figured it was worth a shot. The staff was really helpful. They guided us through the menu of hot and cold sandwiches and gave recommendations on meats and breads (none of which I was familiar with except prosciutto and focaccia). We ordered the Alyssa with Porchetta on Foccacia and the Pinocchio on Smonolina. Both very different types of sandwiches - the Alyssa was fresh and airy while the Pinocchio was quite dense and salty. Both great, but depends on your preference. I would certainly come back if looking to grab food and go. No places to sit, it can be pricey ($16 per sandwich), and you need to know what you'll like. read more

See all

During my first visit to Moynihan Train Hall there was just something about Alidoro that made me choose it over its competitors (worth noting that I LOVE their next door neighbor, Maman, and had plenty of time to wait in the bagel line). I'm very glad I did! The very welcoming, professional and proficient cashier kept the line moving without making the experience feel rushed, the folks in that kitchen were hustling, I loved the little buzzers they give you so you know when your order is ready (and to ensure the right bag goes to the right person), and the two women collecting said buzzers and handing out said bags were nice to everyone. That sammy was something else! Even though I didn't get much hint of parmesan on my sandwich (next time I'll sub mozz) this thing was hot and fresh, with delicious bread (awesome crunch and crumb to the crust with a nice bounce to the tender inside), the fluffiest eggs in the business, very generous portion of porchetta for the price, and that hot pepper spread! Bottle. It! Plus the packaging is simple but pretty dope, giving you one last build of anticipation as you pull it out of the bag and unwrap all that goodness. Clearly I'd recommend giving them a go, enough so that I'd cross the street from Penn Station (or pop in if passing by), grab me some Alidoro, and then go on my very merry way. You don't need an Amtrak ticket to give 'em a go, if you're of a mind! read more

ALIDORO - Peep that fancy gold wrapper - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Bought a Pinocchio on Focaccia yesterday and it was absolutely delicious. The bread was slightly crispy on the outside and very fluffy as you sink your teeth into it. The combination of salty prosciutto and sopressata worked amazingly well with the sweetness of the roasted peppers and the brininess of the olive tapenade. The sandwich was large enough that half was enough for lunch. Brought the other half home for dinner, so $15.50 was reasonable price for two delightful meals. read more

ALIDORO - Half of the Pinocchio sandwich I took home - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ordered the porchetta but they gave me the wrong order. Think they gave me the smoked turkey or something. No mozzarella either. While it was still delicious, it wasn't what I ordered, and was also cheaper than what I paid for. Was too much hassle to walk all the way back to exchange it. Plus they were also super busy, so that would've added even more to the wait time. With limited lunch time, that's def a no go. Ultimately left disappointed. Edit: Went back the talked to someone there and they told me it should be the porchetta, just sliced thinly so it's not the usual porchetta that I would be used to seeing. But she said regardless, it was missing the cheese that should be on it, and they remade it for me. Great customer service and really friendly! read more

Ordered 2 cheesesteaks (which are good) and was mistakenly given 2 Italian BLTs (don't enjoy these). Because sandwiches are wrapped I did not discover server mistake until on train. A very disappointing and expensive mistake as was my 20% tip. read more

Alidoro offers the perfect combination of healthy and guilty pleasure. Their sandwiches taste good and the service is always pleasant. The environment is clean and modern. read more

See all

The best, and I mean the best, nitro cold brew. It doesn't get any better. I haven't had anything besides Cold Brew here, and it's amazing. If you're thinking of the best cold brew you've ever had, this is going to be in the list read more

Alidoro was one of the food vendors in Moynihan Train Hall. I had read some good reviews about this NYC chain Italian sandwich shop, so I wanted to try one of the sandwiches. I went with the hot Fratalli sub. It contained porchetta, mozzarella, sweet peppers, arugula, lemon basil presto, and a hot spread in French bread. It was probably one of the best sandwiches I had ever eaten. All the ingredients were in harmony with each other. Finally, the hot spread tied all the ingredients together and gave the sandwich a hot and addictive kick. The only negative was the $18.50 sticker price. I added a diet soda and a bag of potato chips to complete my lunch spread. The next thing I knew, I was paying north of $25 at the cash register for a sandwich meal. read more

I'm very excited about this location in the Moynihan Food Hall. I'm a huge fan of Alidoro and have been to the original and other locations. The meats and cheeses are super fresh and the bread is so delicious. I had the Pinocchi which was made with prosciutto, capicola, fresh mozzarella, olive tapenade and roasted red peppers. Now I can grab a sandwich before heading home and have a delicious sandwich for dinner. It's pricey but convenient and very yummy read more

ALIDORO - View from across Alidoro actually - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Really great sandwiches! I especially love the soft focaccia bread. Beware when they say "spicy." And skip the salads - they were not as good. read more

ALIDORO - Loved the sandwiches, esp the focaccia bread! - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food was delicious. Truly excellent sandwich. Took forever to get. Was told it would take 10-15 minutes. Took more than 20.

Expensive but worth the hype! The burrata sandwich with the hot jam - out of this world! I would say I would buy a jar of the hot jam because it's the best I've ever had. I would love to use some up for charcuterie board. The service isn't so bad- pretty straight forward when ordering. Have to wait a while for the sandwiches during rush hour. But they do have an organized system going so that they're on point with each order. This is located inside the train hall so it can be crowdy and loud but otherwise I would say it's clean and accessible. 10/10! read more