Great Bed and breakfast. This intimate, immaculate, homey B&B is in a perfect location to explore…read moreand enjoy Long Island's beautiful North Fork. Our Hosts Veda and Wilfred were friendly and very attentive to all our needs. Beautiful well-appointed rooms. Incredibly comfy beds. Charming common areas with a lovely piano to play. All modern conveniences in a comfy welcoming setting. In the morning before breakfast, coffee and or tea is left outside your room. Just a few minutes from beautiful Southold, a short distance to many vineyards and just seven miles to Orient State Park. You will be treated to an excellent home cooked breakfast prepared with love by Veda. Each day Wilfred served us a big fresh fruit salad, OJ, salad with homemade dressing, followed by a yummy filling breakfast entre. The first day the entre was the best cheese omelet I ever had and sausage with home fries. The second day the entre was corned beef hash, biscuits, plantains, both days muffins, OJ and very fresh coffee. Veda is very accommodating to dietary concerns. When we were done eating Veda came out and we enjoyed wonderful conversations with both Wilfred and Vida. They are warm, interesting, knowledgeable helpful and welcoming hosts. We will definitely return. Highly recommended

A superb and thoughtfully curated experience from start to finish! Innkeepers Wilfred and Veda did…read morean incredible job welcoming us into their beautiful home and making us feel like family. We arrived late on the Jitney, which conveniently drops you off right in front of Arbor View House, and Wilfred was there to greet us with a warm smile and genuine hospitality. The room was tidy, comfortable, and incredibly relaxing. The mattress was excellent, and we slept wonderfully throughout our stay. Each morning, coffee was ready at 8 AM, and we enjoyed wonderful conversations over Veda's delicious homemade breakfasts. The 9 AM breakfast featured a fresh fruit bowl, a beautifully dressed salad, and a flavorful entrée. On our first morning, we had chorizo, cheese eggs with biscuits; on the second, chickpea fritters and salmon cakes. Everything was so delicious that I practically finished it in one bite! Beyond the exceptional quality of the food, what truly stood out was the engaging conversation. Wilfred is incredibly knowledgeable, engaging, and has the gift of gab. We loved hearing his stories and insights throughout our stay. The location is also favorable, a short distance from Greenport, and we had no trouble getting around without a car. We enjoyed meeting and chatting with the other guests and genuinely felt welcomed throughout our visit. Arbor View House made our North Fork getaway truly special, and we highly recommend it to anyone visiting the area!

This was nothing short of a fabulous experience from beginning to end!…read moreThe host was super accommodating, the room was unbelievably charming, and the food was absolutely incredible! The location was perfect, too. It's less than a 5 minute walk to town. I enjoyed having breakfast on the lovely porch in the morning and watching the sunset in the evening. I love this part of Long Island, and when I go back (hopefully soon,) I will stay at this fantastic B&B once again!

The Stirling House will spoil you for any other Bed and Breakfast. Other B and B's have porches…read morelooking out over the water and others have large fluffy beds and others also have delicious breakfasts. The Stirling house has all this and a secret ingredient. Clay. The owner, host, chef dedicated to his guests assuring them of a perfect stay. From check in with gifts of cookies and wine throughout your stay unobtrusive caring service Clay makes you feel welcome. Breakfasts on the porch were spectacular and his book of recipes is available in the bookstore in Greenport. The location is perfect the water views are calming, and other guests varied and interesting, but Clay makes the Day. So stay.

The Coffey House is the perfect place to get away and relax for a little bit. My fiance and I went…read morein October, and we had the best time exploring the area and doing all the fun fall things. The Coffeys made us feel like we were at home. The three-course breakfast was fabulous, the grounds were stunning, and the room was so romantic. There's also a cute game room downstairs with a huge collection of old-school DVDs. It was the perfect mini-break for us! Highly recommend.

My fiancée and I stayed at the Coffey House and we had an absolutely extraordinary stay. The rooms…read moreand accomodations were lovely. (Especially the room with a fireplace.) The breakfast was also top-notch, better than anything you'll get at 99% of of bed & breakfasts. The gaming room downstairs was also so much fun. We played some pool, then relaxed and watched a movie from the wide collection. But above all, the hosts were just so friendly and welcoming. I really can't recommend the Coffey House enough, and we had such a fun time exploring the area.

