Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Shereese's Baked Goods

    5.0 (1 review)

    Shereese's Baked Goods Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Shereese's Baked Goods

    Recommended Reviews - Shereese's Baked Goods

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    The desserts are the best and are craveable beyond belief once you get one taste of her deserts you will become a regular gaurenteed.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Shereese's Baked Goods

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 11,613 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sweet Mandy B's - Banana cupcake with chocolate buttercream!

    Sweet Mandy B's

    4.3(138 reviews)
    8.3 kmNear North Side, River East
    $$

    What can I say? I'm a frosting girl and Sweet Mandy B's is the best spot to get my fix!…read more If you love buttercream like I do, you'll find many treats here that will be right up your alley! From frosted cookies, cupcakes, and even cake by the slice, they also sell pies (including by the slice), brownies, scones, and all kinds of other goodies. There's definitely something for everyone (With a sweet tooth) here. It's a great spot! This location in particular had a lot of seating, as well, and is also accessible from the Northwestern Med building or from the street! I especially loved the Cookie Monster cupcake. Vanilla cake with a chocolate chip cookie baked at the bottom, with chocolate buttercream. I think. It was DELICIOUS! The perfect sweet treat!

    A Longtime Fan, but Lately... a Mixed Bag at Sweet Mandy B's…read more I've been a loyal Sweet Mandy B's customer for more than five years. In that time, I've raved about their desserts to friends, hosted celebrations with their cakes, and considered them one of my go-to bakeries in the city. But over the last 12-18 months, something has shifted and the experience has become surprisingly hit or miss. The first indicator was a slice of their snickerdoodle cake that we tried several months ago. The cupcake had always been a favorite so we thought we would try the cake slice, but this time it arrived disappointingly dry. A few weeks later, we tried the banana cake slice, and it was a completely different story, moist, flavorful, and topped with a rich chocolate frosting that reminded me why I fell in love with Sweet Mandy B's in the first place. Their cupcakes were another longtime love of mine. However, they now come standard with sprinkles or chips on top. When I asked if I could get one without those toppings, I was told I'd need to place a custom order (which can't be done for a single cupcake). It felt surprisingly inflexible for such a small request. For a recent birthday, I ordered a yellow cake with chocolate icing. Unfortunately, it landed on the "miss" side of the spectrum, dry and crumbly. Thirteen guests tried it, and more than one commented that even a boxed mix would've tasted better. Lastly, we picked up the peanut butter Rice Krispies treats, a nostalgic favorite. These, too, were disappointing: stale, tough to cut, and ultimately left unfinished because no one enjoyed them. Bottom line: Sweet Mandy B's still has the ability to wow when they get it right. But the inconsistency in quality has become hard to overlook. As a longtime fan, I'm really hoping they return to the delicious reliability that made them such a standout in the first place.

    Photos
    Sweet Mandy B's - Cake tops

    Cake tops

    Sweet Mandy B's - Ordering at counter- wonderfully, lovely staff, very helpful.

    Ordering at counter- wonderfully, lovely staff, very helpful.

    Sweet Mandy B's

    See all

    Sweet Mandy B's - Wedding Cake

    Sweet Mandy B's

    4.2(1.8k reviews)
    12.1 kmDePaul, Lincoln Park
    $$

    We had the absolute best experience working with Sweet Mandy B's for our wedding cake!…read more From the very beginning, the communication was seamless. Their team was so kind, responsive, and easy to work with throughout the entire process, which made wedding planning feel so much less stressful. One of our favorite parts was the tasting experience they set up for us before selecting our cake flavors and frosting. They prepared an incredible assortment of cupcakes, fillings, and icings for us to sample so we could truly customize the perfect combination for our wedding day. Everything tasted AMAZING, and it made the whole process feel so fun and special. The final cake was absolutely beautiful, delicious, and such a hit with our guests. You could truly taste the quality and care that went into it. They also handled delivery directly to our event space, which made everything so easy and stress-free on the big day. We are so grateful to the Sweet Mandy B's team for helping make our wedding day feel extra special. Highly, highly recommend!

    My husband and I booked an adventure in the city that takes us around little restaurants in Lincoln…read morePark to "collect" food and end with a picnic in Oz Park and just... so much fun! The most adorable little dessert shop. The vibe was a whole VIBE. I love it. And the chicas behind the register were so sweet. We got cupcakes here and they were yummy. So happy to know this place is here so we know where to go for our sweet tooth if we're ever in the area.

    Photos
    Sweet Mandy B's - Custom birthday cake

    Custom birthday cake

    Sweet Mandy B's - Peanut Butter Rice Krispie

    Peanut Butter Rice Krispie

    Sweet Mandy B's

    See all

    Shereese's Baked Goods - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...