Been wanting to try this pizza place for weeks, so glad we finally did! We only waited about 10 minutes on a Saturday night at 8 pm - it's busy, but not crowded, so you should be able to walk right in. Lots of the tables here are communal which is actually nice and social - we had a great conversation with our tablemates toward the end of our meal. The Herb Garden has a modest selection of wine and beer, wine glasses come in three sizes. After my glass of white wine, we ordered a tomato basil mozzarella salad to share, and then I got the #6 pizza (broccoli, pecorino, walnut, gorgonzola, thyme).
First of all - these pizzas are big. I doubt you'll be able to finish one on your own, whoever you are - I couldn't, but I REALLY wanted to because it was so delicious! The crust was crispy with that pleasant char taste from their powerful oven. The gorgonzola gave a wonderfully strong flavor, and the broccoli was abundant. All the pizzas come with a tomato sauce base even if it doesn't say that on the menu (the word "tomato" means fresh tomatoes, tomato sauce is a given). Pizzas are divided into... I think about 8 small triangular pieces?
The salad was good too - a small portion for the price, but fresh and the basil tasted wonderful (did they grow it in their "herb garden??" I think so, you can see herbs literally growing in a sort of greenhouse along one wall). My boyfriend got the #9 with three kinds of meat and loved it. I think mine was better (less salty, cured meats are delicious but quite salty always). It was totally addictive, even once I was full I kept picking at it, wishing I could eat it. Go with more than one other person and try more things - three people could share two pizzas and a large salad. Just two people and you won't finish all your food. The couple next to us got the calzone on special and it was MASSIVE (and apparently very spicy!) so don't get that all to yourself either. Can't wait to come back and try more pizza - service is friendly, food is great! Right up there with Cal's Own for great Newcastle pizza. read more