My wife and I recently stayed at Ruby's Cove. It was the perfect spot for us to stay during our…read moreweek-long getaway from the city. With just three guest rooms and plenty of space on the first floor and on the expansive deck, we felt very comfortable throughout our stay. And Donna was a wonderful, gracious host. She was very accommodating to our arrival and departure times, and offered thoughtful recommendations for restaurants and other things for us to enjoy. We had an especially good time taking her bicycles on the short ride to the nearby Kontokosta Winery and 67 Steps Beach. We would definitely stay here again when visiting Greenport!!

The greatest B&B ever!…read more Forget that it's centrally located -- but it should be noted that within seconds you can walk to all the restaurants and shops in the heart of Greenport. Forget that the rooms are more comfortable and relaxing than any other dwelling you've ever experienced -- but it should be noted that you feel instantly at home. Forget that the breakfasts are better than anything else you will eat for the rest of the year -- though it should be noted that the food is both original and familiar and you will not be able to stop eating what you're served, even if you're not hungry. (And as an aside, for those of you who come here and need many hours of recovery from eating and wine tasting and other gluttinous pursuits, Donna is not strict about the time breakfast is served. Hey, this is a B&B, not a weekend in army boot camp, okay? And while Donna is the most generous soul, you had better respect her and the time and effort she puts in to making you happy! Or else you'll hear from me! ;) ) I CANNOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH: the greatest thing about this beautifully stunning old Victorian home is its keeper, Donna. The second you meet her, you'll think you ran into one if your best friends from way back! Her sweetness and generosity and ebullience and tremendous sense of humor are all showered upon you and the only thing you'll regret is that you have to leave. But you will tell everyone you know about this place and right after you leave, you'll be thinking about coming back. Anyway, I'm writing this on the last night of our three-night Labor Day stay and while I am looking forward to eating nothing salads and celery sticks for the next week, I am sad to leave this house, which already feels like a second home. Thank you, Donna, thank you a million times!

In the midst of farmland, vineyards, and tiny port towns, there are no Hiltons or Holiday inns to…read morebe seen. Everything around here is small, personable and locally run -- adding to the charm of being out on the east end. Your options are a smattering of bank breaking bed and breakfasts, hard to acquire airbnb rentals, cottages by the golf course and a motel with one of the best views you've ever seen. The blue inn falls somewhere in the middle of those choices. Our room reminded me of a cozy ski lodge rental. Small kitchenette, exposed wood beams and a pleasing country decor. Rates were extremely reasonable (about $150 midweek off season). Everything was very clean and they even left us a surprisingly nice toiletry package with toothpastes, floss, makeup wipes, Q-tips etc. It's the little things like this, which I wasn't really expecting that really added a nice touch. Our stay was pleasant, however the noise level deserves a mention. There were folks staying on both sides of the room and at night I could hear bits of conversations about who knows what and both of their TVs blaring incoherently. Thankfully our neighbors weren't night owls or I would have not gotten any sleep. As for sleeping - the king size bed was cozy and mushy. I liked it but its probably to soft for most. Unfortunately, the restaurant and pool were not open but I wouldn't have minded checking both out had I been here during the summer!

It's an okay place, nothing special, nothing really bad. The staff is pleasant and helpful and the…read morerooms are kept spotlessly clean. Has a roomy mini-fridge with a freezer compartment. The grounds and buildings are well-maintained. We had a second-floor room with steep stairs; no elevator. Breakfast is all carbs, only on weekends when we were there in mid- May; the restaurant was otherwise closed. The room has a small table with two kitchen chairs. There is no desk or comfy chair. The bathroom sink has no space to put anything by it. In our room, the toilet valve had to be manually reseated after every flush, and they couldn't fix it for the four days we were there. We might have changed rooms, but that seemed like a bigger pain.

This weekend was our second stay at Menhaden, to celebrate a combination birthday/anniversary…read more And Menhaden easily met every expectation. First - A shout out to Alex, and Kailee, and the rest of the staff we met for their wonderful kindness and support. Second, our King Room was exceptional, Clean, Large lots of windows for spectacular views. Third, maybe most important, We were able to bring our newly rescued 8 lb precious little Bichon Sadie. Sadie was made to feel at home and the three of us look forward to our next stay at Menhaden

I recently stayed at The Menhaden on July 15, 2026, and it was an exceptional experience from start…read moreto finish. This boutique hotel perfectly balances a luxurious feel with a warm, intimate atmosphere. The highlights of my stay included the careful attention to detail throughout the property, from the beautifully designed rooms to the thoughtfully curated lounge experience (loved the retro board games and Vinyl Record collection) The staff was incredibly attentive and provided top-notch service, ensuring that every need was met promptly and with a smile. Honestly, I could not find any areas for improvement during my visit; everything was seamless and well-executed. Overall, I would rate The Menhaden a solid 5 out of 5 stars. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a boutique hotel that delivers both comfort and luxury with outstanding hospitality.

