My wife went in to get some Fudge, while the fam, German Shep (Mando) and I waited outside. (I…read moredidn't check to see if it was pet friendly, I just automatically believe a food-service place wouldn't appreciate a 90 pound dog blowing his coat in the store!) A very nice guy came out and asked a few questions about Mando and showed some affection. Then asked if he could get Mando some ice cream. (I showed him my wife and said she would need to answer as she's a vet tech.) Next thing I know, here comes this exceptional man with a med bowl of vanilla for my pooch. Free. (The Fudge my wife bought was also exceptional!)

Cheap ingredients and cheap hot fudge sauce, hot fudge sauce was cold poured from plastic…read morecontainer, felt ripped off from this place, definitely not premium fresh made ice cream

the employees were very sweet and helpful and there was a wide variety of options. Very affordable…read moreand worth the stop. Only difference is that they close at 9:30 on weekdays

I ordered the Black cherry based on the great reviews and description- it had NO cherries in it…read more When I realized that, I went back up to inquire and they handed me a cup with 5 maraschino cherries to "fix" it. would not recommend it. My sister order it as well and same experience.

Headed over after the Jack Pine Lumberjack show, the ticket stubs had coupons for fudge- Win/Win!…read moreGrabbed pizza from Fox's Den pizza and enjoyed some ice cream. Marshall's staff was friendly & helpful - highly recommend the cherry cordial fudge!

Of all the MANY fudge shops in Mackinaw City (we counted 7!), Marshall's wins our vote. Not only…read moreare they actually making fudge on premises and on display, they are the most welcoming, friendly, and informative shop. The staff all went out of their way to satisfy our curiosity about their vast selection of fudge, candies, chocolates, and flavored popcorn, but they also provided us with tips and ideas of other things to do in the area. A shout-out to Brittany for her fantastic hospitality! We actually went to Marshall's twice!

We loved standing outside and watching them make the fudge from the window. We couldn't be inside…read morevery long because it was very hot standing in there the day we visited. The staff were okay, we felt a little rushed even though there was no line when we came in. But the fudge is amazing- literally the best I ever had. We chose the chocolate cherry to share. Your piece comes wrapped with a tiny wooden knife to cut to share. Staff told us it lasts weeks out of the fridge.

My children are now hooked on fudge. Delicious! Turtle was very good and all the fudge lasts…read moreawhile.

I tried fudge at five different popular shops on the island. I thought Joanne's Fudge was the best…read more It was very soft and creamy. They let you have samples of any of their flavors. All the employees were really nice. They actually have two shops on the island and I bought fudge from both. They also have excellent chocolates. They make the fudge there in the store and you can watch it being made during the day. You won't regret your purchase.

Got two boxes. 1st box of 3: Double dark chocolate, dark chocolate espresso, dark chocolate salted…read morecaramel. 2nd box of 3: Double dark chocolate, dark chocolate raspberry, dark chocolate mint. A bag of salt taffies. Just under $80 Would have liked a dark chocolate with Irish cream or maybe French vanilla for my mom. The raspberry, mint and double chocolate are tasty. You can really smell the chocolate goodness wafting from the store. They were letting a new batch cool some on the counter.

I love their double chocolate expresso fudge. Friendly services. Clean shop. Live fudge making…read moreexperience.

Amazing, fast service and yummy fudge, taffy, and caramel popcorn!…read more As soon as we arrived, the staff behind the counter were so friendly and offered to help us and gave us free samples of the fudge. The fudge samples were a generous amount and so good! We decided on the double dark chocolate fudge, assortment of taffies, and caramel corn (with peanuts). We loved the experience and would recommend it to all tourists of the island!

Not authentic Mackinac Island fudge, fudge had a salty, processed taste. Truly disappointed.read more

This place caught my attention because you have to walk through it to use the restroom if you are…read moreover in Nonna Lisa's or the winery. Nice selection of salt water taffy, candy, caramel corn and ice cream. They even have an arcade. Where they got marked down was that I found the caramel corn that they make in St. Ignace 200 miles away at half the price. I know there is a mark up for the tourist in Mackinaw City but c'mon. I didn't buy any fudge because Joann's has that market cornered. Street parking. Organized and clean. Lackadaisical staff. If you go be ready to pay up.

Delicious! Classic confection shop with that old timey feel…read more The store is located within downtown and is pretty large with high ceilings. Open area to see where they make their sweet treats. Staff are friendly and we chatted with one staff who said she has worked there season after season. Tons of fudge, ice cream, sweet treats, and freshy made waffle cones. I went with the pumpkin ice cream in a waffle bowl and it was heaven! The ice cream so smooth and rich. The waffle bowl was churchy and sweet. It hit the spot! Also got some fudge and it was just as delicious!

My favorite ice cream flavor from Kilwin's is their Mackinac Island Fudge and there was something…read moreso poetic about ordering this flavor (one of my first ice cream cones of the summer season) at the Kilwin's ON Mackinac Island no less! Kilwin's is a Michigan staple that I absolutely LOVE! I live closest to both their Ann Arbor and Plymouth locations, which are the ones I frequent the most, but often times they run out of their Mackinac Island Fudge flavor. I was so glad it was in stock on Mackinac Island AND that this Kilwin's was the largest Kilwin's I've been to yet! There are live fudge demos that you can watch, along with their entire "kitchen" area looking like it's out in the open so you can watch the workers hard at work! They have a massive selection of so many different sweets and treats - so many more offerings than I've ever seen at another Kilwin's too! It was a *treat* to see and always a MUST VISIT stop whenever you find yourself on the island! Love you, Kilwin's! :D