It's my job to take my friend there. She's been coming here for a couple of years. But lately, they're not very dependable. It seems they're going out of business. The landlord is evicting them. They are having markdowns on everything; in order to raise capital. If you have any money on the consignment list, it would be advisable to collect it now. Don't bother calling; it always goes to voicemail. The vast majority of photos that are on their site were taken by me read more

See all

The only reason I'm giving this one store is because it closed without sufficient notice. I just wanted to make a post to spread the sad word.. In case you've not heard---- PERMANENTLY CLOSED. I will not push rumors, just quietly mourn the loss of this shopping experience. When it closed, consigners like me may have lost our consigned goods, but for me, the loss of this unique shop and lovely staff. read more

See all

BEWARE: if i could leave zero stars i would. Nicole is super sweet & friendly IF she thinks you are there to make a purchase. But if you are selling something she's only nice to you once she gets your items. THEN she is rude, dismissive, has a bad attitude and is running a Con. She sold some items and never ever sent the money due. Items were dropped off on March 2022. Some were sold Summer of 2022. Was told in November the check was in the the mail. It's now February 2023 and no check in the mail. She is a THEIF and she has done this to other people as well. read more

Hello, i brought a lot of items there to be sold. right now i still have not been paid. I was given a a small check and guess what the account was closed. She still owes me money. i would not go there and bring anything to sell for me.I was cheated and treated very badly. Sell the stuff your self..I am going to see,what i can do, to get my money from her. read more

The store has a welcoming & vintage sleek vibe to it however it's very pricey for second hand merchandise. we left satisfied with our purchases & the owner was being social & professional with us it just felt more like retail prices and spending more nowadays living in inflation isn't something I want to do. There's not a large selection of clothing and you can barely find a size large. read more

I would give -10 if I could. The last time I asked for payment due I was put off several times and finally got a check that bounced. I was eventually reimbursed including NSF bank fees via Venmo when I mentioned I would report her. Now I am trying to get paid out the balance due to me. I have emailed multiple times. Can't leave a message since the voicemail is full. I have a cell # for Nicole which has been disconnected. Nicole Wrona shame on you! Do yourself and customers a favor and close up your shop. You are in over your head. read more

Very difficult to reach on phone. Way too high priced. Was given attitude when I asked a question. Required three visits plus several calls to get paid. Black Bird is superior in every way. read more

Great consignment shop! Lots of selection and good prices. Friendly staff. I could spend a whole afternoon there reworking my wardrobe!

I really love the concept of this place, but I'm not sure how they stay in business. I've consigned here a few times, each time with different issues, but it seems like things are going down hill. To note: I have no problems or issues with their consignment policies at all. First time I consigned, they didn't enter my items in their database, so there were problems with them knowing if/when my items were sold, which was a bit annoying. Several phone calls back and forth with much research on their part and 2 trips into the store- it was finally resolved. The next time, they told me some of my items didn't sell and were donated, yet I saw 2 of my items still for sale on the floor. Since then, I have stopped in a few times attempting to consign from time to time and have been turned away or told that they weren't receiving consignments that day/at that time or without an appointment. Fine. Understood. So this time when I attempted to consign again I tried to call in advance to find out when I could bring my items in. Phone isn't working. I try for a week. Phone still out of order. I happen to notice they have a new 'outlet' location closer to where I live. I decide to call to see if I could consign there instead or at least find out what's going on with the other location. Guess what- phone isn't working there either. So I walk there instead. Girl says no consignments at that location yet. So I tell her I'm trying to contact the original location to bring in items to consign. She messages the owner, asks for my phone number and tells me the owner will call me directly. She also says Mondays you don't need an appointment, you can just stop by the shop anytime on Monday. Perfect. No one ever called me back. I called again on Monday morning. Phones STILL not working. Decided to just go in on Monday, I make the 18 minute drive and arrive by 4pm and the place is closed and locked. Sign on the door says they are open until 5pm - and no additional sign or explanation as to why they are closed early. To say I'm DONE with this place would be an understatement. Probably great for those who want to shop here and won't be irritated if you show up and they are randomly closed. There are 2-3 other consignment shops in the area that I'll be bringing items to instead. The store may be called SIMPLICITY, but clearly it doesn't refer to the actual consignment process. It really shouldn't be this hard. read more

edit this an edit to my original post below. i want it known that effective today the owner of simplicity nicole and myself are resolving the issue that i originally mentioned. i stand corrected most of my items have been found and the sear continues and we are working on resolving the missunderstanding on my part. i greatly underestimated all the factors that go into locating my items and i apologize. i mean no harm to simplicity or owner nicole. thank you. beware brought large quality (approx 27) of high end jewelry items from previous antique shop business supposedly all were unsold however requested return of my merchandise more then one month before my item expiration date and got 2 jewelry pieces returned claimed she can't locate items over two months later. unethical business practices is taking place here. read more

