This delightful restaurant was phenomenal and very accommodating. My sister, who is visiting Florida, and I wanted to try the lobster bisque but did not want a full cup as we know lobster bisque is generally a very rich soup. The chef was willing to to place the soup in two smaller portions-- essentially sharing one cup of soup. It was the best lobster bisque I have ever had. The bisque was creamy, not salty as some bisques can be and had chunks of lobster in it. We each had the hogfish. Blackened. This fish was unknown to us but it was delightful, the portions were large. It came with two sides. I had the black beans and rice and the wontons with a mango tomato salsa. Scrumptious. My sister's sides were the creamy coleslaw with just the right amount of mayo so as not to be runny and the sweet potato fries which were seasoned with just the right amount cinnamon sugar. Jasmin was our server and she answered all of our questions about the fish which is caught fresh from the Gulf each day. She was very welcoming and made us feel like we were visiting friends. The restaurant does have live music for the dinner crowd. If your family is visiting Florida and you want a meal that is high on the wow factor of taste-- this is the place. read more

Five years later and we're finally back and the one thing we talked about the entire time was the ahi nachos. Happy to report they're still just as good as we remembered. Absolutely did not disappoint. My wife and I split the fish tacos and a side salad (not pictured), and the salad was actually a great size for sharing. Between the ahi nachos, shared salad, and the tacos, it ended up being the perfect amount of food for the two of us. We washed it all down with a couple local beers on tap and called it a perfect afternoon. The servers were great and even suggested a beer that paired really well with the meal, which was a nice touch. Parking is easy, and the view adds to the whole experience. You can sit back and watch boats cruising by while others are getting launched or lifted out of the water by the massive forklifts at the marina. It's just a really cool atmosphere. If you go, the ahi nachos are a must. Five years later and we'd come back again just for those. read more

See all

Very middling experience. ***Before you get there, know they have no liquor license - beer and wine only. We weren't going to drink, so this didn't affect our experience, but everyone should know!*** As soon as we were seated down, a fellow patron was raaaaaving about the incredible fish here. Felt like a good thing! A very happy-go-lucky server was roving and there was live music (chill). We ordered blackened fish with 2 sides and ahi nachos to start on. The nachos were not incredible, sadly. The tuna was small, lacking in quantity, and appeared very subpar in quality. I couldn't taste it because of the hefty volume of sauces and salsa piled on this dish, which overwhelmed everything (and ultimately caused the wonton chips to get soggy). The chips themselves were clumped and unevenly cooked - some quite dark/burnt and others barely kissed w frying. It was not BAD, but poorly executed and could be a really great dish! Fish that came out was good; reasonable portion, moderately blackened, but served on TOP of the side salad, making it warm and goopy. The fish was itself good but not top-tier compared to so many other options in the area. Ultimately the choices made in preparation and presentation made this an average stop for us. You could do worse as well as better! read more

Spearfish Grille - End of Ahi nachos - drowned in sweet chili sauce and many chips (wonton) stuck in clumps like other reviewers have stated - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Worst experience ever Posted price was $14 we get there and it's $20 the grouper cheeks I ordered was not lightly battered as menu states and for sure other than a few pieces was catfish flavored not grouper. I hate catfish so I know as well as being a chef. Oil it was fried in was super dirty too. Too late in the night to send back and deal with BS. Real shame establishments want to post locally caught fish and nothing was fresh. We also ordered the coconut shrimp and conch fritters posted as $13 we get there and it's $17.... Not worth the upset stomach and going back to hotel disappointed for the bad choice of restaurant . Everything else is closed on Sunday night to even stop for something else read more

Spearfish Grille - Supposed to be grouper cheeks but the taste of catfish - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Lunch was delicious here. Started with the corn chowder which came with 3 lg grilled shrimps (not in pic). Then had the big Sammy fish sandwich with blackened grouper. Everything was delicious! Our server Jay was prompt, and professional. Loved sitting outside and enjoying the good weather and delicious food. The fries were good but the rice and beans were average. read more

Spearfish Grille - Corn chowder with shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Love the indoor mixed outdoor vibe of this place. I would bring a light jacket if it's a breezy night. I tried the local beer on draft and nice it came in a to go up so I can take it on my walk back to the hotel. The ceviche was really good. Lots of pieces of fish. My boyfriend got the hogfish, rice, and beets. Everything was delicious and portion size was huge. I think he got 3 filets with his meal. We also got the calamari. It was mostly rings. Service was quick and our server was really nice. read more

