The Diamond Reserve has set the standard for what an exceptional jewelry experience should be. I've purchased several pieces from them over the last several years, and every experience has been first-class from start to finish. They've helped me with a tennis bracelet, a diamond bar necklace, and two custom diamond rings with each of my sons' names beautifully spelled out in diamonds. Looking back, I only wish I had known about The Diamond Reserve when I purchased my wife's engagement ring and wedding band years ago. At the time, I went with one of the larger, well-known jewelers in Denver. While the experience was fine, it was nothing like the personalized service and attention to detail I've received from The Diamond Reserve. My wife's engagement ring and wedding band are beautiful, but they're essentially mass-produced designs that many other people own. What I love about The Diamond Reserve is that they specialize in creating unique, custom pieces that aren't just another ring from a display case. The level of craftsmanship, communication, and genuine care they put into every piece is unmatched. They make you feel like family, not just another customer. I won't go anywhere else for my jewelry, and I recommend The Diamond Reserve to anyone looking for exceptionaly quality, honest service, and one-of-a-kind jewelry they'll treasure for a lifetime. read more

Really enjoyed our visit at the diamond reserve. Sabrina took excellent care of us and would highly recommend. The process was thorough, personalized and very helpful. read more

I can't say enough about my experience at the The Diamond Reserve and Kaeleigh! I took in an old cocktail ring that was given to me by my grandmother in her will. I told Kaeligh that I wanted a station necklace with kite shaped mountings and a claw clasp. She immediately knew what I wanted and gave me a great price. She recommended that we make it a flexible length, so it can adjust to what I am wearing. My necklace was done in 2 weeks! And let me tell you... it is stunning and exactly what I wanted. The Diamond Reserve specializes in custom wedding pieces, but had no problems with my special request! They are honest, reasonably priced and experts at what they do! Undoubtedly I will be back! I just need to figure out what I want to do with some of my other old pieces.... Thanks Kaeleigh! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

For my 10-year wedding anniversary, I went to The Diamond Reserve and worked with Jillian. I designed a basic 3-stone ring. (for my 3 kids) I chose a diamond that was larger than I wanted to go but was trying to picture it in the setting. Jillian was only able to hold the diamond over my finger for me to get an idea. I was hesitant about the size but excited, and we moved forward. I received a 3D rendering and was warned it was extremely magnified (10x) of a small object, making the metal weight appear thicker than it is actually. (their words to me) So I assumed it would seem "softer" once I got the actual ring. I received the ring in the mail on October 7 and notified the store within an hour of seeing the final product. The ring is beautiful, but the center stone is too large. On their website, it states if you notify them within 7 days they can work with you. I was told since mine was a custom design it was as is. I was freaking out because this was an almost $8k purchase. They would not work with me at all. I even asked if they would take the center stone back so I could get a smaller one and they said no. I never asked for money back or anything. I am still shocked from a business perspective that they were not willing to do anything to help. They finally came back after 8 emails of saying no and essentially told me I could start over and get no money for what I already paid. 4 days later I went to Diamond Source Jewelers and the owner was surprised as well. He was able to cut out the center stone (The Diamond Reserve said that was not possible) and we are putting in a small stone. I highly recommend going to see Bruce at Diamond Source Jewelers for a seamless experience from start to finish. He genuinely wants his clients happy and works with them. Beyond grateful to him! Below is the picture of the ring with the stone that is too large for my taste. Once I get my ring back from The Diamond Source Jewelers I will post it as well. read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

As a Denver transplant, I had my reservations about finding a trusted Diamond jeweler here. The Diamond Reserve is the place to go! They are so welcoming and supportive and easy to work with. We worked with Perrin who has made all of our ring dreams come true. We absolutely recommend the Diamond Reserve! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Engagement ring - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

My fiancé and I worked with Erin and I have nothing but amazing things to say about our entire experience. Erin worked with us via email to get an idea of what type of diamond I wanted, and had an assortment to show us when we went in for our appointment. She was extremely knowledgeable and respectful of our budget. I never once felt pressured to spend more than we were comfortable with. Erin took the time to explain the basics of diamond education and identified which qualities we're most important to me in a diamond. After we picked our center stone, Erin immediately went to work and began designing my engagement ring. She designed a perfect ring (and did not get upset at my indecisiveness, I probably went back on forward on small details at least four times!) and it arrived after just a few short weeks. I couldn't be happier with how my engagement ring turned out and wouldn't dream of going anywhere else for my wedding band! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