Simplicity - EDIT ORIGINAL POST - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

Horrible service! I was given a late check that had bounced back. I called and emailed multiple times with no response. I showed up to the store multiple times and Nicole had an excuse every time as to why she couldn't pay me back yet. We finally agreed that she would have the cash in store with her the next day. When I went to pick it up the next day during her business hours the store was closed!! Once it was mentioned that the authorities would be involved I finally received my payment. read more

Ok place to shop ..... CONSIGNERS BEWARE ! I have had nothing but excuses to get my valuable merchandise back , not to mention checks for merchandise sold . I have written multiple e mails with excuses that I can not get MY Prada and other high end merchandise. BEWARE read more

Beautiful inviting space with gorgeous daily priced items for everyone The owner is super friendly warm and welcoming as soon as you walk through the door knowledgeable about all items in store I have found several unique and affordable pieces here Sizes and items for everyone I would highly recommend going to this beautiful boutique- soon becoming my new favorite store read more

I went to this store today just to browse. I happened to look around & finally saw this orange handbag. Next to a red bag. Morgan, the young staff was very helpful & friendly.I decided to buy the orange bag which was labeled Celine. It took me few minutes to buy but the problem was I didn't examine the bag . I went out of the store, called my Y sister & she thought the bag might not be real thing . So I went back within 5 min to tell the owner/ manager what I thought. She got very upset & said they don't sell not real bags, stuff etc. I didn't see the big sign in the wall about no returns until I went back in. I was not informed verbally about no returns. I was made to get another bag instead of returning even when I wasn't t so sure I wanted an exchange because that's all they will allow me to do. Needless to say, I'm not going back to that store.I was literally out of the door 5 minutes, was still in the premises of Simplicity store. I think it's really bad customer service. That same person told me that the previous owner of the orange bag is very wealthy & she doesn't buy fake bags. I have a few very wealthy friends & they do buy fake or copied bags. read more

Fill your handbags with paper, they will have more appeal than those deflated ones hanging around. Get over high end ugly stuff just because it has a name. read more

Simplicity Consignment Shop Is a Vintage ,Rustic,Shabby Chic .. full collection of perfect mix deals of unique items You can't find anywhere else.Nicole is the owner this store is definitely a representation of her VIBRANT SELF!The stores always updated ..CLEAN..and so INVITING! Love This Store! Giuliana read more

Unprofessional owner who outwardly disrespects not only her customers, but her staff. Also, payment is a constant issue requiring many unreturned calls, visits to the store, and one time the check bounced. I am still waiting for payment on a high end item, which was due to me one week ago now. Always an issue. read more

Great store offering unique and interesting items for your wardrobe or home. Items are curated by color, so the store is easy to navigate.

Fantastic consignment store! It's very well-organized and has a wide array of items that can appeal to both older and younger generations. Many of the items I looked at were $20-40, but they did have a 50% off section. I also love that they have fitting rooms. Only critique is that one of the employees was a bit loud. read more

I prefer to do business with the small business owner. However, every time I have dealt with the owner there has been an issue, including taking a lengthy amount of time paying the consignor. Today was the final straw when I was treated in a condescending, demeaning manner only because I did not know that the rules have changed and on Mondays an appointment is required. In front of another person I was chastised for not having an appointment and was told that I needed to make an appointment, even though there was one other person in the store. So, I came home and phoned Linda's Stuff who promptly emailed me a free shipping label. I will not do business with Simplicity again. read more

A Hidden Gem! My girlfriend who is a real bargain hunter recommended we pop in here before meeting another girlfriend at a nearby restaurant. This was one of the most productive ways I have killed an half an hour! Looked around the small shop chock full of top quality used women's clothing and accessories, and discovered two cross chest purses with lots of pockets that are hard to find, that looked brand new, and bought them. Also bought a beautiful birthday card for a friend. Their already low prices are further discounted by items being on sale. The owner, Nicole, offered excellent customer service. Don't wait until other business brings you near them, they are worth a trip all by themselves! read more

See all

What a unique and well curated shop. Such interesting finds!

I have been coming to this consignment shop for years. Best one in Dutchess County by far, their selection is always an assortment of tasteful pieces. I highly recommend Simplicity for anyone looking for something unique & affordable. Every encounter at this shop is an adventure read more

Simplicity is a great consignment store. The items are high quality and priced appropriately. There are discounts and sales. The owner is young and has a good eye for design. The layout of her shop is more like a boutique than a consignment store. She offers women's clothing, jewelry, and housegoods. Make the trip. It's worth it. read more

Great stuff. Cool place. Items are like new. Worth the trip. I have bought several items at a great price. I would shop there again.