Cancel

Open app

Search

Tullies Pizza

3.0 (1 review)
Closed • 9:00 am - 9:30 pm

Tullies Pizza Photos

Recommended Reviews - Tullies Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

7 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza - Grab your slice!

The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza

4.2(134 reviews)
5.0 km
•$$

I came to St. Croix for some much-needed R&R and a good, strong dose of sun & surf. Being a man…read morewho appreciates a good pizza, I found The Mill Brick Oven Pizza in short order, and it suits me to a T! Not only is their brick-oven baked pizza excellent, but also the drinks are strong and tasty. The bartenders are attentive, and I have no doubt that if I were to stay here for an extended period, I'd visit here multiple times per week :-) My go-to cocktail here is the "Painkiller". It's good for whatever ails you, and after you've enjoyed a couple of them you wouldn't fuss if you got hit over the head with a mallet ;-) As for pizza recommendations, if you're only looking to try one then "The Shroom" is the one to pick hands down. If you're planning on enjoying more than one pie, then I'd suggest adding "The Wedge" (which is topped with both watermelon and bacon). Wash your pies down with several cold ones, and all will be right with the World!

We decided to check out The Mill since it was close by and open on Sunday, December 28…read more There were three of us. My son ordered the wings, my cousin ordered the cheesy garlic bread (I believe that's what it's called), and I had the Cruzan Confusion. The wings were good, though I personally would've liked them fried a bit harder. The garlic cheesy bread was also good, and my drink was enjoyable as well. One issue we experienced was with the billing. We were a party of three, but my son and I were on one bill while my cousin was on a separate bill. The waitress provided two clipboards, yet the charges were still mixed up and placed on the wrong bills. Although she corrected it, it wasn't an easy fix. Additionally, the wait time to receive and pay the bill was longer than expected. It did get busy, and it seemed like the waitress struggled a bit with multitasking. On a positive note, the ambience is really nice. As shown in my photo, you can see the water while seated, which adds to the overall experience. Will I return? I'm not sure, as I'm only back home in St. Croix for a week and want to try other spots. However, if you're on the island, it's still worth checking out.

Photos
The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza - Your seat is waiting!

Your seat is waiting!

The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza - Rum cakes.

Rum cakes.

The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza - Frozen cocktail

See all

Frozen cocktail

Tullies Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...