Not an artisan pizza or a hand tossed crust. Their specialty is a perfect thin crispy crust. It is…read morevery consistent in form and thickness which leads me to believe that it is factory premade. Premade or not, it forms an excellent base for the pie. This is not NY style pizza, so save your bitchin' for someone who cares. This is a good ol' small town, pizza joint pizza, loaded with a generous thick layer of fresh ingredients. 12" Papa Joe's Supreme. Not greasy, not overloaded with sauce. It is packed with meat, veggies and cheese. We had leftovers. Still tasty, cold from the refrigerator the next day. Big comfortable deck with picnic tables for outside dining. Nice view of the cove. Right next door to Sharky's ice house. I imagine this place gets to rockin' on the weekend. Friendly service. Great place to spend this beautiful spring afternoon. The pizza is good! Someone's dog either bit someone or took a crap on the deck; as of March, no dogs allowed.

Never have had a bad slice. Good pizza and cold beer with a good view of boats and Grand Lake…read more Could life get any better?

We had the original Stromboli very good service is great. We really enjoyed coming here when we're…read morecamping at natural Falls State Park in Oklahoma.

This pizza is a bit different than most. Super thin crust, an Italian sausage called span - I may…read morenot remember that right. I don't think there was any tomato sauce on it. Good and worth a try!

We stopped by to get some food, pizza was delicious Greg was so nice and sweet! Super helpful and…read moretold us about the deals and the best flavors. The inside seemed super clean. Will be coming back for sure!

We found Papa G's a delightful little drive through pizza joint. There is only outdoor seating,…read morewhich on a hot day was not ideal. However, the pepperoni pizza was delicious. My first impression was "where's the pepperoni?", but then i discovered it was tucked in between two layers of cheese. This was great! Also, I am used to dabbing grease from my pepperoni pizzas with a napkin. Not so here! It had the right amount of grease. The crust was battered with salted butter as well. We will be back!

The pizza is consistently great even delivered! They used to…read morehave gluten free crust. I've never eaten it. I didn't know they had other Italian food and sandwiches! Gotta try it!

Love the pizza. Be sure to allow plenty of time as they stay quite busy during warmer weather…read moremonths when the lake is popular.

Such a fun, small town pizza place!!! Great pizza...their pre-set designed pizzas are a great price…read morefor a ton of toppings!!! (I'd really like fresh mushrooms, but the pizza was delicious!) It was 20 minutes from order to piping hot pizza on our table. You can also call ahead your order, and they even offer take-and-bake We ate inside at a tall table, but next time we're going to try the comfy chairs out on the covered/lit patio. We'll be back!!!

Had dinner here tonight for the first time! It's order at the counter, seat yourself. We shared a…read moregarden salad that had very good ranch. We shared buffalo wings, which were very tasty. And a hit man pizza. It's basically supreme. It was also very good. It's a cute little spot on the Main Street downtown with indoor and outdoor seating. I'd definitely eat here again. Good local pizza.

We had the pizza with all the meats on it, and it was freaking delish! Also tried their Hawaiian…read morepizza....HOLAY! Best ever!!

We got the supreme pizza and the Mediterranean salad…read more The pizza was top notch! It was loaded with toppings and had a thin and delightfully crunchy crust. The salad was also very good, but we would prefer mixed greens instead of the iceberg lettuce that it came with. Our server, Amber, did a great job!

What can you say about a HUGE restaurant in the middle of no where with a HUGE fan base, karaoke…read moreand a couple bars? Try the PIZZA. In town again w the fam. Was recommended the pizza. Walked in, had a drink while I waited and took it home. Ordered a large SHEBANG special. Sausage, pepperoni, canadian bacon and black olives and bell peppers. Thin crust, covered in toppings, hot and fast. I'll be back. With my karaoke pants on next time.

It's been about 5 years since I have been to this restaurant and I'm glad to see that is now under…read morenew ownership. Ironically I got to meet the family that took it over and they are great people whom I believe will revive this place. The service was great and had no complaints on that end. Always friendly and welcoming. Now to the food. I got some appetizers such as the jalapeño pimento cheese dip and cheese curds. It was as expected. I ordered the prime rib, which is what they are supposed to be known for. I ordered my prime rib medium rare and it came out well done. Prime rib is usually served with a horseradish sauce but I didn't get any. I asked for a side and my server came back and said they had to make some. I had no problems with that, but when the sauce came out, it tasted way closer to tartar sauce than horseradish sauce. Truly, this was the worst prime rib that I have ever eaten in my life. I am hopeful the new ownership will turn things around for this iconic spot.

I'm a pizza snob. Mama Tigs pizzas are on point! Delicious crust, I ate the slices backwards to…read moreenjoy the crispy first crunch bite. It's not all crispy though, the first bite gives way to a light and airy yet moist dough, almost like a fresh sourdough loaf with a perfect crumb. The dining room is super clean and chill. Played good tunes at an enjoyable volume, I hate super loud places. Staff is very nice and checked on me in perfect intervals!

Here from California to see family. Everyone recommended this place! Deep red marina sauce on the…read moreSausage & pepperoni Calzone I ordered. Really good! But my wife's Chicken Alfredo, Spinach, Artichoke tasted more than authentic. Cool building out in the woods, with a real family dining room feel! I've been traveling to and from Muskogee for years and this is Awesome!

We called in a pizza order, and it was ready by the time we drove over. We got the mobster pizza,…read moreand it was excellent. We will definitely come back here next time we are in the area for a lake trip. Service was friendly as well!

We recently purchased a lake home on Grand Lake. We have been trying the local restaurants and it…read morewas Gambino's turn. We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza, one of my favorites. When we opened the box the pizza looked great, full of toppings and lots of cheese, no skimping on ingredients. The pizza tasted awesome much better than other pizza we've had at the lake so far. We will be getting Gambino's again.

We called and asked what the specials were and was told a med Supreme and a large pepperoni for 20…read moredollars. But when we picked them up we received two medium. So we told them that the order was and they said that's not what was said to us . And on top of all that the female that was there was extremely rude. And one more thing we bought 6 pizzas and four of them wasn't even sliced.

Pizza is delicious. I love the stromboli! I wish they had a deal with the stromboli in it…read more Everything there is yummy!!