This is a fantastic place. The home, rooms, food, everything was perfect!…read more Clean, lovely, large rooms. Host was extremely friendly and warm Walking distance to town with great restaurants. Breakfast was delicious. Very happy and can't wait to return.

We were very last minute arrivals and the host/proprietor Vince could not have been more gracious…read moreand welcoming. This is a quite high-end accommodation. Everything is beautiful. It reminded me of those historic houses that one can tour except you get to stay here. Breakfast was amazing. I highly recommend Wells House especially if its an occasion. Because it feels like one, not just a hotel stay.

My boyfriend and I stayed here this past weekend hoping for a little getaway, but were a little…read moredisappointed. The inn was pretty, grounds and harbor view were very pretty. The room however had alot to be desired. We stayed in the Harbor View room which had 2 windows and only 1 had the harbor view the other was on the side of the house, the room and bathroom was very small, my bedroom and ensuite bathroom at home is much bigger and I live in a one bedroom condo, the bed was HORRIBLE it was so hard it was like sleeping on the floor! We were supposed to stay 3 nights but left after 2 because we couldn't bear to sleep in that bed another night. Breakfast was good but a little skimpy for the price. Overall definitely overpriced and the inn keeper needs to get new beds!!

Classic, beautiful inn right on the water in beautiful Greenport. I go every year, never…read moredisappointed.

Amazing hotel with even better service. The location is…read moreperfect--just steps from everything in Greenport. The design has a fun retro vibe that's both stylish and thoughtfully done. You really don't need anything more. I was obsessed with the flavored water in the lobby--such a great touch. Don't miss relaxing by the firepit in the evening. A wonderful stay all around!

Most awful place I have ever stayed in my entire life. This hotel is very run down and extremely…read moreoverpriced.

An Absolutely Exceptional Stay -- Silver Sands Is Something Special…read more My wife and I spent three days at Silver Sands celebrating our 31st wedding anniversary, and although this was our first visit, it certainly will not be our last. From the moment we arrived until the moment we left, the experience was exceptional. The entire staff went above and beyond to make our stay memorable. What impressed us most was how incredibly organized, attentive, and welcoming everyone was without ever being intrusive. It was almost as if the staff had mastered the art of being there exactly when you needed something, while somehow remaining nearly invisible the rest of the time. That level of service is very difficult to achieve, and Silver Sands does it beautifully. The property itself is immaculate. The grounds are meticulously maintained while still allowing the natural beauty of the surroundings to remain part of the experience. The private beach was spotless, peaceful, and beautifully organized. Throughout the day, we would notice staff quietly moving through, straightening and maintaining everything, yet they were so unobtrusive you could barely tell it was happening. The attention to detail throughout Silver Sands is remarkable. From the design and atmosphere of the property to the pour-over coffee in the room, the thoughtfully selected shampoos and conditioners, linens, amenities, and overall cleanliness -- everything feels intentional. Our room was absolutely impeccable. Silver Sands somehow manages to capture the nostalgia and charm of the classic American motel while feeling modern, sophisticated, and luxurious at the same time. Calling it a "motel" almost doesn't do it justice. It is a truly unique property that can easily rival some of the best hotels and resorts we've stayed at. And then there are Eddie's and Nookie's! Both onsite restaurants were fantastic. The staff and service were wonderful, and everything we ate was top-notch. We left already talking about coming back so we can try more of the menu. Over our 31 years together, my wife and I have been fortunate enough to travel to many beautiful and far-off destinations. Yet there were moments during our stay at Silver Sands when we genuinely felt transported somewhere else entirely -- certainly not like we were still on Long Island, and at times not even like we were anywhere in the United States. It has a special atmosphere that is difficult to describe until you experience it yourself. Thank you to the entire Silver Sands team, as well as everyone at Eddie's and Nookie's, for making our 31st anniversary one of our most memorable, relaxing, and enjoyable staycations. You helped make an already special occasion even more special. We arrived as first-time guests and left knowing we'll be back and bringing others to experience what we had. Thank you again, Silver Sands. See you all soon!

Cool, recently refurbished, cozy motel on the sound. Nice bar and restaurant, updated rooms, small,…read morequiet beach. Good food and good vibes. Friendly staff. An escape from the city, and the Hamptons. A good base for exploring the area.