The food was so good! We started with the mozzarella sticks and garlic bites! Pictures will show…read morehow good they are!! Two of our party got the pizza rolls (ham & pineapple and then a pepperoni), one the lasagna & also a meatball sandwich (they toasted the bread) with fries! We left with full happy tummies! The only slight downside was it was a bit longer stop than we had expected, but understandable since they were swamped!

I was driving thru. Ordered over the phone to pickup. The custom pizza roll (with sausage,…read morepepperoni, green peppers, and black olives) was amazing. I thought I would eat only a portion of it, but it was so delicious, I ate the whole thing. Also ordered a cannoli (wish id gotten the tiramisu). Cannoli was just ok. The filling was a bit runny, and didn't completely fill the shell.

Very good pizza and wonderful folks running it. Namesake of the place and owner was very nice and…read morevisited with all her customers and made sure they had everything they need. Supreme pizza lives up too it's name and a 10" is enough for two people or one really hungry one. Nice small town pizza parlor with a down home vibe.

I first opened the box and was immediately disappointed because I dislike thin crust pizza but one…read morebite and I was hooked! This place is amazing! I have only been twice and only for pizza but I am excited to try their whole menu. They don't deliver but when I went in it was clean and everyone was friendly. They were accommodating with my order (I asked for something other than red sauce on my pizza). I wish they were open on Sundays!

The food was delicious. The service was amazing. & I loved the family friendly ambiance.read more

The food was amazing. We liked the pizza and the fried ravioli. It was truly delicious and we will…read moredefinitely be back!!

Had pizza from Matteo's on Sunday food was good, we had a pepperoni and sausage pizza and pasta…read more Service was quick

Amazing hand tossed crust with just the right amount of crunch in every bite. You can even watch…read morethem toss the dough. There are tons of pizza topping options. They even offer a cauliflower crust if you prefer. The salad bar, smash burgers and wings are also excellent. The arcade and projection movies add to the family atmosphere. Matt puts his heart into every dish and puts smiles on the faces of all his customers.

Amazing gluten free pizza!!…read more Sierra was our waitress & was very friendly!! Cheese bread was also amazing - would definitely come back again!

The crust was very good but just didn't care for the sauce. Can't comment to the service or…read moreambiance because we picked up our order.

Great Beers, especially the Jalapeño Lemon! Highly recommend visiting for lunch and beers!read more

Good beer, good people. I typically don't like beer but they have some great fruity options that I…read morecouldn't believe were beer. I like the whole set up. Definitely go check this place out & catch a game.

Best specialty pizza I've ever had. My favorite is the deep dish taco pizza complete with hot…read moresauce, lettuce, cheese, etc. Nice comfortable booths to sit in too with pleasant low key lighting.

From the owner: Pizza, Pasta,Chicken,Fast Food, Kids Menu, Fish Dinners, Seafood Platters, Chicken Plank Dinners,…read moreCountry Fried Steak Dinners

You don't find square pizza like this anywhere else! I've tried to find a similar pizza but…read morenothing quite matches it. And I know, I know - square is not a taste! But believe me it is! The atmosphere is also great - warm and cozy. It can be busy so find a good time to come or be prepared to wait on a weekend evening!

Best pizza in town: thin crust, always well-balanced level of ingredients, cooked to perfection…read more Love this eatery and vibe!

The guy hung up on me when I was upset because my order was late. Very freaking rude.read more

Worst customer service experience I have ever seen. Didn't even get my food. Rudest managers ever.read more

Loved this. It's out a ways but worth it. Every beer was terrific! Super nice staff. We will be…read moreback

This is an amazing find and super relaxing atmosphere that feels like home. Beer was better than…read moregood--award winning. Check it out