Nice location and good atmosphere with a great view of the water and being downtown. Drink…read moreselection wasn't bad

Hands down best bar in the area. Owners and staff are welcoming and friendly. The vibe is just…read moreincredibly relaxing. Cocktails are all made from fresh squeezed juices, and now they have a Daiquiri Bar!!! Some nights they have live music, no matter the night, it's a great time!!

As to the person that left a comment about one of the bartenders being drunk, let me just say that…read moreI have frequently visited the island and this establishment. I have had personal interactions with all the bartenders and have never once thought they are drunk. I have also never seen them drink on the clock or behind the bar. 4th of July weekend is one of the busiest weekends for the island. Your servers and bartenders are the ones funding your fun;) treat them with respect. Another comment, male bartender with lots of tattoos, I believe his name is Cody from the interaction I had with him. He does an awesome job and is really making this place something great!

Sand Trap captures the island vibe. It is open air, surrouned by Adirondak chairs and picnic…read moretables, so no matter where you sit you have a good view of putting green and giant Connect Four game for kids. Friendly and attentive staff. Seems to be the "it" place on the island.

this place is sooooo cutie inside! it gets five stars because there's nothing else like it. once…read moreyou walk in you are truly transported!! drinks are good and strong asf (even the ones in safe harbor!!) food is pretty good (people don't come here for the food but it's a plus for sure!) i would suggest having a bite before you leave, don't come hungry. service is consistently pretty mid. i've not have a server really go above and beyond but they get the job done.

WOW, what a fun place…read more Location and Parking is terrible, and there was a person outside asking for whatever you have to give. But once you're past that, this place is a must visit. Something very different from what we normally go to or go for. The tiki vibe is very well done and the drinks are equally thought out as well. Once you arrive, there's reserve seating but otherwise everything else is on your own. The staff is very friendly and the drinks are very tasty and entertaining. I already have plans for when friends/family visit from out of town and take them here. Such a fun and unique place! Go!

Mojito Bay was our very first bar stop on the island. I will say that we were there in late…read moreSeptember, so our experience was much different than it would be in the height of their busy season - it was super quiet on the island and all of the bars we visited were almost completely empty. Honestly it was so nice and relaxing, and I don't think I could handle being at the "Key West of the Midwest" during the summer months! Anyway, Mojito Bay is a cool sandy beach bar with swing seats that specializes in - you guessed it - mojitos. They have a huge menu of different types so I got the "tropical surprise" and Nate got a passionfruit mojito. They load them up with lots of fresh mint and liquor - they were strong and very tasty! The vibe was so beachy and fun, definitely a party spot when it's busier.

Stop 2 on the Put-in-Bay pub crawl. The sand and swings at…read morethe bar were fun but the poor attitudes of the bar staff were not. The drinks were average for paying a premium price. My next visit to the island will not include the Bay. Very disappointed to say the least.

Has the bestie pizza in the are! No reason to ask for…read more"extras", because it is a heavy pizza!

After an unexpected stop at Lagoon Saloon I'm upgrading my last review. The OG's are back! The…read moreOriginal Girls, who take pride in their work and enjoy their jobs, have helped this little river spot get back to what it was and more. Lagoon Saloon has cleaned inside and remodeled their outside bar to make it more seasonal. And they have new menus with the "real" prices. I will definitely be back to enjoy their great pizza.

Great swimming pool and bar open to the public. Lots of seating and lounge chairs. Pool also has a…read morehot tub on one end. On Saturday they have music and a club atmosphere. Great group of bartenders and bouncers to keep everyone happy. They even serve food.

Even on a rainy day, this place was great to lounge at as I enjoyed my frozen cocktail (Miami Vice)…read moreand met new friends at the bar with my husband. The service was top notch, and we really enjoyed ourselves during our first evening on the island.

I loved this place....took so many people here and wanted to have a final hooray with some of the…read morepeople who also appreciated this place. However, that night I recognize why stop coming. The employees. The place has the tiki vibe but the heart was ripped out when they hired a group of people who don't have that spirit of what tiki is about. To me it represents a way of life focused on kindness, unity, humility, patience, and mutual regard. It felt more exclusionary and lack of kindness almost an irritation to be in the service industry. I do hope great things for the owner in the future because he did have something special there. Wish his vision was seen by the employees.

Today is the last day for this place apparently which is probably not fair raiting the place so…read morelow... but drink was subpar. I got a Painkiller. Son got a Mai Tai. No where near a Trader Vic's... most patrons there were rude.

Unless you are a regular - forget this place. Impersonal service. Like you walked into a strangers…read morehouse and asked for a beer. Never offered a menu.

Great spot to have an adult beverage, meet with friends, listen to tunes and watch the river!read more