The restaurant was conveniently located near our hotel, and since the one near us in suburban Indianapolis had closed a few years ago (and we missed it), we decided to stop here before leaving town on the Sunday after we'd been in Coralville for a weekend event. The biggest change we noticed was that self-service screens have replaced the write-on sandwich bags for ordering. I kind of miss the bags, but loved the convenience of the screens. There were several stations, and one was open when we walked in, so we were able to walk right up and place our order. There are also many more choices than there used to be, which we loved. I had the Reubenwich and my husband had the Wicked. Both were good. The selection of soft drinks was okay. I was disappointed there wasn't a cherry cola choice (Dr Pepper is not this, I mean like Cherry Coke Zero or similar), so I had the Root Beer, which was a nice change of pace, by not my first choice. The sandwiches were ready fairly quickly, and the seating was comfortable. Our only complaint was that even though the restaurant wasn't very busy, our table hadn't been cleaned off and we had to brush away a few crumbs. I was okay with it this time, but during the height of Covid that would have been a huge deal. read more

We've been to a few other locations and were looking for a good lunch stop. We haven't been to. Which Wich since they started using the touchscreens vs. the bags to order. The computer is easy enough, but does eliminate some of the options. I got the Buffalo Chicken - very good with a nice zing. My wife got the Tuna Salad and added avocado. The avocado was good, but she was underwhelmed by the tuna salad. There wasn't a lot of it, and she didn't think it was as good as what she's had at other locations, and not as good as similar restaurants. The food did come out quickly and was as ordered. Decent stop, but not as good as it used to be.... read more

I have to admit that I wasn't expecting much since it was my first time trying a Which Wich, but my Reuben sandwich was very good. The corned beef was very fresh, the sauerkraut was very nice, not overpowering as it can be sometimes on an inferior sandwich. The 1000 island dressing was mmmm. I'd definitely try it again. Clean restrooms. Clean tables, and a good group working. read more

See all

Really good food. I had the Wicked sandwich and was NOT disappointed. Service was pretty fast and was not super busy so we were in and out quickly. I'll be stopping by if I'm in the area again. read more

Tasty sandwich not too expensive really comparable to jimmy johns but with better food and more options to customize

Solid four star lunch. Tasty sandwich, clean store, not super fast, but fast enough for me. The bread was that kind of puffy kind you get at Subway. read more

Food here is overall really really great I've never had any complaints they always have the perfect mixture of every ingredient. The only thing that makes it not worth it though is the price because you get the small hand sized sandwich for over $8, compared to a nearly footlong sub at subway or jimmy johns. If all of their prices dropped by a dollar I think it be more with it read more

This was a typical experience from this chain. Place seems a bit dated but clean. Sandwiches were good but slow

I wanted to love this place. But it was just meh. I liked the unique ordering system where you take a sandwich bag and mark which one to want on the bag and check if you want chips, drink or both. Then write your name on the bag. Take the bag to the register and they ring up exactly what's on the bag. It's that easy. A machine could probably do it. For a Ruben sandwich, chips and a drink it was $11.13. A bit more than what I would have expected. I would expect a sit down meal for that price. It takes a bit to make your sandwich. Probably 5 minutes because they have to toast it. Once done they package it and stick it in the bag you wrote on. The restaurant inside is pretty straight forward. Basic seating, minimal decor. Once I got my food I left and in 5 minutes was at my hotel. I opened my sandwich and the moisture and heat along with the dressing had made the bread soggy. The Ruben was pretty basic. Nothing that made it better or worse than any Ruben I've ever had. I liked their house chips. They are ruffled chips with sea salt and cracked pepper. I'm just not overly impressed. #1 because of price and #2 my sandwich was nothing special. read more

See all

For chain subs and sandwiches this place rocks. I love they way you order, do it yourself on paper bag. They have great choices from veggies, cheeses, sauces, and meat. I really love that you can really get a quality sandwich your way without wanting something more since they almost have everything. read more

We stopped in to Which Wich on a Saturday afternoon after helping some friends move. I was thoroughly impressed with the menu selection and the delciousness that ensued! It gets some props for having me check off my order on the bag my sandwich is to be served in - very classy! It's a big step up from subway, but definitely still in the fast food realm. Solid ingredients with a ton to choose from and the wonderful option of doubling the meat on your 'wich for around $2. The cuban sandwich was delightful and my best half had something with turkey and avocado. Both solid and worth the price of admission! Standard subway-esk chip and drink selection as well as some bomb cookies when you need just a little sweet at the end. Overall a good place to go for lunch or when you're looking for something that tastes a little fresher than quizno's, but aren't looking to impress anyone. read more