We took the trolley to Spearfish Grille on a rainy Saturday night. There was live music, but a rowdy bachelorette party made us opt for a quieter corner table inside (they let us seat ourselves, which was great). The boatyard ambience is so cute and cozy. Since we'd already had cocktails earlier in the day, we stuck with waters and shared the BEST cup of gumbo. seriously the best we've had since New Orleans! We'll definitely be back for a full bowl next time we're in town. We also got the calamari, which came out piping hot and perfectly crispy. I loved how thin and light the breading was, not heavy or caked on. A squeeze of lemon made it delicious, though I found myself wishing for more seasoning. For our main, we went with the fish and chips. Our server (who I think may have been the manager) kindly chose the fish for us since we couldn't decide. The breading was wonderfully crisp and served steaming hot. Again, I personally wished for a little more seasoning or kick, but the freshness and preparation were spot on. From our table, we had a great view of the staff at work, and it honestly felt like watching a big family. They were laughing, chatting with guests, and training a new young team member, encouraging her and showing her the ropes. At one point, a difficult customer came in and made some rude insinuations, but the staff handled it with total grace. They stayed calm, professional, and positive, contacted the owner, resolved it smoothly, and didn't let her negativity affect the vibe. I was really impressed. The restaurant itself was very clean and well-kept, and the overall energy was so welcoming. It looks like they do an awesome to-go business as well. read more

See all

Wak Lied right in on a Friday evening musician was playing outside. We chose to sit inside. Specials of the Big Green Egg which we ordered: bacon wrapped scallops and a HUGE Piece of tuna. Amazing chef Erick came over and explained how he grilled the scallops and the tuna. The smoked flavor was out of this world. Also ordered blacked grouper with mashed potatoes. The fish was so fresh and tender and delicious The service was amazing Our drinks were continually being refilled and he gave great suggestions read more

See all

We ordered Togo. Stopped to Fill up the boat with gas and stopped in for an order. This place was busy! My pulled pork sandwich was tasty - a bit salty but full of good flavor. Fries were good. I'm sure the fish is good. My bil had some later and he liked it fine . Lots of cool design touches inside and the outside area is nice. Our order took awhile but they let us know before hand it was very busy and would take awhile. I'd go back. read more

See all

We came upon this place really by accident and thanks to our trusty Yelp app! What a great find though. The place is in the Siesta Key Marina. Food and service were both fabulous. First time I've ever had Hog Fish and it was great. White, flaky and mild. My wife had the coconut shrimp which I tried and they were great as well. Shrimp were done perfectly still plump and tender The best part though may have been the clam chowder. Was unique style that was just terrific. If you are looking for great food and friendly service check this place out. Highly recommended !! read more

First time at this resturant. There were 9 of us. We all ordered a different dish. We were all very disappointed in the food we received. As residents of this area for the past 30 years we have frequented many resturants. This one was one of the worst. Food was simply not good. Before placing our orders the menu taker was raving about how great the food was and how everyone that has gone there thinks the food is so great. Why did he need to tell us how good the food was. Maybe because he was trying to talk us into believing this. Of course this is a high tourist area so the tourists do not know any better. Trust me, there are many other resturants in this area that serve much better food. Also the only place to park is across the street for $ 16.00 per hour. How outrageous is that. read more

I had an amazing grilled Pork Chop. It was prepared on the Green Egg. It was tender and delicious. Great job.

Restaurant was as advertised, thanks Yelp! Simply prepared, freshly caught fish in a casual atmosphere. I had the grilled grouper tacos blackened and they were perfectly cooked and served atop a corn and crumbled cheese mix. I also liked that they had the option of a lettuce wrap. My son had the Mac and cheese which he appreciated was not Kraft from a box. The live music was a nice touch though perhaps a bit loud to carry on a conversation. Would return if in the area. read more

Spearfish Grille - Tuna poke - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We stopped in around 4 on a Saturday expecting it to be packed... it was not but was completely packed by the time we left. They had a man playing guitar for about 2 songs when we got there and then he was done. Feels like they should move the live entertainment to the beginning of the dinner hour. They do not make their own cocktails. So when you order a margarita off the menu, you are getting a bottle that is premade they sell at Publix for $12 a 6 pack and charge you $10 for one bottle. Our Server "Aye!" Was very nice and friendly. The grouper cheeks were the best we've had, lightly friend with a great dipping sauce. We order triple tail tacos and the fish and chips. We got the hogfish for that and it was light and great flavor with the breading. I would t get the tacos again- seemed to lack flavor that I was looking for. Overall good experience if you stick to the beer menu. read more

