This place reminds me of so many places I loved when younger. I mean I still love them now but I do…read morenot use manic panic in my hair anymore :P we had fun looking at everything, bought a few things too. I'm just happy we had a little town to walk around in that was not like a shopping center.

Always great stuff to see and find here! Fun, kitschy selections great for gifts on any occasion…read more Helpful and personable staff. Thanks!

My Mom has picked out perfect gifts, for her grandchildren and greats for years, from this store…read more The owner directs Mom towards toys based on each child's likes. She also wraps and ships them around the country. The suggested gifts are a hit everytime. The owners knowledge,advice and variety are priceless . She has made this a valuable source of perfect gifts from Grandparents.This store is a hidden gem.

If you're a childless gal with lots of friends' kiddos to buy for then I highly recommend Kim…read more(owner and now dubbed by one of my friends as a 'gift concierge') to shop for you! She stayed in my price range, picked out 2 gifts for each kid (for the 2024 holidays) & wrapped everything! The kids have absolutely loved their gifts! Worth the 1 hour drive!

Just had an absolute blast talking to John and making a deal with some of my old collectors stuff…read more He was super friendly and knowledgeable, and wanted to make sure that I got the right/best price for my items. I genuinely felt like he cared about his job which is refreshing. Some places treat you like your stuff is garbage, you DO NOT get that when you come here.

This is such a special shop - seriously, one of the coolest stores I've ever been to. It's packed…read moreto the brim with nostalgia and charm, filled with all the toys of your childhood from the '50s and beyond. Loved all the walkie-talkies, Super Nintendo games, '80s original G1 Transformers, Polly Pockets, Ginny Dolls, Smurf figurines, Rageddy Ann dolls, Strawberry Shortcakes, Furbys and more. John, the owner, is incredibly smart, helpful, and funny. Name an esoteric toy, and he knows it and has got it! We'll make the drive to Pawling just to come back. Cannot wait and am already recommending this shop to everyone. 5 stars!!!!!!

Love this store! Great Customer Service and attentive staff. They recently came into new ownership…read moreand you can tell - better store layout, new stock of toys, books and anything you could need or want. My wife and I love the puzzles they stock as well. Prices are great and comparable with what you would see on Amazon - usually slightly cheaper and you get to support a local small business. They have A cute train table that my kids always want to play with. Also the mini shopping carts are too cute! Location is great too, you can stop and get a bite to eat or coffee nearby, and close to the library.

This place is awesome! Love that there's a toy store my baby can frequent during her childhood…read moreyears. I popped in not expecting much and ended up buying a cute sit & play for my baby. I was happy to support a local business and didn't care if it would cost more. However, I googled the price for what it's sold elsewhere and Nordica sold it for $20 less. Woohoo!

I tried to comment on Troy Emmi reply but I ended up updating the hole review. I don't know if…read morethere's a feature on here that I can reply to the owners comment but there is something that I need to say that's going to be listed down below. 8/15/21: After writing this review on Yelp Troy Emi (head at Fanboy Collectibles) decided to post all of my personal information Full name, Phone number, Address, and Email address and to a different site for everyone to see. What is something NO BUSINESS should do with a customer's personal information. I'm not going to allow someone like this to steal $210 and then post all of my personal information on another site. I will be contacting his Police Department as soon as I can in his Township about him posting my personal information. Troy Emi has a history of doing what he did to me to other people aswell. Only customers had this same experience of him stealing and robbing them out of money. He stole my $210.00 an what he's doing now it's not acceptable. On top of that when we first had this issue what I forgot to mention was that he was sending me rude and nasty Facebook messages and Emails due to he was upset with me more or less of him harassing me and calling me racist slurs. The guy is not professional whatsoever and he should probably not even be running a business if he's going to act like this. Original review written: on Google. BEWARE OF THIS COMPANY. Stole $210.00 of deposits I had with this company. They closed my account do to I got in a damaged statue and after I told them the problem with the statue I got in they closed my account and kept all the pre order deposit I had with them. Before this I was shopping with this company for 2 years but right when I had a problem they closed my account and stole my deposits I had on my pre orders with them. Best to buy somewhere else. I would not recommend this company whatsoever 2/11/22: Saw that Troy Emmi cared to reply back on 1/28/22 but Troy didn't tell the truth again. In Troy Emmi reply he said "This customer has made these claims that we have stolen this money on multiple social media platforms and Yelp. To which we always reply with all of the information we listed above and have stated we have all of the e-mails, screenshots and sales orders to which we've referred and can gladly make them available." I these had a BBB claim upped about Troy Emmi at Fanboy Collectibles because of him taking all my personal business information that I gave him and posting it on a different website for everyone to see. Troy never provided any of that information that he says that he has whatsoever to the Better Business Bureau. Almost as if he doesn't happen. The only thing he did was talk negative about me as a customer and about my past negative business experiences with other companies and businesses. Also the worker at Better Business Bureau I spoke to them by phone and she also said I should probably contact consumer relations about him or a lawyer do to him stealing the $210 of mine but most definitely about him taking all my personal information and posting it online. So Troy Emmi at Fanboy Collectibles is now believing that BBB is wrong? Also I did try to contact consumer relations by phone but because of covid data on take phone calls and to set up a complaint on this site is kind of hard for me. Something else Troy Emmi has said is "As for these new claims. If we were harassing you on Facebook why would you not just report us to Facebook? They would immediately close our account." Troy Emmi has me Blocked on Facebook. It's kind of hard to report something when you're blocked Troy. Now I have screenshots of that and everything else proving my point if you want it. So the first picture is of me logged into my Facebook and Gmail account and the 2nd is of me when I'm not. So yeah. Blocked. So yeah. I do care about this because I'm not going to have something steal $210.00 from me first and 2nd post my personal information online and have that be OK. Troy Emmi did this samething to another customer if you look at the reviews left to his company.

What a great experience. I was at the recent NY Comic-con…read moreand was looking for some rare statues for my collection. There were a few vendors selling what I was looking for and were close in price between each other. After explaining my situation to the owner of Fanboy, Troy Emmi, he took his time to go over different options and even was able to help me preorder some rare items on his site, that no one else had available. He was basically 10%-15% below all the other companies and I have purchased about 4 more items since then and all we delivered as advertised in perfect condition. Some of these other reviewers seem to be focused on shipping issues which any owner has no control of.

I went there for the first time on Saturday and I was impressed by the tracks in the merchandise…read moreand especially the owner and his workers. If there was 20 stars, I would give them that great place to visit and buy.

Stopped in for the first time looking for a screw I needed for my Tamiya Brat. Although he didn't…read morehave the Tamiya part I need he came up with a creative solution using parts he had. Thanks for getting me running again.

Keep in mind if you come here occasionally you might have to wait a little bit for a lane to open…read moreup. But also at the same time this target is always 50/50 for being good service, good selection and a good value. You might have days where this place is like a closet but at the same time it might be good. This is really depended on if it is a good trip.

I visited this location on 12/28/25…read more There were no shopping carts in the store and, because no one returns carts to the corrals anymore, I had to chase one down across the parking lot while toting a 19-month-old. Also, the two people in the tech section pitching cell service were weirdly very aggressive and confrontational. I'm sure it's an awful job to cold pitch cell service to people who don't want to talk to you but, as the saying goes, you'll catch more flies with honey than vinegar.