While scrolling social media one evening, I stumbled across a heated debate about who makes the…read morebest peanut butter pie in Central PA. This conversation was clearly MADE for me. As someone who takes peanut butter desserts perhaps a little more seriously than the average human being, I immediately started making a list of the top contenders. Oak Grove Farms kept popping up, so when I found myself with a free rainy Saturday afternoon, it became time for an official Peanut Butter Pie Procurement Mission. Now, Oak Grove Farms offers way more than peanut butter pie. Their farm market is stocked with fresh produce, baked goods, meats, dairy products, locally made items and all kinds of other goodies. But this particular Yelp review? This mission? Laser-focused on peanut butter pie. Before leaving home, I called to make sure I wouldn't drive over only to discover they'd sold out. The nice lady who answered the phone happily confirmed they still had peanut butter pie available. Mission status: ON! When I arrived, I was actually surprised by how busy the farm market was despite the rainy weather. Apparently a little rain isn't enough to keep folks away from Oak Grove, which is always a good sign. I walked straight inside and made an immediate beeline for the refrigerated pie case. There were only two individual slices of peanut butter pie left, so I grabbed one before anyone else could beat me to it. They also had half and whole pies available, but let's try to exercise at least a little self-control on the first visit. The damage? A whopping $2.49 for a slice of peanut butter pie. I actually laughed. That's almost suspiciously affordable these days. As I was heading toward the register, I made the mistake of walking past the whoopie pies. Or perhaps the best decision of the day. Five minutes later, I was walking out with not only my peanut butter pie but also a Shoofly Whoopie Pie for another $2.50. My picnic dessert situation had officially escalated. Fast forward a few hours...dinner was over. It was dessert time. The peanut butter pie absolutely lived up to the hype! The filling was light and fluffy while still delivering a rich peanut butter flavor in every bite. I'm usually not the biggest fan of chocolate cookie crusts on peanut butter pie because I think they sometimes overpower the filling, but this one worked beautifully. Even the little dollops of whipped topping around the edge added just the right finishing touch. This one has officially earned a spot near the top of my Central PA peanut butter pie rankings! And then...the Shoofly Whoopie Pie. I honestly bought it because I'd never seen one before and curiosity got the better of me. And, I'm really glad it did! It was incredibly moist with a rich molasses flavor that came through beautifully without being overwhelming. It was unlike any whoopie pie I've had before, and easily one of my favorite varieties I've tried in quite a while. Mission accomplished! While Oak Grove Farms is clearly much more than just a destination for desserts, this peanut butter pie expedition was an overwhelming success. Next time I'll spend more time exploring everything else the market has to offer. But let's be honest...I'll probably leave with another slice o

They have a wonderful display of vegetables and soups lots to pick one.The pies are the best I have…read moreever gotten

Market including locally sourced and small batch charcuterie, pasta, sauces, condiments, meat and…read moredairy items ... and of course the best fresh baked bread and pasties. Anything I've ever had her was top shelf. The folks are super sweet, kind and helpful. There's a laidback vibe that makes you just wanna grab a seat, sip on some coffee, snack on a pastry and read a little ... almost feels like you're in Europe and you'll forget the hustle and bustle of your day to day for sure!

I love talking breads, they carry an awesome selection of local cheeses and meats, in addition to…read moretheir own artesian baked goods and great bread! The ambience echo's and can be loud if there are people seated or children. Good service, and warm welcome from staff with great knowledge of their products. The honey + Brie on ciabatta was delightful, it's hard to find a good ciabatta that won't break your teeth, I wanted another one immediately when I finished it, it was THAT good! No wifi is available, and it's hard to get your hot spot working with limited service in the building- keep that in mind if you're trying to get some work done!

This is a fantastic family run seasonal establishment. They feature farm grown fruits and…read morevegetables as well as pick your own opportunities. They have a small ice cream shop that has an assortment of snacks as well as hand dipped options. If you're in the area you should stop by and check it out!

Such an adorable place! Fun to pick strawberries, eat sweet treats and enjoy the outside ambience…read more Plan to stay at least 2 hours and take home strawberry milkshakes for those who couldn't make it. The hand dipped ice cream cones look amazing!

