Went here for the first time girl behind the counter explained everything to us perfectly. Met the owner he is very nice polite and professional really enjoys his business. Food was fantastic!!! I hand the large pastrami on rye fantastic, wife had the cheese steak which she ate the entire thing which is very unusual. Thank you for great service and fantastic food. WE WILL BE BACK!!!! read more

Great hot pastrami on rye. We shared the double meat. The sandwich should come with chips.

My cousin and I came here for lunch. The young lady behind the counter was patient as we asked many questions. With a smile on her face, she smiled and allowed us to learn more about US17 NY Deli! The pastrami/corned beef was not only authentic but HUGE! On Rye with light deli mustard, the flavors took me home to NY! My cousin had lox, bagel, & matzah ball soup. Wow soup was robust with noodles and chicken. The matzah ball, however, was on the small side. Overall this was worth the drive!! read more

See all

Overall, this is a great little deli located in a strip shopping plaza on Highway 17 (hence the name). The food is good and the place was clean. Service was friendly enough. This is a good place to.go for a sandwich if you are in Fleming Island, Florida. read more

US 17 NY Deli - Delis Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Great Place!!!! I order the The New York Size Hot Pastrami n I am never disappointed!! The sandwich is huge and filling I eat one half when I get it and save the other for later!!! Plus it always juicy and tender!!! Service is always friendly from the moment you walk through the door! read more

Good news: the place is SUPER clean! Bad news: small portions I had a rueben which was very small a d the bread was just toasted not grilled in butter as it should be. very little dressing and a sad little piece of pickle. Hubby had a pastrami sandwich My son had a turkey sandwich 1 pepsi and 2 waters was $48! Really over priced Wont go back but the mexican restaurant nextdoor looked really good! read more

Nothing to complain about here. Cuban was delicious. The cookie was fresh out of the oven. And the Diet Crean soda was very tasty. Place was clean, the staff were very friendly. I can't wait to go back and try the egg salad sandwich. read more

US 17 NY Deli - Cuban (only half left) & a cookie - Delis Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

I never leave negative reviews, so take this seriously. I ordered the egg salad sandwich ($17!) which was supposed to come with mayo, mustard, salt, pepper, and oregano. What I got was a soggy bread roll drenched in condiment soup with zero seasoning, and service that was equally uninspired. Extremely overpriced for what amounted to a truly joyless eating experience. Hard pass. Two stars because the egg salad itself was edible. read more

US 17 NY Deli - Sad Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

When I saw this place was open, I rushed right over to see if they were a true Sub shop. Well they are in CLAY County. The menu is a bit overwhelming as it appears to be trying to make everyone happy. Offering everything from Ice Cream to Pizza by the slice to All DayBreakfast sandwiches. There a number of other sub shops, that are in Duval county that are by far great sub shops with serious subs that contain twice the amount ingredients on their subs at nearly the same price. The Amoroso Rolls are slightly more narrow than some of the other shop's allowing for a bigger heartier sub. I was surprised by the lack of Giardiniera as a condiment for an Italian sub? The meats on their subs Spicy Italian that I had was very flavorful and fresh. The restaurant was very clean and the service was very prompt and accommodating. I would go back out of convenience instead of traveling all the way to beach or to St Johns county or Riverside for some of my favorite sub shops. But I live west of the Buckman and the US 17 NY Deli is much closer, for those of us who are in search of the ever elusive "Italian Sub, Grinder, Hero, Hoagie, Sandwich" depending on where you are from. Overall good sandwich. read more

US 17 NY Deli - Spicy Italian - Delis Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

HOLY MOLY!!! If you like NY Style Deli's... THIS PLACE RIGHT HERE IS AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS! Being from up North, it's rare to find a place that knows how bring if!! Been here 3x first time there were so many people...we couldn't wait, but let me tell the other 2 experiences were beyond great! The place is clean, the atmosphere simple & food is awesome! FYI: The fully loaded Pastrami/Corned Beef Is 5. I was planning to take a pic but when it came out... I dug in and couldn't stop... next time! read more

The food and service are so good! Got a turkey sandwich for my boyfriend and I and holy crap insane!! Super tasty!! Will be going back! read more

US 17 NY Deli - Delis Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Great sandwiches, service and they have ice cream as well! Much better than any of the chains and so many choices! I will be back!

