I recently visited the Surratt House and Mudd Farm, must sees for any Lincoln Assassination student. I don't want my review for this to be harsh in comparison to the Mudd Farm, because that place was one of the best historic sites I've ever visited and by far the best one related to the assassination. In comparison, this was fine, but lacked the things needed to make it excel, I would really like to give it 2.5 stars, but as usual, not an option.
The main issue is that almost nothing in the house is original to the Surratt family. This is understandable as the majority of historic locations have little to nothing original to the event or person you're there to visit. It's understandable when the place was a house, and people lived there, and items change hands or are discarded over time. Nonetheless, it's still preferable to see not only the structure, but the details of the person or event you're studying. One thing they do have, which was a pleasant surprise, is one of the "shooting irons" that the Surratts' had John Lloyd hide in the house so that Boothe could use them on his escape. Those shooting irons, or rifles, were the most damning evidence against Mary Surratt and the primary reason she was hung. So, getting to see one of the rifles was amazing.
The secondary issue relevant to the house was the tour was not very factual. I hate to bag on docents, these people are volunteers who give their time so that people like me can enjoy a piece of living history. The gentleman who gave my tour was very nice, and had passing familiarity with the assassination and with the Surratt family that wouldn't be noticed by someone who had not studied the conspiracy but several of his facts stood out to me. The timing of John Surratt Sr. dying, when the house was leased to John Lloyd, mention of John Surratt Jr. and Mary's visits back to their leased property were often wrong. Regardless, that was just one docent so it may not be a common occurrence. If you're a student of the Lincoln Assassination, you definitely have to check this off your list. I would recommend combining it with the Mudd Farm and be sure to check out what dates and hours both locations are open. They both have limited schedules, so you don't want to waste a trip out there. read more