I've been to this location and their second in Chubbuck, both homemade fire A vast variety of bagels to suit your tastes, each one handcrafted for breakfast, lunch, or dinner! Check out some of the unique sides like their pasta salads, an extra carby complement. Service is fast, accurate, and polite. Both locations offer inside seating, although the original spot is larger for lingering. Great spot near the college on 5th Ave read more

Before leaving back to California, I decided to drop in and get some breakfast and a coffee. This place was 3 minutes from my AirBnB. I ordered the Huevos breakfast bagel on a jalapeño cheddar bagel. It was great. I prefer this place than Einstein bagels back home. The coffee I ordered was called the Deja voodoo carmaker, coconut and vanilla that was great too. It's a small place that gets busy. It's a little spot with about 12 tables. Parking can be a little hectic. read more

5th Street Bagelry - Breakfast bagel: Huevos (egg, sliced ham, green chile, and pepper jack cheese) - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

Service is really kind ! Food is soooo goood omg! Bagels taste fresh and unique sandwich options are the cherry on top! It's also super cozy and cute on the inside and out! Definitely try! read more

5th Street Bagelry - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

See all

Friendly and efficient customer service. Fresh, made to order breakfast sandwiches. Take away bagels toasted up and tasted great several days later. Best bagel in Pokey. read more

5th Street Bagelry - Everything, garlic, and sunflower bagels to go! - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

Tasty breakfast sandwiches but make sure you check you beverages before you leave. I ordered Americanos with honey and a little cream and received black only. I was already on the freeway before I realized it. Tough to navigate the one way streets so it was not worth it to turn around. So disappointing. read more

5th street is always so good and fresh! Love this place!! Wish there was one in Boise too!

So whoever wrote the review about you can't fix it if you don't know it's broken was spot on these were amazing bagels and I love the fact that she knows that you can't fix it if you don't know it's broken so many people assume that management or owners are there 24/7 service was great the bagels were light and fluffy and it was pretty pretty busy for a Saturday morning but it was definitely worth it we'll go back if I ever end up in Pocatello again read more

Im addicted. I can't stop guzzling it down. It's so fucking good dude. Go get yourself a BLT on a parmesan bagel. If you're feeling spontaneous throw some sprouts on there. It's delectable. And don't even get me started on a caramel cloud topped with whip cream. I've never tasted such astonishing spectacular perfection in my life. I can't put them down. The atmosphere of this place is so epic. The vibe is super duper cool with the mural and the smell, it's quite splendiferous. All the workers are extraordinarily nice and they get the food out quick. I've never had a complaint. Guarantee i'll never have one. If you love yourself, go to 5th street bagelry. read more

Best bagels in Idaho. Lunch items are especially creative. Staff is friendly and helpful.

We stopped here on our way back to Boise from Lava, wanting a good but quick breakfast for the road. We loved it! You know you hit a good local spot when you walk in and there's a line to the door! I couldn't decide between a 3 little pigs with bacon on an everything bagel, or a Cactus Jack... so I subbed turkey for bacon and got the Cactus Jack on an everything bagel and it hit the spot! With a delicious pickle on the side, too. My boyfriend got a plain bagel with peanut butter and banana, and was absolutely delighted when the gal gave him the option between "crunchy" or "smooth" peanut butter. All in all, the wait wasn't long and after ordering we got our bagels almost right away. We both definitely want to stop by again next time through Poky! read more

5th Street Bagelry - Cactus Jack sub turkey for bacon on a toasted everything bagel! - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

This place has always taken forever to get anything the employees seem to talk a lot about what to do rather than actually getting it done. I got cheddar jalapeño with a shmeer. The bagel was good but instead of a proper slather of cream cheese it was spread lightly like butter on toast. Wtf. If they are charging for cream cheese then why are they skimping on it? Too bad the area is too small town to support a competitor to keep em honest. read more

What an awesome stop! Everything was good, had a pilgrim, chicken salad and club all on bagels. Plus they are open Sunday which worked out great for a stop with our BIG rig, we were able to Park at the bank next door. Above all the strawberry cake was delicious and like eating one of those strawberry shortcake ice cream bars when you were a kid. Great porch for kids and dogs too read more

5th Street Bagelry - Strawberry bar - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

food was alright but the owner (dan? Dave?) was an asshole to me. did not appreciate the tone of voice he approached the situation with. all I wanted was a tomato on my adobo because they are supposed to come with a tomato and he snapped at me. was quite unfortunate read more

Let's just say I have a 5th st budget I love the shop have since I was a young. Girl. As of lately there seems to be a care free vibe, went in for lunch the other day and got the chicken salad and convinced my friend to get the same it's usually the best. We got them and they were made wrong missing ingredients and hardly any chicken salad seemed all I could see where red onion it was super disappointing and to top it off a medium length black hair. I'll definitely think k twice before stopping and definitely won't order chicken salad again. Disappointed I love to support Local and 5th st was my go to. read more

Way better portion sizes (meat, veggies, spreads) than previous owner. Love this place!