I'm ashamed to admit it that it took me so long to finally get out and try this place. I've been stuck in such a Jimmy Johns rut I did t even know better sandwiches could be had. Cute way to order, marking a paper bag with all your options. Does take a minute, but that is because they are making it with care. The bread is nice and warm and soft, the buffalo chicken was just the right flavor with the melted provolone cheese made it just right. I was so excited to eat it that I forgot to take a picture. I think I've found my new lunch spot, they have so many other flavor and combinations that I want to go back for. read more

Very casual setting. Metal tabletops, cement floor; fairly clean. Ordering is cute: Pick a paper bag and select what you'd like on your sandwich. Lots of toppings to choose from, but there are some asterisked items that are an additional charge, such as avocado, but the items are so few it doesn't really matter. They have 3 different sizes of sandwiches; Small (7'', $5.75), Large (10'', $8.25), and Super (14'', $11.00). Sandwiches come out nice and hot. If you get a drink, you get a plastic cup to take home with you. It's pretty awesome. Sure beats Subway and Jimmy John's. read more

Which Wich - Cute plastic cups you can take home and reuse! - Sandwiches Near Me - Coralville, Iowa

Not sure what is going on here, I have been here before and it was ok. Not tonight... out of several items an well as sandwiches? No ice for soda, couldn't go get bags I guess. Out of 50% of the tea choices, I now realize I why I was the only one there! The only thing I can think is they must be closing and just running inventory out?! Jimmy Johns.... here I come! read more

Was a little put off when the lady took my order with oily gloves on, used the register, took my payment with the gloves on, and then made my sandwich. The sandwiches are always good but could've been a better experience without the gloves. read more

It's a franchise chain, but with above average sandwich ingredients. My favorite: Italian Grinder with Olive Salad. Great salty & meaty combo. Ordering process: take a numbered paper bag, write down on the bag what you want, hand it to the guy/gal who makes your sandwhich. read more

Consistently the best sandwich place in Iowa City. The ordering process (paper bags and menus) is great as is the variety of condiment combinations, etc offered. Like most sandwich places, what sets Whichwich apart is fresh bread. When its toasted, I'm hard pressed to think of a better sandwich . . . read more

Haven't been here in a while and not sure if I will return. The bag menu reduce my choices on the sandwich as well as being out of product. Order the grinder sandwich and they didn't toast it our put the vin and oil on it. Had to wade in the water surrounding the coke machine to get my drink. Was really disappointed. read more

I had gone to the Which Wich in Ankeny last week and it was fantastic so I thought I'd take my daughter. The restaurant was empty and the first girl that helped us was friendly. The second lady was less so. We took our sandwiches to go. My daughters was ok. I had ordered a Thank you Turkey with bacon. It had neither bacon or cranberry sauce. It wasn't good. Think I'll stick to the Ankeny location. read more

Decent subs. Takes absolutely forever though. I was the only person in the place and it still took 15 min to get my sandwich

Great subs. You can really pile the stuff on them and for the same price. I love this "made to order" way of ordering. read more

Sandwhiches are very good. Visited today about 1pm with about eight people here. Six people in front of me to wait for their sandwiches. It took about 13 minutes to get a chicken buffalo sub. Just wanted to give one example of a posible average time frame to expect. Seems slow but a lot goes on these sandwiches I suppose along with the toaster oven and two people working on shift at this time. Customer service is OKAY not fantastic. People do seem to have a good time working here so that seems for better morale and a better quality food experience overall. read more

We had two great sandwiches this evening but the employee with the bad attitude needs to find other employment. Yes, we were unfamiliar with the ordering process but what's with the hostility? It ruined an otherwise fine meal. read more

Was looking for a decent sandwich place for lunch and stumbled on this place. It was my first time going and absolutely loved it. Bella greeted me at the door and then explained how everything worked and answered all of my questions without hesitation. She was super friendly and definitely a reason I will be returning soon. read more

Super good food, only issue is that they were understaffed and it took forever to make my order. It should be common sense to bulk up your staff during the lunch rush hour. They were also out of turkey (which is insane for a sandwich place), but overall the general sandwich was good. read more

