Try the Old School Pepperoni Rolls ... Big hit at the Warwood Vets club! Find them on Facebook for…read morehours and menu! Check this place out for sure!

First time dining at Lil Gerardo's. Back in the day, I frequented the original Gerardo's and the…read morepepperoni rolls and the pizza were just as good as I remember. Thanks for keeping this tradition alive!

Love it. A great local hometown favorite. No extra cheese needed this is cheesy enough.read more

Great job on the pizza and sub. Delivery was quick. Thanks…read more So much. I'm trying to add a few more remarks according to the information I'm getting but , haha haha I hope this is enough . Thanks again and appreciate it and thanks again .

This place has been closed for a few years. It's a shame since it had some of the best pizza in the…read morevalley.

My son lived in Martins' Ferry about 10 years ago, and he still talks about how great these pizzas…read moreare. He says they are so much better than any of the regular pizza places most people go to, and affordable. Place was clean, people were friendly. He really liked it.

Their everything pizza was loaded with a ton of extras. BUT, I never saw a pizza shop place an…read moreextra piece of cardboard under the pizza to soak up the grease. You'll definitely get greasy fingers. Keep paper towels handy.

I don't know if it's me, but from NY, this was not good at all. I considered calling authorities to…read morereport and press charges for calling this pizza. I'm trying to be nice Ive never seen a SpongeBob square ass pizza in my life!

I have passed this place several times on National Rd in Bridgeport and decided to give it a try…read more We got the tray of 16 pieces with one topping for $17. I can now say this is my favorite square pizza pick up place in the Valley. Crust was excellent, just enough cheese and sauce. Plus, for a Friday at dinner time, the order was ready quickly! Wish I would have taken a pic before devouring.

First time trying this pizza place up in Wheeling, West Virginia wife and I knew it was gonna be…read moregood. Wasn't used to the loose provolone that they put on top of it so we asked them to melt it for us and they did we tried it first it was a little weird having the cold mozzarella on top of the hot pizza. I highly recommend the spot when I go back up to Wille next year I'll be hitting it again.

No mozzarella cheese in the building, only provolone for everything…read more I will not return. I hope this helps someone make their decision. Thanks for listening.

This place was amazing when it opened. Something has went very wrong. They are always "so busy" and…read morethe food is always delivered super late.Pick up orders are ready 40 minutes after the time it was supposed to be ready. It's ridiculous.

I moved to Saint Clairsville eight months ago. During the busy time of moving and setting up a new…read morehome, we had tons of take out food. We tried all of the pizza shops in town numerous times. Papa D's Pizza consistently beats the competition. I believe they have six employees in total. Every staff member is friendly, courteous and professional. The store is neat and clean. There are several tables for dining in. My wife and I ate there twice. She enjoyed watching HGTV while eating at the pizza shop. I have probably had over twenty take out orders and never encountered a mistake or problem. On one occasion, I ordered a tray five minutes before closing. It was perfect pizza, not old, re-heated pieces. This pizza beats every competitor from here to Wheeling and beyond. The pepperoni rolls are nothing short of awesome. When my son visits from out of state, we order a tray for him to take home. He can't get enough of Papa D's Pizza either.

We always get Patsys when we come up to Wheeling. We usually buy a tray and take some back to…read moreCharleston. Love the tomato sauce and the crispy crust.

Always happy with Patsy's pizza. Affordable and I enjoy that the crust has a little crisp. Always…read moregenerous with toppings and ready to go when you arrive. Have been coming here for as long as I can remember and will continue to visit.

The pizza is exceptional for the same type in the Ohio Valley. It beats DiCarlos and Patsys hands…read moredown.

The sauce is spread too thin. The sauce is what makes the pizza taste good. Put more sauce on…read moreplease !