I have been dealing with a back injury since April of 2016. I have yet to see a single doctor who examined my back. This in particular is about Dr Brophy of Semmes-
Murphey. I went to him first on December 2nd, 2016. I gave him a MRI disc for my back injury, which he then ignored. My chart, prepared by Brophy and on record at Semmes-Murphey, states he diagnosed my back injury as Cervical Myofascial Pain Syndrome. Despite my injury being a back injury, he managed to ignore the back entirely and focus on the neck.
The MRI report, which I obtained a copy of, states that there are two bulging discs in the T5-6 and T6-7 area, with a paracentral extrusion on the T7-8 vertebrae, resulting in a leftward displacement of the spinal cord. This has more in common with Spinal Stenosis, but as Brophy has made clear, he will not examine nor treat my injury regardless. Initially, he refused to even accept that I had a back injury.
As he had decided to ignore the back injury, he sent me to work hardening, which at best caused further harm. In addition, he intentionally gave conflicting work duty orders. He ordered me to "Continue Current Duty" one one line, and ordered me back to work on another. As I only noticed the former, I now have no job thanks to Brophy's efforts.
During the Dec 30th appointment, he repeatedly denied that he would provide any treatment, insisting that as the neck MRI showed no injury, there was no injury. He also harassed me for trying to not further injure my back, as he desired. He also lied and claimed that he did not diagnose my injury as a cervical injury, however I have the original chart from the Semmes-Murphey website, which proves he only diagnosed the injury as cervical myofascial pain initially. As he's already altered the chart, I can only assume he's modified every record at Semmes-Murphey as well, in an effort to conceal his actions.
http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e45/azraelck/chartoriginal.jpg - The original chart, as prepared by Dr John D Brophy and on record at Semmes Murphey.
http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e45/azraelck/MRIReport.jpg - The Thoracic MRI, showing the radiologist's report that my spinal cord has been displaced leftward by a paracentral extrusion of the T7-8 vertebrae. Note that according to Dr Brophy, vertebrae are part of the muscular system, and the spinal cord is not part of the nervous system.
When confronted he refused to address the injury at all. He, in fact, at one point started laughing at me in mocking derision. He also stated that there was no injury to the nervous system. So according to Dr Brophy, the spinal cord is not part of the nervous system.
After confronting him about his misdiagnoses, he went and altered my medical records, adding a quick thoracic myofascial pain syndrome diagnoses to the chart. The updated chart still shows the dates however, proving he only added that diagnoses after I confronted him, and it still ignores the displaced spinal cord which is the cause of my pain.
At best, Brophy systematically disregards his patients' injuries entirely, perhaps feeling that as many workman's compensation cases involve the poor, they have no ability to hold him accountable. He seems to derive great pleasure in harming his patients, and has gone out of his way to do so.
Because of his intentional efforts to prevent me from receiving treatment for my back injury, I now have no job, and have no ability to work as I once did. He actively has conspired to harm me, and has done so very well. And he did nothing but laugh about the matter. He has also falsely stated that I have been uncooperative in treatment. I followed every order I was given, no matter how wrongly it was given. I was early to every appointment.
An internet search shows that his only diagnoses is myofascial pain. Irrespective of what the injury is, or what MRIs, CT scans, or Xrays show, he will always claim it is myofascial pain syndrome. He also will demand patients cause further damage to their injuries, just for his own sick and twisted amusement.
He has a noted history of complaints, especially of worker's compensation cases, of ignoring injuries entirely based on what the case worker and insurance adjuster ordered him to do. Others have noted that their medical records were falsified by him in an attempt to conceal his misbehavior.
I have, with only a few minutes of searching, found 4 malpractice lawsuits against him, with more likely having been sealed under court order. These can be easily searched at https://www.juralindex.com/. Likewise, you can find similar complaints of medical fraud and malpractice against him at www.healthgrades.com and likely other doctor review sites as well.
If this is the kind of behaviour that Semmes-Murphey condones and supports, then they should be shut down. Dr Brophy is nothing less than a criminal sociopath, and Semmes Murphey enables and protects him. read more