Our family has picked strawberries at Naylor's for years! I have taken my children picking there…read moresince they could toddle. We have made many wonderful memories at Naylor's and bought many tasty strawberries. Great place with friendly owners and staff. Very family orientated and kid friendly (though children should be well mannered and respectful of the plants, farm, and other people).

From the owner: Naylor's Produce is a family-owned fruit farm specializing in fresh wholesale fruit. Turning it's…read morefocus to Pick Your Own farming, you will find the farm growing year after year.

Delicious apples! Best cucumbers and tomatoes when they are available! Good watermelons too!read more

Great place, Always enjoy the drive. Corn is outstanding.read more

For the past 20 years I have been driving almost an hour to get strawberries at Shenks. Their…read moreberries taste better than anywhere else, the pick your own setup is wonderful, and the people are top notch. They are such a kind and welcoming group. Definitely worth visiting

I really like this place, you can pick your own strawberries, blueberries, and black and red…read moreraspberries when they are in season, usually May and June, sometimes into the beginning of July. They take credit cards, checks, or cash. Usually the fruit is about a dollar or two less than if you buy it in a market because you're picking your own. They told me they do have to use some sort of treatment for the plants to avoid fungus but try to use as little as possible.

Amish fruit vegetable store, not cheap but very fresh and good quality…read more Saw fruits vegetables flowers baked goods.

This is a long overdue post but I got all my wedding flowers here - bouquets, ferns, and bucket of…read moreflowers. It was an October wedding and the selection was amazing. I showed them some inspiration pics and the outcome was better than expected!! They were super great to work with, the pricing was great, and everything looked amazing! You will not be disappointed!!!

My friend invited me to a late season strawberry picking session at Cross the Creek Farm. I was…read moreimpressed with how well their operation is run. It appears to be a family affair. Mother is out and about talking to pickers and offering suggestions, while daughters check people in and out. The farm uses a flag system to show where the previous pickers left off. This means that the next group of pickers can get started right away where berries have not been picked. There's nothing worse than trying to pick in a section that has already been picked over. The farm offers already picked berries as well. There is a steep price difference between those you pick yourself and those that are picked for you. The berries tasted incredible. The berries are on a slight hill with lower rows between them. This meant that while you had to get down to pick them, you didn't have to crawl. Simply sitting, crouching or getting on your knees would suffice. Overall, I was very pleased with Cross the Creek Farm's product and prices and how easy they made strawberry picking. I will definitely be back next year.

Yummy strawberry's are looking delicious this year can't wait to dig in!! Thanks for All of your…read morehelp and hard work so that I can pick and enjoy! I appreciate it! Susie Singer Realtor

Wow. This place is...crazy...in the best possible way. Mt. Airy Orchards was recommended by a…read moreneighbor who is a regular customer. In this instance, we were on the hunt for apple cider donuts. We found the donuts (delicious!) and a whole lot more. True to the name, Mt Airy is a working orchard and farm with a very impressive farm store operation. On this fall day, there was a dizzying selection of produce, baked goods, frozen prepared foods (pies and more), gourds, pumpkins, apples, and much more. There are apparently pick your own opportunities as well. Parking is plentiful and Mt Airy is well-staffed with a very friendly team of folks. The farm store is immaculate. Note that Mt Airy is in a very rural area off winding, narrow roads. Pay attention to your GPS and drive carefully. Highly recommend this York County gem.

I'm giving this place two stars because I feel like they can improve. Starting off with the food…read morewas OK for the pricing. I just wish the people handling the food could wear gloves. I seen man digging in his ears and then pass me my fries. On top of the chaotic mess of six teenagers trying to figure out whose food goes to who. I will give the venue five stars for the scenery. But after I got done with Apple picking that's when it really gets a low score for me the three ladies at the end of the hill that weighs what you picked were really extremely rude, unprofessional, and inhospitable. Yelling at the children that were in my party. Asking if we were gonna pay for things and not in a polite tone. On top of who looks like a manager because she wasn't wearing the same color shirt as the other ladies, but was sitting in a chair really didn't do anything and allowed those other two to keep talking to us the way that they did. So when somebody in my party had to address their behavior to them because of how they were addressing the children in my group. they started playing victim. Saying they were confused about what was going on after we asked them several times to give us a second so my party can get the kids that were with us together. Wish I had a better ending to this day, but sadly it did not. PS. the popcorn here is delicious