Holy cow this place is amazing! Why didn't I try it sooner?!? If you've ever had Planet Sub, this place is very similar. Lots of toppings to choose from, warm, fresh bread. Fast and friendly service even though they were busy. read more

Had south side Philly cheesesteak, first time there, very good sandwich ( could have a larger size). I think ordering on the bags is a waste of time, but that must be there hook. I will go back when in Iowa. read more

I went to which which to try it out since it had good reviews on here. I ordered the Philly which I was excited to try and paid $11 for the large. . nice girls in there working but was the sandwich worth what I could have gone down the road to their competitors and got it for 3 dollars less no. It was like any other sub shops Philly. I did like the way tyou order your sandwich though very innovative. Not a very good sandwich for what you actually pay for it when in all honesty I could have gone to Hy-Vee and got the stuff and made it my self for probably the same price and had left over meat veggie and bun to make a couple more sandwiches. Plus they really didn't ask if i wanted any spices or dressings or anything else on the sandwich. Dissapointment. read more

I guess when you are a chain that serves subs you have to find some way to differentiate yourself. Clearly here it is the ordering process which is probably advantageous when you have a lot of regular customers but cumbersome when you have a lot of new customers because you have to explain it every time. I was disappointed that there were not more pictures available so I could see what the different subs looked like, there was only two pictures on the whole wall. But I muddled through the process and ended up with a slightly better than average sandwich and really an excellent chocolate shake. They do not have one of these shops near where I live, but if they did I would probably split between going here or Subway. read more

Unique ordering process, great service and most importantly excellent subs. I recommend the French dip and the cuban. :)

I wouldn't eat here again on purpose if they paid me. I see a lot of comparison's saying "better than Subway" but I don't even think they manage that. Bad food, bad service, dirty (nasty) inside. read more

Wow I have been missing out. Tried this chain once in California and hated it. Thought i would give it a second shot. unique ordering style allows to not have to wait behind an indecisive person. They have more variety of any sandwich shop i have been to. I went with a muffuleta (which i rarely see outside of the south) and it was great. Prices are fair and as far as sandwich chains goes it is as good as it gets. But the very best part i don't have to go all the way to iowa city for a good snack read more

Better than average which which sandwich shop. Everyone in the family enjoyed their sandwiches here. Floors and tables were were a little dirty after the lunch rush even though the staff wasn't busy during the time we were there otherwise it would be a 5 star rating. read more

Didn't blow me away but it's really darn good. I had the tuna bowl and it was delicious yet healthy. I must say that the peanut butter cookies are fantastic! My wife had the hummus bowl and it was also very, very good. We both had balsamic vinaigrette for dressing. I will definitely be coming back to try out some other items. read more

Filling, fresh, fast, fabulous and inexpensive. I like the personalized order process.

Which Wich is a neat little sandwich shop that I would recommend if you're tired of the typical Subway or Jimmy Johns. It has a pretty cool interior with trendy bar stools and Hawkeye colored paint. The paper bag ordering system they run by is kinda fun and a refreshing change of pace, but their sandwiches are nothing to rave about. If you're looking for a nice treat, Which Wich has great shakes (especially the Chocolate Banana) and tasty homemade chips. read more

1 star for slow service. Ordered 3 sandwiches with no customers ahead of us. Waited 25 minutes to get our sandwiches.

We visited Which Wich while visiting our son who is working in Iowa City and it was GREAT. I would have given them 5 stars but it is a little pricey for sandwiches. It is a fun interactive atmosphere where you get to choose each and every aspect of your sandwich from the size to all the toppings and there are so many to choose from. We had a great time and even my boys got plenty to eat!! read more

I love Which Wich. There are so many good sandwich choices locally that I often forget about Which Wich. This, of course, is a big mistake on my part. If you're tired of the typical deli's then you must try Which Wich. You will be in for a very pleasant surprise. read more

All of the food at Which Wich is absolutely delicious, and their customer service is outstanding. I am a vegetarian and it's really hard to find a restaurant that has a variety of vegetarian options like Which Wich does. I highly recommend the black bean burger. It is also obvious that Which Wich Coralville really emphasizes great customer service. All of the employees are very friendly, and make sure that you are satisfied with your meal. I DEFINITELY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE! read more