We were excited to try this new New York-style deli in our community, and the food, for the most part, delivers. The sandwiches are fresh, flavorful, and made with quality ingredients. If you're craving an authentic NYC deli experience, they're doing a great job on taste. My husband ordered a Philly Cheesesteak, which he said was very good! No chips/sides $16.64 I ordered a chicken pesto panini. IMO, not really a panini. It wasn't "panini-pressed." Not a big deal, but it should just be called a grilled chicken sandwich with pesto. The pesto, however, is the other issue. As a main ingredient, the item should be visible without having to hunt for it. As you can see in the photo, the small amount of pesto on the bun is mixed with the shredded lettuce, and there is no pesto on the bottom of the bun near the grilled chicken. $11.44 (7" bun is what the menu says; reality: 5"). Again, no chips/sides. The pricing feels very "New York," ($35.88 for two sandwiches, water and iced tea) and we're not in New York. Additionally, charging for a 12 oz. styrofoam cup of water was surprising (just don't do it! Build it into your other prices, but NO - there should never be a charge for tap water), and $5 for iced tea feels steep for our area. A last-minute add-on of cookies for a friend...$5/cookie!While the food is good, the prices may make it hard for many locals to support it regularly. We truly want to see this business succeed because the food seems to be fresh and quite tasty. Hopefully, some feedback and pricing adjustments, or more value options, could make it more accessible for the community in the long term. read more

See all

Turkey Reuben on sourdough was huge and delicious will be back and the Black / White cookie just like NY.

The main food was excellent would give it 5 stars. The service was also excellent. Now the service bad , overpriced for the sides and drinks. Thought i was getting hash browns and got tater tots and only a few. The side and drink cost more than sandwich. Will go back but not for the sides. Maybe will get it to go. read more

Excellent deli with consistently great service. The pastrami sandwiches are massive and delicious. We've been frequenting this spot since it opened and highly recommend it to anyone seeking a quality meal. The mobile app is also very efficient for quick pickups. read more

I work 2 doors down from them at the storage place and wanted to check them out. EVERYTIME I've walked in there it is VERY CLEAN and the people are SO FRIENDLY and SO PROFESSIONAL I've tried at all different times of the day too. They treat you as though you are the ONLY one there. They actually care and that is very rare to find nowadays. I have tried several different items on their menu and all that I've tried is THE BEST! If you havent checked them out yet YOU HAVE TO! The food is just delicious and the owner happen to be there today SHE IS SO NICE as well!! AGAIN VERY RARE!! IF I COULD GIVE 10 STARS I WOULD! CHECK THEM OUT YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! read more

Portions are tiny for high prices. Menu is massive and they don't seem to know how to properly make any of it. Massive disappointment.

My friend and I met for lunch at US 17 NY deli today and it was a welcome change for anyone looking for a good deli experience. The menu is extensive. everything from soups, salads, sandwiches, pizza, ice cream and more. The sandwich I had was piled with tasty roast beef on fresh bread and my friend enjoyed a true Italian sub sandwich. Both were made to order and arrived quickly. My only wish would be for tables that seated more than 2. Overall a welcome addition to lunchtime choices in our area! We will definitely go back again! read more

I'm not an avid yelper by any means but. This place is great. I love the wide menu selection. Its new so of course its going to work out a few kinks and with a huge rush of customers it'll take longer but that's pretty standard for a new non-chain restaurant. People will complain about the prices but you can't get a five dollar footlong anymore with the current economy. Those days are LONG gone. I have 0 issues paying an extra couple bucks for the incredible amount of meet they put on these sandwiches. My friend had roast beef and he described it as "melt in your mouth" because of how thin it was shaved. I had a rueben with a crazy amount of meat on it. I got the feeling all of the food here is made with love and the owner is super nice and a perfectionist (that might contribute to it being a little slower/overwhelming in the beginning). read more