My fiancé and I didn't want to go the traditional route of engagement ring shopping and decided to do it together. We quickly realized we wanted a custom ring. Having worked at Zales for a year I had no interest in low quality diamonds and mass produced products. An engagement ring is an investment and Kaeleigh helped us decide from the best quality. It was literally so hard to choose which diamond was better, because they were ALL so flawless. Kaeleigh was so knowledgeable and warm to work with it took all the pressure off not knowing exactly what we were looking for or even what size diamond. Because of Kaeleighs exceptional service we are returning for a custom wedding band. Kaeleigh will always be our go to! I'm excited for the many anniversaries to come that we will be working with her! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I enjoyed working with Perrin and Kaeleigh at TDR while exploring options for custom wedding bands for me and my fiancé. I found the shop to be professional, upscale, and secure. Perrin and Kaeleigh were knowledgeable, friendly, and communicative throughout the process. I highly recommend TDR for custom wedding band work. read more

Best jeweler in Denver! The Diamond Reserve made our dream, custom engagement ring come to life! It was no question that we'd create our wedding bands with them as well. They are kind, professional and incredibly talented. Look no further read more

Extremely kind and accommodating staff. You do need to make an appointment but that's only so that the team can give you their full attention to address your needs. Kaeleigh and Jillian were both very helpful in showing us options and helping us decide what was right for us. They also carry lovely contemporary jewelry that's beautiful and difficult to find at older, predominantly male jewelers. Very impressed by the Diamond Reserve as they provide such attentive and exceptional customer service. read more

I could not be happier with the experience. Yaneev was top class from the minute I walked in. He was extremely knowledgeable and was great to work with while getting fitted for my wedding suit. The suit itself fits me perfectly and is by far the nicest suit I have ever put on. This place is the real deal. Highly suggest using them if you need a high quality suit and experience to go along with it. I read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I entered working with Diamond Reserve (DR) excited to have found a quality local custom jeweler that is female owned. The person we met with was caring & confident they could help me create a new engagement ring. I didn't have an exact design in mind, so knew I needed help in that area. The only thing I knew was that I wanted a halo in some form that sat flush to the center stone. I was promised that this was all achievable. Unfortunately, this turned out to be a lie that took 6 month of back and forth before i got a clear enough answer to actually cut my loses & walk away. During this time, Erin was always friendly but never actually took initiative in helping to create any designs; the promise of which was a large reason we chose DR to begin with. Each round went as follows: I would scour the internet to come up with a new idea & present it to Erin -- I would be told this was great and should totally work -- Wait a week or so for a new rendering (several of which had mistakes that I was the only one to notice) -- In looking at the rendering it would still show a gap between the center stone & the halo -- given some reason why this was & then have to start all over. As my concern grew & my design ideas kept being simplified to achieve my goal, Erin had me come in to look at a wax mold and some example rings. All of these continued to show a gap & Erin began telling me this was as close as it could be and that all rings have this gap. She told me to trust that the benchman would get it "as close as possible." This just didn't sit right, so I reached out to custom jewelers I follow on IG, including showing them photos I had taken at DR. I was reassured by at least 6 jewelers that their rings have no gap at all & that what I was being told was the limit to flush just wasn't true. I shared this information with Erin, who remained steadfast that she was right & that what these others were telling me made no sense. I finally decided to listen to my gut & switch to a new jeweler. Unfortunately I still had to purchase my diamond through RC because they refused to return my deposit despite the fact that they couldn't deliver on the ring they promised. Do yourself a favor & don't give them as many chances to get it right as I did. There are plenty of great female owned custom jewelers out there. Pros: -nice people -lab grown diamonds at a fair price -good choice if looking for a solitaire design Cons: -have to put 50% down before you ever actually see a design -not ring designers -- i had to bring ideas for them to work from -turn around time for renderings can be over a week & often include mistakes that require additional time for correcting -lack of attention to detail shown in rendering mistakes & other experiences -rendering software isn't the best in terms of realism -try to sell you on a false idea of what it means for a halo to be flush -inflexible in refunding money if they can't do what you've asked for & they've promised they can deliver -showed up to appt to pick up another piece of jewelry i know longer wanted them to work on & they didn't have it ready even though meeting had been rescheduled already giving them more time read more