Staff was super friendly and food and drink was so yummy . Place was really nice to do some work read more

5th Street Bagelry - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

See all

Pleasant place to be 1st time here. Patio out side seems dog friendly. Brother says he's been here before read more

5th Street Bagelry - Brother son and I - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

Y'all could get some people who actually know wtf they're doing pretty incompetent workers in there told us 10 minutes on the phone and we waited for a damn hour for 3 freaking sandwiches that are supposed to be warm and they're cold as can be.... Pretty damn disappointed with this place lately has gone to shit. read more

Yummy bagels, classic spot, gotta get 1 w cream cheese and 1 w egg n meat. Must stop if you're passing thru

This was my first time coming here, as a bagel fanatic I have been wanting to try it. I got the eggs florentine sandwich on a spinach florentine bagel and it was delicious! I know they have the spinach florentine bagel only on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. I would come back for the sandwich alone, but I also had the iced caramel Cielo latte and I ordered it a little less sweet which was perfect for me. The service was great because it was quick and the employees making the sandwiches were very friendly. The cashier was also friendly and recommended different drinks to me. The ambiance is nice there's music, indoor seating and outdoor seating which is where I chose to sit. I go to school right around the corner and so I will be returning soon! read more

5th Street Bagelry - Caramel Cielo and blueberry bagel with schmear - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

Delicious , and on an Everything bagel. Bagel was perfect, slightly crispy outside and chewy inside. Cool vibe w good background music (Foo Fighters were playing while I waited for my order). read more

Where to start. Besides Blue Sky Bagels, I would have to rate this one as my top favorite bagel places to eat. The Fresh various bagels they make are beyond incredible for words to describe and the filling for each sandwich they make always hit the spot. They provide breakfast and lunch bagel as well as pastries, smears/spreads, and beverages such as orange juice and essential cafe drinks. Their menu has their own twist that makes you know it's from theirs. My Go-to in Pocatello. read more

See all

Ordered ahead paid when I arrived still had to wait for my coffee and bagel sandwich to be made so I go wait on a stool like everybody else difference is I ordered ahead after 5 minutes go by they ring me up again and I say no I already paid they then give me the bag that has been sitting there in front of them the entire time but even if we disregard that the eggacado was bland and the cinnamon toast coffee tasted artificial and nothing like cinnamon toast at least they were affordable and I think that's the main appeal since its on or near campus read more

Stopped here on our drive from Victor to Twin Falls. Amazing bagels and awesome cream cheese selections allowing tons of incredible flavor combinations! Check their web site for the daily specials. On Wednesday, I got the blue cheese bagel and paired it with the huckleberry cream cheese. OMG! It was the perfect trifecta of salty, savory, and sweet. Every element worked together to create a truly unforgettable bagel experience. I wish I had gotten two so I could have one later in the day after our kayak trip. My partner got the onion bagel with honey butter which he also loved. If you are in the area, make sure to stop for a delicious breakfast! read more

5th Street Bagelry - Outside - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

See all

Driving through from Utah to Montana. Stopped for lunch. Absolutely delicious sandwiches. We had the Cactus Jack and the Adobo. Best bagel sandwich we have ever had. Very pleasant staff as well. Hope to come again. read more

This is better than chain bagel shops. I had the jalapeño cheddar breakfast sandwich. Soooo good, and try the 7 layer bar thing, in fact get two! You're welcome read more

In Pocatello on a Sunday and we found ourselves looking for breakfast. Main Street was a ghost town so we headed over to the university district hoping to find something open. We had the dog with us as well so we needed patio seating. 5Th Street Bagelry fit the bill. We ordered two bagel sandwiches, one drip coffee and one specialty latte - our bill was less than $18 - which felt like a great start! Then we sat to eat and we were treated to innovative flavors on fresh delicious bagels. My quiche bagel kept me coming back for more bites even when the first half filled me up. Really yummy - we even picked some bagels to go for breakfast the next day. The drip coffee left a little to be desired, but we are coffee snobs so no points off there. The outdoor seating was lovely and protected from the road. I highly recommend this little spot if you are visiting - I'm sure the locals already know!! read more

