This place is amazing! They have it fit for hunters to come and relax with deer, bison, mountain…read morelions and others on the wall. They have a great selection of whiskey including some harder to find stuff like Blantons and higher Crown Royals. The salad bar is one of those great salad bars in roadside steakhouses. The potato salad was great. If I was hungrier I would have gone for the Oreo fluff and a couple other things. I ordered the NY strip steak and fries. The steak was delicious and the fries were good, as well. The bartender and I talked about the area and discussed the bad weather they've been having lately and I asked about Castlewood. One of those great Midwest places!

Very disappointed in this place now, from a year ago. Six of us came for supper. Ordered burgers &…read morefries, and a patty melt and fries. All the burgers were charred and terrible. Fry portions were pathetic. The other disappointment was the service. Our waitress never checked on us, didn't care to ask how everything was, and would rather stand at the bar socializing.

The place was fun and spacious for families. Kids stayed busy with the toys in the corner while we…read morewere enjoying our drinks. They even have mock tail options for pregnant women. The food was good and the service by Jimmy was amazing. Will be back soon!

Not really that great, they tried but are not a true steakhouse......great people that work there…read morebut it kinda missed the mark for the steakhouse theme.....

New Frontier was amazing! I had the pork ribeye and it was hands down the best pork I've ever had…read moreperfectly cooked, flavorful, and seriously memorable. The food was outstanding, the atmosphere was great, and the service made the whole experience even better. Definitely recommend checking this place out if you get the chance.

We had an excellent experience here from start to finish. The food was outstanding -- perfectly…read morecooked, juicy steaks with great portions, creamy garlic mashed potatoes, and bread with butter that honestly beat Texas Roadhouse (and that's saying something). The Smokey Old Fashioned was the perfect finishing touch and one of the best I've had. What really made the night special was getting to meet the owner, who was incredibly kind and welcoming. You can tell they genuinely care about the food and the people who walk through the door. Great food, great drinks, and even better hospitality -- we'll definitely be back.

We came in Friday night for their special which included the salad bar. I have to say, the ribs…read morewere the best I've I've in all of South Dakota. Starting off the salad bar, you can't get a better selection of healthy choices; even had deviled eggs and herring! Now, onto the ribs once again... The ribs were super meaty and tender as well! About the barbecue sauce, was simply amazing. Chef said ribs were smoked for six hours. You could truly smell and taste the hickory. And guess what, it was only for $21 for that half rack you're looking at. Yes, I'll be back!!!!

Decent size place in a small town. I was not expecting much,…read morebut the burger was great and I liked the nice selection of sides. I love the story behind building this place and if in the area again, would definitely come back. Noticed a group of HS girls working on their homework at one of the tables. Seems like a great local spot. I wish this place all best and continued success for many years to come!

There is bar seating and separate family seating…read more I ordered the Monday prime rib sandwich special. It was a generous portion of thick cut prime rib. Served with delicious au jus. The sandwich was plain just bread and beef. But honestly the meat was good enough it was fine. Wife had hamburger steak. Cooked perfect tasted great. Kids had cheese burgers. A bit expensive for a kids meal but great burgers. The fries were delicious. Perfectly cooked crisp on the outside and creamy inside. We also order a side of broccoli. It appeared to be fresh steamed. It was great. None of the food had much salt which is preferred for us. We added just what we wanted. The salad bar was small but good. Not much fixings for the lettuce but a large selection of pasta salads. (And each was different.) and a fruit salad too. It was a Monday so only one person working the bar and restaurant but she did ok keeping up. Would definitely eat here again

If you did not live nearby you'd never know it was here…read more This steakhouse is hidden along the lake and is worth the find. They have some amazing steak and pasta options with a dock to put your boat at if needed.

Pulled up in our pontoon. Sat outside and enjoyed an adult beverage with an order of Trash can…read morenachos. Service was good and the nachos were yummy.

So this place has been around since the 1950s. Now it's not your typical hole in the wall but a…read morewell-kept hole in the wall/restaurant. The steak comes with the salad bar and your choice of potato. The salad bar was pretty good with a lot of choices. The potato not bad as well. But, that ribeye really hit a home run for me! It's one of the best I've had in South Dakota! You guys really know what you're doing when it comes to steaks. The atmosphere is pretty neat but tired looking. The outside overlooks miles and miles farmland. Very beautiful indeed. Thank you for offering such a wonderful experience. Staff are so nice and professional!

A great spot to get a steak dinner near Pickerel Lake in South Dakota! We typically go to The Lodge…read more(same owner) and decided to venture up to Hilltop for our date night this visit. My husband and I sat at the bar and had gin & tonics, a delicious 10oz sirloin steak, potato, and salad bar! We left full and happy and even had leftover steak to make a yummy salad for lunch. We recommend if you're in the area and in need of a comfort meal.

Food and service great! Would recommend. Great option close…read moreto Watertown. Steak cooked to expectations and salad bar yummy.

The steak was tasteless and the service was even worse. Yeah...it's gonna be a while before we try…read morethis place again.

Ate here with my son Ordered a NY Strip and a Ribeye with…read moretwo appetizers Cooked as ordered A bit pricey No alcohol bill came to just below $ 100

I ordered medium prime rib--it was dry and tough to chew--recommend you pass up the prime rib.read more

Love this place! The service is always friendly, and the food is fresh. We ordered the Smoked Gouda…read moreBurger (I added garlic aioli) and the Triple Threat, and both were delicious. It's so nice to have a local spot with genuinely great food when you want to eat out. We'll definitely be back!

Arrived with a starving group of four. Ordered drinks and the appetizer of pub chips. They came out…read morehot and so delicious. We all were in heaven. I ordered the flatiron steak with hash browns and a side salad. The salad had perfectly fresh greens with large slices of cucumber and a couple cherry tomatoes. Couldn't have asked for anything better except maybe a couple croutons. The steak had a bourbon glaze, was cooked to a perfect medium and ever so tender. I had to share a bite with everyone because it was that amazing. The rest of the group was just as happy with their food. Chislic with steak fries, Tuscan pasta with chicken and BOMB burger. Everyone raved. If you are within 30 miles of Castlewood, EAT HERE. You will not be disappointed.