See all

When my fiancé and I started looking at engagement rings, we found Diamond Reserve and instantly knew it was the right fit. Kaeleigh walked us through buying a diamond and helped my fiancé design my dream ring. Perrin helped us find the perfect wedding bands to match. I cannot recommend Diamond Reserve enough! read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE The Diamond Reserve. I went in one day and spoke with Kaeleigh about rings and what I was looking for. She was super fun to work with, very helpful, and really got to know me and what I liked most. As soon as my fiancé went in to speak with her about putting one together she took it all from there and built the most beautiful ring. My fiancé said it was the easiest process and had all the confidence in her as she knew exactly what she was doing. He provided the diamond (passed down from my grandmother) but she put together the rest and it came out PERFECT. I'm so happy with it and loved working with her! Thank you Kaeleigh!! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Disappointing overall experience - my fiance and I originally purchased my engagement ring from The Diamond Reserve and had a lovely experience, but about 5 months after wearing it a diamond baguette fell out. We understand things can happen, but it did seem a little odd. When we reached out about a replacement/repair the response felt very non-empathetic and when we brought the ring in the process also felt very transactional. The overall customer service experience was disappointing, especially since we were looking for a long-term jeweler. We decided to take our business elsewhere for the problem. read more

I went back and forth on whether to post a review, but it's been a few months and I'm still appalled. I took my ring in to get resized as well as purchase a custom wedding band. The wedding band came out great. When they resized my engagement ring they took it from a 5 and a half to a 6. To do this it was as if the benchmen stretched the metal and my ring ended up tapered. I asked them to fix it and they said they would. I then drove back to cherry creek (30 mins each way) a few weeks later to find out they hadn't fixed it. When I told them again that it was not right, they accused me of not knowing my ring. They said it must have been tapered to begin with, asked if it was a mass produced ring (it was not - it is from a prestigious New York City jeweler), and said that their benchmen "wouldn't do this in a million years." Well, he did. They did offer to fix it again, but at that point I was tired of the 1 hour round trip drive and being treated rudely. I got it fixed with another jeweler. They did refund me for the resize. I also know that they offer discounts for positive reviews. read more

See all

Kaeleigh is wonderful. She goes above and beyond and she's not your typical jewelry salesman/woman. She takes the time to get to know you and your wants and will make sure you are happy no matter what. Absolutely loved my experience with her and Erin. They really know their stuff and are very kind and honest which really made the whole process simple and easy. Highly recommended!!! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Erin was wonderful to work with. She was patient and ensured our ring was absolutely beautiful and exactly what we wanted! We couldn't be happier! read more

Kaeleigh and the Diamond Reserve were so helpful helping me design a one of a kind ring for my future wife. I had a very unique design that I didn't even know would be possible, but The Diamond Reserve helped me through every step of the way. They sent computer images of the ring as we worked though the design and we finalized the ring within weeks. It was on my Ffancee's finger in about a month! I'm so happy that we were able to create a one of a kind, reasonably priced ring that will be an heirloom for generations! read more

The Diamond Reserve - The Diamond Reserve created a unique beautiful ring that she loves! - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

This place was top notch! Kaeleigh & team were incredibly accommodating and helpful in picking out the right rings for our upcoming wedding. They kept us informed on the progress, and always let us know the best path forward. They also provide servicing accommodations and other jewelry as well! Will definitely be returning here in the future. read more

My fiancé didn't want to go to one of the "big box" stores to find the perfect engagement ring for me. Luckily he found The Diamond Reserve! He spent a few weeks looking for the perfect diamond and worked with Steve & Kaeleigh personally to design the perfect custom ring. Steve found just the right diamond that he was looking for at a competitive price. He said that he wouldn't have been able to get me the size of diamond that he did elsewhere and it's GIA certified of course. He said that Steve's knowledge and experience is invaluable and he was very happy that he found them! I had the pleasure of meeting Kaeleigh when I had to drop my ring off to be resized. She is so friendly, helpful, and is very knowledgeable! Most friends told me that it would take at least 2 weeks plus to get it resized, they had it ready in less than a week! They did an amazing job too, had to take it down from a size 8 to a size 6 without losing any diamonds in the band and without compromising the integrity of the ring. I can't recommend them enough! We can't wait to come back to start designing our wedding bands! Thanks again so much for making the 8 years I waited to be well worth the wait! read more

