Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Treasure Island Marina

    3.7 (3 reviews)

    Treasure Island Marina Photos

    More like Treasure Island Marina

    Recommended Reviews - Treasure Island Marina

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Don K.
    1
    29
    136

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Marinas 613 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Matt's Marina - Floating docks

    Matt's Marina

    (2 reviews)

    I recently acquired a Catalina 25, and was moving it from Bellmore to his marina earlier this week…read more (Unbeknownst to me, the boat had some engine issues and was covered in three years of barnacles.) It was slow going and we were very late showing up to Matt's Marina. Not only were they so nice to me when my plans kept changing, but were accommodating when I showed up late and a bit frazzled from having such a tough boat move. The guys there helped 1) securely store my sailboat on their limited open dock space overnight and 2) take it out of the water first thing the next day. They reported back on the condition of the boat and necessary repairs before they got started with anything. They did hours upon HOURS of MASSIVE barnacle removal, which is a thankless and dirty job, all so I can move my boat to it's North Shore location later this week. They even did a walk-through and reviewed the condition of the hull with me after the barnacles were off and it was fully power-washed, pointing out the next steps for repairs and how to best handle it. These are some REALLY good people on the South Shore, and I would recommend them to anyone. Great crew, nice guys, and have a sense of humor if you're like me and have no idea what you're doing. It's all a learning experience. Thank you guys for being so cool and helping a girl out!

    First time using Matt's Marina, had them put a brand new 2024 90hp Suzuki on my boat. Great service…read moreand really a nice experience to work with a true boat mechanic. Everything went as I was told and the new engine works great. If you haven't tried them, definitely give them a try.

    Open Bay Marina & Wave Armor Dealer

    Open Bay Marina & Wave Armor Dealer

    (5 reviews)

    What a gem of a marina! The facilities are spotless. The slips are immaculately maintained. The…read morepeople who work there are so very helpful. Johnny, especially, is the nicest guy. The owner, Cliff, is truly a class act. And the location is very convenient whether you're going out to a restaurant, fishing, cruising around or going off shore. Finally, the view of the bay is amazing.

    I have been boating for over 20 years, the norm in the industry, in the area, has become, "go…read morewhere you get ripped off the least". That is not the case at Open Bay Marina. Chris runs an uber professional outfit: I was basically deciding whether or not I would be getting out of boating. I had tried out numerous marinas on the same BLOCK. All of which, I was inherently dissatisfied with the sercice. Not only does Chris GO OUT of his way to satisfy his customers, he goes above and beyond. I am the only small boat on a jetski dock, Chris is ALWAYS ensuring I am satisfied with my service at Open Bay. I have never ever felt like a customer here. He truly has his marina members best interests at heart. If I even think my motor is running rough, I hardly have to mention it. All of the other marinas in the area are truly a waste of time. I strongly suggest NOT trying out your hard earned money anywhere else. This marina is owned by a stand up, /true to their word family, Open Bay Marina is a great addition to the south shore boating community. I will continue to give them my business and recommend their services to others.

    Amity Harbor Marine

    Amity Harbor Marine

    (21 reviews)

    Worst customer service. I sold a boat through Amity and the owner "Ron" (refused to tell me his…read morelast name) refuses to mail a check or wire the funds from the sale of the boat. He said I had to come personally to pick up a check from their office. I explained that I lived far away (over 2 hours drive each way), work full time, and have a family. He refused to budge, citing potential fraud. I asked he mail the check to the address on the title, or wire the funds to me directly, and that I would waive any liability related to fraud in writing with him. "Ron" would not budge. I spoke with the sales agent, John Noonan, and said "what if I sold the boat because I moved to California, would you make me fly in to pick up the check?" He said "yes". Both just kept repeating themselves over and over about their "policy". FYI: when Amity needed money from me for storage fees, it happily handled the transaction through mail or on line and I certainly did not make Amity come to my house to pick up the check.

    should have choice to pick no stars,,bought used grady white..long story short had to pull teeth to…read moreget call backs, had to drive down there app 5 times to address issues because of useless office help..upon picking boat up..it was uncovered in marina right along montauk hwy...boat was fithy with road slash falling down on open bow rider...oh it gets better...200 yds in canal upon delivery , boat dies...no fuel..morons have me take delivery of fithy disgusting boat with no fuel..no idea how these clowns remain in business inept ..

    Treasure Island Marina - marinas - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...