I would be careful listening to reviews telling you the hotel is clean and comfortable. The hotel was clean. However, the hotel did not provide enough hot water to take a shower longer than two minutes, so baths for two young children was not something that could happen. Housekeeping kept the room at 65 degrees. Any effort to increase the temp to 70 degrees was met with housekeeping adjustments. That's relevant:
The hotel accused me of smoking, twice. Letters claimed there were detected particulates in the air and a room temperature of 80 degrees. Management refused to come up to the room to understand the impossiblity of a room at 80 degrees at 7:01am but 65 degrees by 7:30am. A 15 degree drop would take at least an hour and perhaps as long as three hours. That refusal cost our family a day and a half of our trip.
Hotel reception explained we would have to meet with management downstairs as the smoking fees for each event had already charged to our room. Management would be available in thirty mintutes. We went down at the scheduled time but the manager was still off site - on the way. He rescheduled for an hour later. Management did not show for that meeting either and rescheduled for early afternoon. Again, not there. Towards the end of the day we received a telephone call from the manager who offered only that telephone meeting and a referral to corporate (which made us wonder why anyone had insisted on and scheduled meetings downstairs). Corporate emails doubled down - their equipment was checked and found sufficient. If that is the case, I don't see how it's possible that the device was located in my hotel room.
While we were waiting for the meetings management missed, I read Reddit reviews that warn of this as a scam in this hotel. Because of the way we were treated by hotel management and corporate staff, I understand why folks complaining on Reddit's see this behavior as intentional participation in a scam.
The hotel insisted on being paid 100% after removing the smoking fee, even though their actions ruined the last two days of our trip. Romer "evidence" , "twice", of smoking and their "gift" to remove meant the full invoice was due. American Express explained any cost recovery would be between our family and Romer, robbing us of all leverage. No response from Romer to our telephone call. No suprises there.
Part of me wants to battle the injustice, but I've learned we have systemic issues here in the states that render a normal consumer powerless. The only reasonable recourse we have are these reviews. And they don't hold that much power. The reviews can protect others.
However, a colleague explained that corporations like Romer purchase a service that removes bad reviews from their sets of reviews. Dear Romer, I don't normally write bad reviews. I normally follow the logic of Thumper's mom, if one does not have anything good to say, don't say anything at all. However, the way your hotel treated my family is out of line and you not only did nothing, you doubled down.
How ridiculous is it that a hotel would tolerate a manager who scheduled a meeting in the morning and fail to show for the entire day trapping a young family visiting from Sweden waiting not knowing. Romer succeeded in confirming my son's low opinion of business here in the states.
Perhaps I should explain that my son laughed when he saw the letter on my bed accusing me of smoking and so did my spouse when we telephoned him. I was the only occupant of the room and freezing. I have been allergic to tar and the chemicals in all smoking products my entire life - vaping is worse. When my family was young, I was able to detect smoke on breath long after the experimenting event - because of that allergy - catching them without exception. My sons didn't end up with a smoking habit thanks to those allergies.
The hotel staff below this management corporate behavior fiaso was wonderful. The staff was never loud or cross allowing us to all behave civily and kind. Very professional. If you can avoid the rooms where the hot water doesn't work and be prepared with an extra blanket, the location is great, you'll have a blast. NYC is a wonderful place of art and history and amazing food. Enjoy. read more