Kaeleigh and Erin are a dream team - warm and fun demeanors, incredibly knowledgeable about their craft, honest in their opinions, reliable and lightning fast to boot. My fiancé worked with them to create my custom engagement ring and I loved it so much that I decided to get my wedding band designed with them, too. We incorporated diamonds from a very special earring my late mom gave me into both rings, and Kaeleigh has taken great care in doing so - giving me two pieces that will always carry very deep sentimental value. The second I walked into their office, they felt like old friends. I imagine it's hard to find this kind of service elsewhere in Denver. I recommend them fully! read more

Picking a place to purchase a sentimental piece of jewelry such as an engagement ring can be overwhelming, but we are so glad we chose Kaeleigh and the Diamond Reserve. My fiancé and I went about engagement ring shopping together. We decided to get engaged and designed the ring together, with me giving most of the details and updates towards the end of the process. Kaeleigh was helpful and understanding the entire time, and we truly appreciated her input and opinions. My ring has two side stones, and she was able to bring in multiple sets of stones for us to look at and compare with the center stone. This was very helpful because seeing them in person actually changed what we were looking for as far as the dimensions were concerned. The CAD images that she provided were very helpful in determining the final design of the ring and she was very receptive to all my little nit-picky questions. Once we finalized the designs and the ring went into production, it was turned around in a great amount of time. I've received numerous compliments on the stones in my ring, the attention to detail when it comes to the design (especially the claw prongs), and the lovely rose gold color. We can't thank Kaeleigh enough for helping us through this process! The price was great and having a relationship with someone that's making your engagement ring is invaluable. We will certainly be back for future jewelry purchases...I'm already thinking about what awesome design we can create for my wedding band! read more

The Diamond Reserve - Jewelry Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Kaeleigh made my engagement ring and our wedding bands! It was so fun working with her and we wouldn't ever go anywhere else. Her prices are very competitive and quality is superb! She specializes in custom jewelry and can make anything you can dream up. I absolutely love my rings and will definitely be returning to her for anniversary gifts, etc! read more

Kaleigh was so great to work with and I looooove my engagement ring! She will be my go to jeweler for life! If you want honest, reliable, and beautiful wedding rings The Diamond Reserve is the place to go! You get one on one interaction, help with design, and diamond education. Their is a lot of value that goes into your purchase! With such a big purchase, I wouldn't go anywhere else! read more

What else can I say about the staff here. Kayleigh, Erin, and Steve were my personal engagement ring designers and diamond consultants. I'm not an easy customer- I learned as much as I could about the process and diamonds and really tried to get the absolute best engagement ring for my fiancée. Kayleigh, Erin, and Steve worked side by side with me and were all for me doing my own research. They built the perfect ring, it's been a few mi this since I proposed and my fiancée is still getting compliments on a daily basis and is always telling me to look at her ring in different lights. They resized the ring for the perfect fit, even helped me get it insured. They rock! I can't wait to go back and get the bands customized now! read more

Our story starts back in October when my fiancé and I were visiting Colorado for a trip and came across this place while browsing in Denver downtown area. Erin, without us having an appointment with them, spent time answering our questions. We liked one of the bands that she showed us for my fiancé and to our amazement, she remembered us when we reached out to her after a few months. The process was smooth thereafter, Erin walked us through every step and little detail. The band was created in less time than we expected and was shipped overnight. So happy we found this place. read more

Just skip the typical diamond stores and give Kaeleigh a call if you're looking for an engagement ring. She will work within your budget and have a custom ring designed to meet your needs. I was a little worried that something "custom" was going to be out of my price range, but that wasn't the case at all. Even if they don't have the diamond you're looking for, they'll find you one. Process was easy, fun, and the ring was everything my fiancee was looking for. read more

