The pizza was really good. We tried some new menu items and were pleased. The restaurant was clean…read moreand the people there were very friendly and courteous.

I believe this is a Mexican restaurant!! Communication is terrible. Think you should change the…read morename of business to a Los something

We came here for lunch on our weekend getaway. We were immediately greeted my Cash. He was very…read morefriendly and polite. He gave us the option to sit wherever we wanted. Once sat he came over and told us what the have and old us about the pizzas. The ambience is fun and a lot for the kids to see and do, including arcades and a chalk wall. Take a look around. It will bring a smile to your face. I like how they all come in the 14" size and you can mix and match. We had half supreme and half buffalo. This pizza was amazing. Hot, flavorful and perfect. The excellent friendly service was throughout the elite meal. Cash even brought out a new frosty mug for my wife's beer they only come in cans and bottles). Next time we are in town, we will be back.

I just happened to drive by this spot on my way home from a roadtrip. I thought I could jump out…read morereal quick and grab a pizza to take home to my kiddos. I ordered at the takeout counter and was then told it be 30-40 minutes which I did not expect so I sat down for a muffuletta dip and root beer float while I waited. The service was quick and courteous even after I had a moment when I first learned of the wait time for the pizza. The ambiance was a very cute hippie vibe and the food was fresh, unique and delicious. The pizza was absolutely worth the wait, in fact, I would go out of my way to pop in again should I ever be in the neighborhood, yes, it was that good!

9.0/10 Great pizza…read more We got the margarita. The sauce is absolutely amazing, and you can tell it's made with quality ingredients. Dough melts in your mouth. Even better, people walking by couldn't help but notice--the aroma filled the air and smelled incredible. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.

We had three pizzas that were all delicious but the black goat was the highlight! The only reason I…read moretook a star away is for the space. Very awkward, tight walk to the bathroom and you have to walk through the kitchen to get there. The whole restaurant is tiny so when you walk in with a big party there's no place to stand and wait without it being very awkward. However, the pizzas more than made up for the inconvenience and this will be our first stop on our next trip back to Ellijay!

The absolute BEST pizza ever!! Owner is really passionate about this business and it's nice to see…read morethe same people every time.

Pappys has the best pizza in Adairsville, and the atmosphere is so good. The owners are wonderful…read morepeople. Bingo night is so much fun.

Best pizza I've had in a long time. I'm so glad we found this spot after visiting a relative that…read morelives near the area. This is real authentic pizza with a real authentic Italian family. They're very good people and they know their craft. Phone order was easy to make and food was ready when they said, service is great. It's a must stop if you're ever near the area. Even worth going out of the way.

Best pizza we've had up in the mountains. It's far better than options in Blairsville, Young…read moreHarris, Hayesville, and Haiwassee - we've had em all... We drove over from YH and it was worth the drive. Super small inside, so plan to order ahead and pick up to go. We ordered the Goodfella (red sauce, cup pepp, sausage, onions, and banana peppers) crispy. It had no flop and undercarriage was perfect. Ingredients are of high quality and crust was banging good. Make the trip if u love good pizza.

Next to Cava I ordered a 12" meatball sub. It's very tasty & not messy to eat. I couldn't find the…read moreexact ingredients & left before asking but the meatballs don't look like beef. Didn't take away from the flavor. Plenty of seating for big or small groups. Note: 3% charge applied when paying with credit card