See all

One of my absolute favorite places to eat on the Key. Their fish tacos are some of the best around. My boyfriend and I went twice on our week vacation. The first time we went I switched it up and got the lobster roll and the second time I had to get my classic fish tacos with blackened hog fish. I personally think you can't go wrong with any of their seafood! read more

Spearfish Grille - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

I go out of my way to try conch fritters, and these were the best that I've had in years. So tasty and I highly recommend them! read more

See all

The food was absolutely delicious, Jasmine our waitress was awesome made some great recommendations. You definitely have to eat here . Ask for Jasmine! read more

See all

We heard very good reviews for this resturante but ended up utterly disappointed. Our food was not served to our table at the same time. One of our group did not get order before everyoIne else had finished their dinner. The cook grilling the food brought in this meal, that was late. We complained and he basically told us to Shut Up. We called over the manager and complained. I also asked the manager if the cook was on some kind of drugs. I never been so insulted in a resturante in my life. I wouldn't go back here if the food was free. Also I had the hogfish and was completely dried out. My wife had the coconut shrimp and is overcooked. read more

This is our first visit to this pleasant dive just across the bridge. Adriana was our server. She is amazing. She knows everything about the food and will give honest advice. This restaurant is all about the food . Everything is wonderful.. Try splitting any of the main menu items since portions are all double the size necessary to feed a large person . Spearfish was great. read more

Most of the seating here is outside but even on warm nights the fans and shade make it feel nice. There was live music when we visited which we loved. Everything is cooked fresh and you can watch some of it being made on the grill. The Scallops were incredible and so was the hogfish. We actually ordered to go another day during our trip because it was so good. Would 100% recommend. read more

See all

We really enjoyed our experience here. The wait was only about 30 minutes on a Saturday night. Our server Jess was really nice and helpful. The grilled oysters were good and the entree was fantastic (fresh spear caught fish of the day- hogfish). The key lime pie was alas amazing and very tasty. I'd recommend this place to others! read more

Spearfish Grille - Hogfish (fresh spear caught fish of the day- left) and crab stuffed grouper (special of the day- right) - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

We had a fantastic night tonight. The food was just great! All the employees were working hard and had great attitudes. Giovanni, our server, was on point. Jeremy, the manager was awesome as well. Good music and vibe. We can highly recommend. read more

Nice to be able to sit outside and our wait - although somewhat long was also outside at long bar and we were able to enjoy a drink before we were seated. Service was good and the food was decent although I wouldn't recommend the shrimp and grits. The music was a big plus and perfect accompaniment to our dinner. read more

Small paper plates and Luke warm food temperatures were a turnoff. Ambience was ok. Quality of the food was ok. Also disappointed with limited cocktail menu read more

OMGosh! Locals, make it a point to get here while you can, before the height of season. Local catches, prepared in a variety of ways (grilled/blackened with complimentary sides, on Sammie's, or tacos) cannot be beat for freshness and flavor. Visitors, enjoy the place that locals LOVE, not only because of the awesome food, but the casual vibe of the marina, and local musical talent. I went on a Friday night, and Joe played tunes from Jim Croce, Bad Company, and Fleetwood Mac, Outdoor fans made the experience very comfortable (even in mid-September)! Our server was confident in her recommendations, and knowledgeable about the fresh catches. The staff was flawless working together to make sure everyone was served promptly, and followed up to make sure the preparation was excellent. I would like to recommend several menu items but can't seem to break away from my favorite- the Gulf Fish tacos! 99% of the tine, I just ask the chef to choose his favorite (because I pretty much love all Gulf fish), and you can't find any fresher hogfish or snapper. Anywhere. So I guess I'll just have to keep coming back to try new things. Go. Get the tacos. And the Key Lime Pie. And/Or the Chocolate Mud Pie. The perfect night cap. Hope you enjoy! read more

Spearfish Grille - Hogfish Tacos -1 because I was hungry! Fabulous - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Amazing just amazing however my mom got hers about 20 mins later. Staff were happy to be there. Fish vibes lol 99.9℅ recommend

Food and service was great! I'm looking forward to bringing people back for the music and to try that green egg smoker! read more

Great food, great service. Atmosphere is not so good, but food makes up for it. I will definitely be back to try more of the menu. Lots of good choices. read more