5th Street Bagelry - Quiche bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

See all

Have stopped by here several times in recent months and have been happy with everything I've ordered so far. Their menu has plenty of options and no one should have an issue finding something to their liking here. The girls working the counter are awesome and have always been pleasant to talk with and have put our orders together quickly. Parking can be a little tricky given there are only five off-road spots so look for a spot on the side road to the south. read more

I always love eating at this place!! I totally recommend it! I prefer the regular plain bagel but they have so many choices and the other ones I've tried have always been super yummy:) read more

5th Street Bagelry - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

The coffee here is REALLY good and the bagels are yummy too, they are pretty classic in my opinion. The women working here on Friday 6/14/2019 were incredibly kind, patient, and helpful. The atmosphere is lovely as well. Highly recommend to anybody in the area-- we are traveling through on our way to Yellowstone. read more

5th Street Bagelry - Veggie Bagel sans spinach, lettuce, and banana peppers. Super yum! - Bakeries Near Me - Pocatello, Idaho

This was our go to to start our day! We love their bagels their friendliness and quick service! So delicious! Any and each bagels were fresh and delicious!!! Thank you bagelry staff for putting up with not just 1 test but 4 on iPhone! Because we can't speak! You all ROCK! Thank you! read more

When I moved away from Pocatello every time I came home to visit 5th street was first on my list of foods I needed while I was home. The house made bagels are to die for and it always keeps you on your toes with the alternating menu of bagel selection. My go to favorite sandwiches are the Adobo, which is a turkey bacon chipotle styled sandwich and the Pilgrim which also has turkey and the best cranberry cream cheese this side of the Mississippi. The staff is always friendly and accommodating and the atmosphere makes you feel like you've been transferred to the pacific north west. Truly a cozy, delicious spot for breakfast or lunch. One of my all time favorites. I have yet to have a bagel ANYWHERE that is comparable to 5th Street. read more

Great food, even better hands on service from two of the employees we dealt with. We definitely plan on returning! Nicely decorated too. Thanks 5th Street Bagelry!! read more

The food here is amazing. Best breakfast shop in Poky. Everything is moderately priced and they have the best sweet treats options as well.

My favorite summer Saturday morning requires a sunflower toasted with veggie cc. Coffee, homemade bagels, comfortable surroundings, breakfast sandwiches or more... read more

This is a mixed review. As soon as we entered, we were greeted warmly by a great staff. Each of them were friendly and attentive. If it were about the staff friendliness it would be 5 stars and done. But let's face it... it's about the bagels, right?? So... bagels were chewy, schmeer was tasty but quite reserved in the amount they "schmeer" on. I asked for my bagel to be toasted as well. Their idea of toasting is to smash them thin so they fit in a normal drop toaster. Save yourself the trouble and go to Einstein's Bagels if you want a good bagel. Or go to 5th Street for a nice place to sit and eat thin chewy bagels. read more

The food was fantastic and service was very quick My wife got a chicken salad sandwich and I got a turkey sandwich and both of them were very good. read more

We got two delicious lunch sandwiches as we were passing thru on a road trip - t he cream cheese and lox and the veggie. They were both made with fresh, tasty ingredients! I only wish we lived closer so we could go back! read more

I'm so sad I don't live in the area anymore because I miss this place so much!! Anytime I am passing by, I have to make a stop at 5th Street. Anytime I bring people here, they only have nice things to say about the bagels. The Pilgrim is my favorite sandwich (with Asiago bagel) to get and I can't wait to have it again. read more

Good coffee. Terrific bagels. Warm atmosphere. And they're open on Sunday!! But. They could use an efficiency expert on their production line. Several times my toasted bagel (with nothing on it) has been "lost" in the chaos. Why are there 3-5 people making sandwiches/bagels and only one person manning the cash register and making intricate coffee drinks? (sometimes 2-4 of those sandwich people around while the cashier is drowning) Why is there no one tasked with "moving things along"? Before visiting I was warned that the lines could be long, and watching the confusion behind the counter I can see why. Don't mess with the bagels or the coffee or the desserts....but please study up on how to streamline your production/distribution because your employees and customers will appreciate it. read more