A great family business that supports our kids with all sports. Their ice cream and cakes are…read moredelicious.

This is the best ice cream I've had in my entire life and will be gladly driving an hour for it!read more

Another great ice cream place to add to the list! The variety of flavors and new flavors I haven't…read moreseen was really great to see. The s'mores ice cream was divine. I love how they were able to get that graham cracker taste and it not be over powered by the other notes. Service was great, the ladies were so nice and gave us great recommendations.

I've always loved Jefferson Dairy. We were headed to mini golf and stopped in before to get our…read morefavorites. I love Elephants Never Forget and it never disappoints. Hubby went for the supersized "The Jeffrey" which included Dirty Diaper (my other favorite), Elephants never forget, Lake Hopatcong Mud. It was topped off w/ chocolate cream cookies, whipped cream and of course a cherry on top. They are always super nice and let you sample any flavors you wish. When it's nice out, they have chairs and picnic tables for you to sit, relax and enjoy!

You don't need to look any other place other than the dairy swirl on Route 94 on your way to Vernon…read moreand I gotta tell you you will be amazed and you will put this down as your best ice cream place around. I know we will.

friendly staff the answer the phone and have low-fat and sugar-free offerings. What more can you…read moreask for?

Dear Yelp, How have…read moreI never reviewed Curly's before!? Mind blown. Curly's is not our nearest ice cream shop, but we make it a point to come here often - the ice cream is that good. My favorite is a small cup of coffee royale and graham slam. Dear husband is newly dairy free. He knew he was ordering dole whip today but really wanted it on a waffle cone. He was pleasantly surprised when the counter person went in the back to check the box. And excellent news- the plain waffle cones are dairy free! He said the orange dole whip was very good! There is street parking or they have a lot. Tables inside to eat or benches outside. Love, Nicole

Curly's Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt was a quick pit stop we didn't expect to stop by when we were…read morecraving on a Saturday afternoon. I had a berry whip in a small cup. Refreshing and it was the right amount to get a solid taste of what to like for next time . Small town, home made icecream. In a small space, it doesn't stop anyone from coming in to have taste.

The ambiance is so cute, love the wall art, plushies, games and overall vibe. Super cute spot for…read morethe family, yourself or with a date. The service was fast and friendly, no complaints. Even 30 min before closing they smiled and made me feel welcomed.The ice cream was a lot, I couldn't finish my rolled up cup of Oreo ice cream. Overall 5/5!

Such a fun ice cream shop! Very spacious inside with plenty of photo opportunities. There are board…read moregames spread throughout the space for you to play while you enjoy your ice cream. Staff was very welcoming & patient as we looked over the menu. The ice cream was presented perfectly & it tasted delicious. Parking can be a bit tricky but this place is definitely worth it!

We came here at night and it was pretty empty, it took a minute or two for the person who came out…read moreand greet us - she was incredibly sweet and very nice. I decided to get their Dulce de Leche milkshake without the whipped cream on top. The milkshake was OK, it didn't really taste like Dulce de Leche, but that was to be expected since I haven't been able to find a place in New Jersey that is accurate with that taste. I do have to point out that the ice cream they sell here, from looking at the containers, is "Gifford's Famous ice cream," so it'll match other ice cream places who use the same supplier. The prices were reasonable and there was a fair variety of ice cream, but it not being "homemade" (though they don't claim to be) is what isn't great for me. I believe they have a couple tables inside that you can sit on which is nice, and it seems like they also sell crêpes, but I didn't see them on the menu, though I did see the machine.

Meli's just opened recently. We were happy to be able to get some ice cream on a hot day. It was a…read morelittle expensive but it was very good. Now that we know less than 8% of plastic has been recycled, plastic is toxic and effecting our health, it would be nice to see bamboo utensils and less plastic containers.

This ice cream shop is located in a cute plaza. The inside is bright and spacious, almost a little…read moretoo spartan. They have ice cream, milk shakes, ice cream sodas, flurries, Italian ice, ice cream sandwiches, and ice cream cakes which you can order in custom sizes. The ice cream is fairly standard issue, but the scoop prices are good, hence 4 stars. There is a playground behind the building, which my kiddo enjoyed after eating our ice cream!

Lily is so nice !! Best best best ice cream place in Jersey both locations are incredible! I LOVE…read moreIT and amazing flavors and all the girls are so nice and the cakes are beautiful ! chefs kiss

What a great little "self-serve" ice cream stand in Newton (closer to Stillwater). Cash only, pay…read moreand fill your own cup or cone. Today's special flavors were "maple creme" and "honey". Or you could select vanilla, chocolate or strawberry. Nice clean well kept area with picnic benches to sit and relax. What a treat.

The sugar shack is an awesome little self serve ice cream trailer located in a scenic country…read moresetting. You can choose between a cone or a cup and they always have chocolate, vanilla, chocolate/vanilla twist and usually two seasonal flavors to offer. Sometimes it's maple creame, strawberry, pumpkin, mint or even sweet corn. Their ice cream is amazing and the concept of being a self service ice cream trailer is so cool! The people that own it are super nice and it's the perfect treat after a long hike or a hot day doing chores around the farm!