Run don't walk to this marina side local haunt. Casual location with five-star food. The service is excellent, knowledgeable and friendly. Giovanni, wow, thanks brah; you are a superstar. They have hogfish - if you don't know about this local fish then google it before coming in or check out my pictures. Ordered the blackened hogfish tacos and the coconut gulf shrimp and both were perfectly fresh and seasoned. All local fresh fish, what? Amazing. Local beers on tap, and a coconut water and vodka in a can. I think I manifested this restaurant in a hunger-induced fever dream. read more

See all

Really good food, and large portions. My husband and I both got blackened hogfish and it was fantastic. Seasoned fries are the fat kind, and sweet potato fries are in waffle form - both delish. Kids liked their Mac n cheese. Grouper bites (happy) was a large portion, fried crispy and served with a nice chipotle mayo. Clam chowder was good to. Prices are a bit high given food is served on disposable plates (albeit fancy looking ones) and drinks come in plastic cups. Hogfish sandwich for example was $27 (came with fries). Service was just ok. Ambiance is cute - nice little indoor space plus a big covered patio read more

Love this local gem. Best part was they had a fresh grill set up for all those waiting. Eric and Gray had a double green egg setup rolling - and they served up some delicious food with a smile. They had amazing scallops, oysters, tuna steaks, etc. We had the iberico pork chop and lobster tail. KILLER!!! read more

Food great. Service great and fun place to eat with live music. Hog fish and grouper were awesome. Highly recommend if visiting Seista Key.

Fresh fish. Fast service. Simple and casual, don't forget to take a picture in the scuba helmet. read more

Spearfish Grille - Grouper Tacos - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Our intended destination was closed due to a/c problems, so we are glad to have found this place. The majority of tables are outside but we opted to eat indoors. There was a good singer outside entertaining patrons. The gumbo was good- not thick but tasty and tomato based. My fish and chips consisted of hog fish(three pieces), tasty seasoned fries and coleslaw. Our waitress was helpful and friendly. She was very familiar with the menu and made helpful suggestions. Plenty of parking, another alternative for us in the future. read more

Spearfish Grille - Inside - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Very disappointed. There were 4 of us and we all had different variations of fish. The fish and chips with fried grouper was lukewarm and chewy, the fries were cold. The fish and chips with hogfish was lukewarm and chewy, fries were cold. The grilled grouper was very chewy. The last meal was to be gluten free grilled grouper - so the waiter said they could season the fish with something, but it came out without any seasoning. Even though we called ahead and the guy that answered the phone said they do gluten free all the time and they would be happy to accommodate us - our server was not as enthusiastic. The roasted root vegetables were beets.Terrible. My sister who never complains told the waiter that one of the grilled grouper meals and that the fish was chewy and he didn't seem to care. He said "Really, huh." That was it! No apology or anything! We spent over $200 on 4 meals and all of them were bad AND small portions AND overpriced!! I've never been to a restaurant that didn't care if you weren't happy with your food. Our server was completely indifferent. read more

Back again at Spearfish for another amazing meal, whenever I am in the Key this place is at the top of my list. We got the usual Conch Fritters as an app and I got my Big Boss sandwich with grouper fish, amazing as usual. My wife once again got the Po Boy and my mother in law got the tacos. Place was damaged a bit during Hurricane Milton but has remodeled a bit and looks bigger than before, they still have live music every night, this place just doesn't miss. read more

See all

AMAZING!! Our favorite restaurant of the trip. Quick service, kind staff, and great portion sizes. The peel n eat shrimp was great, salad had good flavor, and fish was fresh, cooked well, and a big portion. Staff was kind and urgent. Great location on the marina and nice porch area for dining. Will be dreaming about this place for months! read more

Yum! Spearfish was the best meal we had while visiting Sarasota. My wife and Ioved everything Eric and Grey sizzled up on the grill too! Our service was fantastic and again the food was great! Highly recommend. read more

Amazing! food was amazing. Hogfish platter big enough to feed at least two people. Adriana our server was too much fun!! Outside music was perfect. read more

Love this spot! We were here for the third time last night. The place was busy- and for good reason. Our server was on it: hosting, taking to go orders, and waiting on the inside tables. She was knowledgeable about the menu and told us her favorites. I love that about a place. You know the food is good if the staff eat it. We ordered the conch fritters and grouper cheeks to start. Some of the best conch fritters I've ever had. Flavor was amazing and so was the dipping sauce. For my main I got the hogfish and a Caesar salad. The fish was perfectly cooked in a key lime butter with roasted red peppers. Perfection. Omg. I loved the way it was served with its tail on. I should have taken a picture but couldn't waste time. They had live music and seating outside. This a spot to go to in siesta key for sure. read more

Spearfish Grille - Grouper cheeks and Conch Fritters - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida