I got the blueberry cheesecake (favorite) and the peach. Both were Fantastic!!!…read more Then, I got the blueberry cheesecake and creme brulee in a cone. Best taste ever!!!!!!! I'm so in love with this place. The service is also really fast. They have a clean bathroom here. I found outdoor and indoor options for eating and plenty of parking. Definitely coming back!!!

Literally the best ice cream i have ever had. We tried a few flavors and had to stop bc it was…read moregetting harder to decide the more we tried.

I ended up at Rock Salt Milk Bar by complete accident. I was visiting Newnan, parked right in front…read moreof it, saw they were open... and figured why not. It's a small spot with a few tables inside and even fewer outside. There's a long bar displaying all their ice cream flavors, and they offer free samples, which I definitely took advantage of. I ended up getting a small scoop of the Fig, Honey, and Ricotta--and trust me, it's good. Unique, not overly sweet, and just really well done. If you're in the area and looking for something sweet, I'd definitely recommend stopping in.

Enjoyed a short stop here on my way back up to Atlanta! They've got some unique flavors like…read moreblackberry earl grey and some normal flavors like dark chocolate - I sampled a couple and while some of the flavors sounded interesting, the more complex flavors fell a little short in carrying a strong flavor. I ultimately went with caramel apple without trying it, but it was great! Solid flavor and I loved the chunks of apple that I got. I was extremely tempted to get at least a medium because the prices here are amazing compared to in the city (a small was $3.91 in total), but I didn't have the stomach to eat more than a small. Next time I'll come prepared to enjoy more haha. Plenty of street parking!

Remains my happy place! Besides ice cream, there are other fried treats to be had -- corn dogs,…read moretots, Oreos, the list goes on. Service is always fast and super friendly. The new setup is nice and glad to see them recovering so well from the fire.

If you haven't visited AGW since the remodel, this is your sign! Go today :) it's so great to see…read morethe new candy displays that bring back childhood candy nostalgia and the extra ice cream choices. Super friendly staff :) and my girls also love the arcade behind the ice cream shop

We love this place the rolled ice cream is the best!! I love the banana split with the fruit all…read morechopped into it! Parking can be tough but it's worth it !

This is downtown it cute area. I love the downtown area looks the old buildings. The service was…read moregood & fast. I didn't get any food. The drinks are very very Good. FYI: parking is very limited because it downtown. So be prepared to walk. It's worth the walk with the cute scenery.

Their unique recipe for frozen custard is way more creamy and dense than Culver's or others that…read moreI've tried. I find it a really delightful experience. Always busy, for a reason. Very family oriented. Always happy to visit whenever I am in the area. I would go out of my way.

Great and quick service, always friendly! My husband always gets his favorite Hawaiian…read moreLuau! I get something different every time! The mini is a large portion, and a good price

Sweet location. We walked in, the three young ladies working greeted us immediately! They asked if…read morewe wanted to try any flavors. Lots of unique flavors that you wouldn't find other places. They have a reward system which is always nice bonus!

Came here with my boyfriend yesterday for the first time and we will be back! The girls working…read morethere were so friendly and sweet, gave great recommendations, and let us try a few samples before we could decide. The ice cream was amazing, and the pumpkin dessert i had was a 11/10 as well and soft. I also think it was readable priced for the portions you get. Can't wait to go back!

Little disappointed to go back and now it's nothing but Hershey ice cream being sold. This place…read morewas a standout because it was all homemade. While the ice cream was good and the service was good, I don't plan to come back as I can get Hershey ice cream a lot closer to home. Uodate: owner responded. Based on this, I would suggest patience (me included). They are searching for a new producer as old ice cream producer went out of business. They've earned my trust over the years.

We haven't been here in years. I think they've switched owners and now the ice cream is better than…read moreI remember. Delicious! We went in with 11 orders and all the flavors were really good.

We're visiting family nearby and decided to stop back in after remembering this place from years…read moreago--back when they were still new. I was looking for a sweet treat for me and the kids, and I'm so glad we came back! The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. They let us know we could sample as many flavors as we wanted, and were patient and helpful the whole time. The flavor options are fun and creative, and they offer kiddie cups, milkshakes, and more. Last time I was here, I had the Browned Butter Brownie and still remember it as one of the best ice creams I've ever had. This time, I went with the Biscoff Cookie (so good!), and my kids got PB&J and Butter Brickle. We all loved our choices--the ice cream is thick, creamy, and perfectly sweet without being overwhelming. Bonus points for their sustainability efforts: paper cups and lids for most sizes, and compostable spoons! Kiddie size still has a clear plastic lid, but I appreciate the effort overall. Can't wait to come back again next time we're in town.

Bae got the white chocolate raspberry, I got the circus cookie && a pupper cup for little one …read more The lady that served us was very nice and even offered to let us try flavors before we committed to our purchase. We all enjoyed our sweet treats . We will definitely be back .

Wow! Nice service. We slipped in right at closing time and got quick, friendly service…read more Delicious ice cream and kiddo cups make it a good deal for families and seniors. Would love to see the outside tables open soon. However, I will need to return to see all the extras they sell! Really cute kids gifts or party gifts.

The old fashioned soda shoppe in the back of the Medicine Cabinet is awesome! Homemade ice cream…read morewith a number of different flavors will always hit the spot. Really high fat content so you can literally taste the difference in creaminess and consistency. Had a milkshake and it was superb. Love the atmosphere and the owner is really friendly and helpful.

Wr came at 4pm on a Friday . This place has a great niche with the ice cream , but their add ins (…read moreCarmel sauce , cookies , waffle cone etc ) is the same cheap stuff you get from Kroger . I don't understand why they don't elevate the entire experience.. they did give us a service and we got our ice cream in a timely fashion . The female. That worked there was complaining the entire time. I did manage to hear her over The horrendous funeral parlor style music they were playing. If your manager reading this here are her complaints 1. You haven't had brownie mix in over two weeks. 2 you can't expect anyone to make a brownie sundae with no brownie mixture that was NOT sent from the corporate office 3. You ran out of spoons and the kid that played the bad music how to use money out of his own wallet to go buy spoons. 4. Also, you need a bigger container for the chocolate syrup because it's the most used syrup and it always needs to be refilled..

This place used to be great, but it's gone pretty badly downhill. The last time we went in we…read morewaited for 45-60 minutes until we finally had our ice cream. There was one couple in front of us in line and at least 3 people working, the couple in front of us ordered two items and my daughter and I ordered two items. I appreciate that the ice cream is made in house to order, but the amount of time it took was truly astonishing. Not to mention it was so hot and steamy inside that the gentleman making the ice cream placed our first ice cream in the freezer so that it wouldn't melt during the next 15/20 minutes it took to make the second. They were out of several ingredients so the flavors were more limited. Overall, the final ice creams that we received tasted pretty good, but it wasn't worth the extensive wait.