I booked a 5-day, 2x1 archery elk hunt at Fishtail Ranch for September 20-24, 2026. It was my first…read moreelk hunt.
The 2 stars are for the scenery and for the staff who cooked and cleaned up after us. They did a great job all week.
Not getting an elk is part of hunting. My issue is how the hunt was run. We saw 3 elk the first morning and 3 the second. After that, repeat hunters were moved onto those spots, and we were sent to areas with no elk. We didn't see another elk the rest of the hunt. After those first two mornings, it was easy to tell when elk were close or had been spooked. Later in the week the guide said several times that he heard elk, but neither my hunting partner nor I heard any movement.
Most of the hunters in camp were repeat clients, some coming back for 15 years or more. They obviously love the place, and I understand an outfitter taking care of its regulars. As first-timers, though, we got pushed to the back of the bus.
The hunting days were short. We were back at the lodge by about 9:00 am for breakfast, lunch was at 3:00 pm, and we didn't head back out until 4:30 pm or later.
When I booked, I was told the ranch had 30,000 to 35,000 acres. In camp, each guide I asked gave me a different number. I was told that 10,000 acres had no elk and wasn't being hunted, and that some of the property had been sold. The groups hunting the one area with elk kept running into each other, while we were sent elsewhere.
One of the guides told us he knew back in August that the season wasn't shaping up well. I booked a month before the hunt and wasn't told.
Lee, the owner, said the success rate was 25%. The guides and the other hunters in camp told me 3 elk had been killed all archery season out of 56 hunters, about 5%.
Lee wasn't very friendly to us during our stay. Before we left on the last morning, I told him in person that I was disappointed with the trip and why. He defended the 25% number and didn't address the rest. We left before the final morning hunt, and we won't be back.
Questions to ask before booking with this outfitter or any archery elk outfitter:
1. What is the total acreage, how much will actually be hunted this season, and how many hunters will be on it my week?
2. How are hunting areas assigned? Do repeat clients get the better areas?
3. If we get into elk, will we go back to that spot the next day, or could it go to another hunter?
4. What does a typical hunt day look like? How many hours are spent in the field, and can I stay out all day?
5. What was the archery success rate this season and each of the last three seasons, counted as bulls recovered divided by total hunters?
6. Has the area been in drought this year, and how has that affected the elk? Will you tell me before the hunt if the season is running poor?
7. Is my guide local, and how long has he hunted this property?