Kaeleigh and Erin have been nothing short of outstanding. From the moment we scheduled our first appointment to get educated on diamonds to right now as we look to purchase our wedding bands, they have been a pleasure to work with. Their honesty and creativity have been refreshing. I will gladly recommend them to any friends/family that are looking for a private and personalized experience. Thanks Diamond Reserve! read more

Fellas, if you're shopping for an engagement ring and you don't want ripped off on an item you know nothing about, come here. Prices are unbeatable and customer service is untouchable. Dude replaced a couple tiny diamonds in my wife's ring this past month free of charge no questions asked. (We purchased the ring from him originally). This five star review is long over due, apologies. read more

Completely unorganized. When you walk in there is nothing but empty glass cabinets which I have not seen in a jewelry store before- it looked like they just got robbed. Furthermore, I had to wait for the person to call their boss to find the diamonds instead of having them out and ready as I did make an appointment. They see clients by appointments only but when you make an appointment they double book you. I was there and literally had another lady behind me listening to what kind of stones and dollar figures I was looking at. VERY Unprofessional. I would not recommended this place. read more

Absolutely love my engagement ring! My fiance and I sat down with the owner and described our ideas for a personalized ring because we did not want to pick one from a big name jeweler knowing thousands of others woud have the same ring (the big stores were not able to customize anything). He then made a quick sketch and 3 weeks later I had my stunning ring exactly the way I wanted! Fantastic craftmanship and great customer service. Could not be any happier and won't go anywhere else! read more

This place is great. I knew nothing about diamonds and after the first meeting, I felt I could make a very educated decision about diamonds. They can do anything you want for your ring as my ring was highly customized. Every detail was thought of and the ring turned out great. I am sending everyone I know to The Diamond Reserve. read more

Mark was awesome! He helped me pick the perfect diamond and setting for my engagement ring. It was a surprise for my fiance, so I had to kind of guess what she would like. After talking it over with Mark, he suggested an awesome diamond and setting that she LOVED! He worked with me on the price so I could get what I wanted within budget. He also came in on a Sunday so I could pick up the ring in time to surprise my fiance. We just bought our wedding bands from Mark as well. Another great experience. read more

was very disappointed in this place. I was discussing ring options with one of the girls there, in which I had an appointment for. She apologized for answering the phone and proceeded to talk with the other customer for 10 minutes! She said he was hard to get a hold of and was spending 50k on a ring. (I guess you get the better service the more you spend) read more

Kaeleigh and Steve are truly Denver's diamond experts! They have a huge inventory of loose diamonds to view in their private office, and the best prices. Working with them was seamless. They were able to create the most amazing ring! I recommend visiting them for all and any of your diamond needs! read more

I bought my fiance's engagement ring from The Diamond Reserve because they found me a very high quality diamond for a very competitive price. To help you quantify the difference, they were able to design exactly the ring that my fiance and I wanted, and then set it with a stone a full 1.25 karats larger than what I could have gotten for a comparable price (and same quality) from one of the mega jewelers. They will work with you to build exactly what you want, and you will be amazed with the outcome! I would highly recommend The Diamond Reserve to anyone for their high quality selection, tailored service, and sound advice on everything jewelry-related. read more

We went to them for the engagement ring and men's and women's wedding bands. They're extremely knowledgeable and taught me Diamond 101, provided tons of recommendations, listened to what we liked, and designed the perfect custom rings. The Diamond Reserve does great work! read more

Amazing experience! Erin was such a pleasure to work with. She helped me design my fiancé's ring and was I was able to stay within my budget AND purchase a show-stopper. From start to finish the process was super easy and she gave me tons of feedback on what would be best. When I took my fiancé back to pick out our wedding bands, Erin and Kaeleigh were so helpful and encouraging. Seriously, don't buy online - the quality of the inventory here is so much better than what you'll find there (at that price). We loved working with the Diamond Reserve! Such a personal and memorable experience and I know we will be back for years to come for more pieces. read more

My fiance went through The Diamond Reserve to find the perfect engagement ring! He picked out the stone and put it in a temporary setting for when he proposed. He then sent me back to meet with Kaeleigh to design the final setting. It was such a fantastic experience from start to finish! She really took the time to talk through my options and figure out exactly what I was looking for. We designed a custom setting and it couldn't be more perfect! I highly recommend going through The Diamond Reserve!! read more