Went here on a weeknight with a friend. The place is actually pretty small. The ambiance is very…read morelaid back and relaxed. We were seated promptly and given menus. We were first asked what we wanted to drink and ordered a glass of House red wine and a Coke Zero. The red wine was brought to the table but my Coke Zero was not. We had a different waiter come by to the table and she was super nice. We never got her name though. I explained to her I never got my soda and she apologized and brought it promptly. The menu had pizza, salad and subs from what I can remember. They also have lunch specials. We ordered a half Deluxe and half Vegetable and a Margherita. There was so little meat on the Deluxe I couldn't tell the difference from the vegetable. We also ordered a small Caesar Salad which was enough for both of us to share. The salad was really cold and refreshing. So many people had been raving about this place. It was good but it wasn't great. It isn't exactly NY pizza either - although pretty close. The undercarriage of the pizza had that slight char and when you folded it to eat, there was that oil drip out of the crust. That's about all the similarities to a NY slice that it had. The table had red pepper flakes but no Garlic Powder. Before anyone comes for me - I grew up in NYC, The Bronx and Queens. I would say it was more like 3.5 stars. The staff is friendly. The pizza was pretty good. The salad was good. My friend said that the House wine was "really good". I would say it's worth a try. Most people I've spoken to love their pizza. It might just be I'm a bit of a pizza snob. I have yet to find a NY slice. But that's hard to replicate when the water is different. My friend that also grew up in NY/NJ loved the pizza. You should go get a slice and decide for yourself. You might love it too!

I always like to go to locally owned places. It's better to keep your dollars running around your…read moreneighborhood than off buying somebody a yacht. That being said, we called in order in my phone. Very friendly over the phone service. Explained the deals they had because this was the first time you'd ever ordered from here. Drove down to pick it up 20 minutes later. Okay as instructed and boom pizza's done in the box. Hot and fresh ready to go. Took them home for the four of us. Bottom line is they were perfect. We got a meat lovers and a supreme crust was crispy. Not overdone. Lots of toppings. End-to-end great flavors. We enjoyed our dinner. Now. Tomorrow morning I've got two pieces for cold pizza for breakfast. We will definitely be coming back.

If you like bland pizza, this is the place to go. If you like slow service, this is the place to…read morego. If you want overpriced pizza, this is the place to go. If you want to be waited on by the hard working owner, this is the place to go. If you want a warm, inviting place to dine-in, this is not the place to go, it's strictly takeout. Why the two stars? Because, despite the poor food quality, it's clear to me the guy that owns this place is trying. I'll give him more opportunities to increase his stars. At least until I see no improvement.

Pizza was delicious. Labor Day weekend, had to wait a little longer than expected but always worth…read morethe wait. IYKYK - heart and soul into every pizza. Staff is more patient than they should be - and we completely appreciate all they do to serve the community. If you want homestyle pizza, worth any wait, this is your place. Open on Labor Day Sunday is not typical so THANK YOU! Our pizza was delicious!!

I was only in the area for a few days. The rain deterred my exploration efforts but I still needed…read morefood. Found this place on Uber Eats, was rated #2. The competition can't be too stiff. The cinnamon knots were great and that's where it ends. The Meat Lovers pizza was fair, the garlic knots were soggy from butter overkill, and the Sprite and Barq's Root Beer tasted flat and watered down. Mind you, I ordered them with no ice! However the biggest disappointment was the Margherita Pizza. I opted for the vegan crust, which was doughy and stuck to the box upon arrival. Taste wise, it was hard to distinguish between the two. There's a picture included, so just know, it actually tasted worser than it looked. For $94.00, I expected so much more. I truly feel as though I was robbed without a gun.

Delicious pizza and Greek salad. Very clean restaurant with Great atmosphere Would highly…read morerecommend!

Excellent gluten free pizza and Italian salad. Friendly servers. Reasonably priced…read moreClose to our campsite. Not much ambiance

Food: we ordered a 10 inch pepperoni pizza. It was freshly made in a wood fire oven. Delicious…read moreflavor, fresh ingredients and super crispy. Service: Order & pay at the counter. Cash or credit cards. Then Grab a seat and your drink(s) from the cooler and the staff will bring you the order. Nothing fancy, just great pizza. Ambience: Small & cozy. Self sitting. Parking: plenty of parking. I recommend & Will definitely return.

Cartecay River Pizza Company was phenomenal! I was staying at a cabin about 10 minutes away and…read moredecided to give this place a try .. and I'm so glad I did! I ordered two large Meat Lovers pizzas, and they were SO good. I didn't even realize they were brick-oven cooked, which made me love them even more! The prices were great, the food was delicious, and the inside had such a cozy, homey vibe. The river is also right behind the restaurant, and if we had more time, I definitely would've gone tubing! 10/10 would recommend. Thanks for the delicious food!