Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Thar and Feather

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    Thar and Feather Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Thar and Feather

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Church Hill Oyster Bar And Restaurant - The back room is very intimate with a great view

    Church Hill Oyster Bar And Restaurant

    4.5(2 reviews)
    54.2 km
    $$$

    If you're going to Stewart Island and you're reading this review, stop and call to make a booking…read moreimmediately. You'll be glad you did. This is the best dining option in all of Stewart Island (which isn't very many either). Bookings are absolutely essential as staff and seating is limited. Church Hill Oyster Bar is located at the top of a hill overlooking all of Oban, Halfmoon Bay and on out into the nothingness of the Southern Ocean. Having read some of the Yelp reviews, I called for a booking the day of and was turned away as they were already overbooked. I begged to be called in case someone doesn't show up (which rarely happens as there are less than 500 people on the island at any given time) to which the manager agreed. Lo and behold, I was called an hour before a table was open (7:30 seating). We arrived early and were told we could sit where we liked (there were open tables, but staff was low). The restaurant resembles a small cottage house with two rooms for seating and an outdoor patio. There isn't much room for foot-traffic and there are two stools at the bar. We chose a seat in the backroom overlooking the water and were quickly brought water, but were told it would be just a few minutes while the manager finished helping some tables. We were ready to order immediately and went for the three appetizers of oysters: Natural, Kilpatrick (worcestershire sauce, bacon and parmesan) and Deep Fried. All three were fantastic, but I definitely preferred them natural. We also decided to split the Lamb Rack which was served beautifully with three lamb cuts balanced against each other, the pototao gratin underneath and veges strewn about. It is making my mouth water to recreate this vision in my head. The lamb was fall off the bone and succulent. My husband went for a beer and I, wine, but you can't go wrong with either choice as they have many great options. For dessert we ordered off of the blackboard specials for their chocolate cake. I forget the specific name, but it was served as a three-tiered cake: hard chocolate on top, mint ice cream/fudge in the middle and a delicious thick layer of crumbly pie crust on the bottom. Served with cream and mint leaves on the side. Check out the photos, but just know that we licked the plate clean. If you are a chocolate or chocolate and mint lover, this is the dessert for you. My husband also opted for the Oban scotch as a palate cleanser, because, hey, why not? He loved it. The staff couldn't have been nicer and the experience dining in this restaraunt couldn't have been more superb. My husband and I truly had a remarkable and romantic evening at Church Hill Oyster Bar and Restaurant and long to return.

    Its worth venturing from the South Sea Hotel for one night to have dinner here. The classier joint…read moreof the two, it had great seafood (mussels, cod) and well-made muttonbird/titi. A bit pricey but the atmosphere delivers. Chef came out after dinner and chatted with us a bit.

    Photos
    Church Hill Oyster Bar And Restaurant - View from the walk up

    View from the walk up

    Church Hill Oyster Bar And Restaurant - Charming dining room with a gorgeous view! Jan 2015

    Charming dining room with a gorgeous view! Jan 2015

    Church Hill Oyster Bar And Restaurant - Classy wine glasses

    See all

    Classy wine glasses

    Thar and Feather - newzealand - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...