Cancel

Open app

Search

Reservoir Creek Golf Course

4.5 (14 reviews)

Reservoir Creek Golf Course Photos

Recommended Reviews - Reservoir Creek Golf Course

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Robert G.

I took a Friday off from work to play an early morning round at Reservoir Creek this past Friday and I absolutely loved everything about this golf course. It was so beautiful there, especially with fall foliage all around. The club pro and the clubhouse attendant were so friendly too! I would definitely love to play here again. It was worth the hour and a half drive for me!

Bryan M.

There are golf courses and then there is Reservoir Creek. This is without a doubt one of the most picturesque and challenging courses that I have played in a long time. The scenery alone is worth a visit. The course is located in the hills above Naples, New York, near Candandaigua Lake. The course is only 12 years old and features heavily contoured greens, dramatic changes in elevation,and has challenging rolling fairways that features many mounds and grass and sand bunkers. A delight to play and is on my list to return in the fall.

Owners on the 12th tee box.

See all

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 months ago

A hidden gem in upstate NY.. Very challenging, but fun to play. Be prepared for a serious workout if you walk. Many hills.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Reservoir Creek Golf Course

Review Highlights - Reservoir Creek Golf Course

Beautiful golf course, well kept, has amazing scenery, with rolling hills and tricky greens that make it challenging and always interesting.

Mentioned in 4 reviews

Read more highlights

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Lakeside Country Club

Lakeside Country Club

5.0(2 reviews)
17.6 mi

A five star country club at an affordable price…read more Note: I am not a member, but I come here when my insurance broker from Stork Insurance needs to talk business. Hole 1: An up-hill climb to this elevated par five green will make you re-think your decision to nix a golf cart. A tight, tree-lined fairway on both sides will also make you re-think your decision to pull driver in front of all those clubhouse onlookers. Hole 2: A medium-length par four that has a disorienting tee shot with a large bailout zone to the left that you can't see off the tee. If your tee shot winds up on the 5th green, you get a free drop, which I learned first hand. Hole 3: The opening four hole stretch is the toughest on the course, and this par four's blind, downhill tee shot provides no opportunity for relaxation. Note: If your ball ends up in the neighbor's yard to the right of the fairway, they don't mind if you retrieve it. But don't hit from their lawn (that's just common courtesy). Hole 4: Another steep up-hill climb to an elevated, semi-blind green that is a staple of the opening ten holes. Don't forget to look back toward the tee box from the green! A wonderful view that pays worthy tribute to the club's namesake. Hole 5: A par 3. I usually hit 9-iron to 20 ft, leave my birdie putt five feet short, and then my kind insurance broker says my favorite words: "That's good." Thanks buddy. Put me down for a three. Hole 6: If you're a lefty who fades it, this tee shot looks nearly impossible. But there's a hack: I highly suggest playing a huge cut to the right of the tree that blocks this par five's fairway. It should slice back into play. And if you wind up on the 7th fairway, it's a pretty agreeable angle into the green. You'll be thinkin' eagle (but if you're like me you will probably flub a chip and make a six). Hole 7: The seesaw front nine takes you back uphill on this short but tricky par four. Hole 8: Back downhill on a par 4. Don't miss right! That ball's a goner if you do. Although if you find a Taylor Made 4, that's mine. Please mail it back to me if you can. You can DM me for my address. Hole 9: The longest par 3 on the course, although it's still probably only a middle-iron for most golfers. Hole 10: The back nine (my preferred nine, for sure), begins with an uphill, dogleg right par 4. The elevated, tree-lined green is one of the prettier spots on the course. Hole 11: The course widens on this back nine stretch. If you were hesitant to let driver fly through the first ten holes, now's the time to let your big dog bark. Hole 12: One of my favorites on the course. A par five at just under 500 yards, a good drive will put you in an exciting go/no-go zone. If you challenge the water and win, you'll be raking in the Schlitz cocktails. If you lose, you'll be complaining about how the Finger Lakes air messes up your ball flight (and marking down a number that begins with 's'.) Hole 13: Back- to-back par fives is a quirk of Lakeside, but not a disagreeable one. This is the longest hole on the course, but an open and forgivable fairway makes it another good driving hole. Hole 14: If you're hungry and forgot to grab a bite at the turn, feel free to grab a few fresh grapes off the wonderful vines along the left side of the fairway, kindly placed for you to snack on. Hole 15: Along with the 12th, this is probably my favorite hole. The cottonwood trees provide an inviting and picturesque atmosphere, even when you're slamming your hybrid into the ground because you chunked one from the tree-lined left rough. Hole 16: An attractive, intelligent, and well-dressed par four. This hole may seem like a beautiful and eligible lady when you square up for your tee shot. But as you head down the fairway, you'll notice the ring. Sorry, boys. She's taken. Hole 17: My favorite of the par 3s. The trees once again create a secluded atmosphere that is the motif of the closing four hole stretch. Hole 18: The blue tees provide a tight angle into a wide open green. The white tees offer a much more forgiving shot. Whichever box you play, you'll love the view as you head for clubhouse and then onwards to The Laurentide to pound Schlitz cocktails with your handsome and delightful insurance broker.

I played a round here for the first time last year in July the day after proposing to my now fiancé…read morewhile we were staying at a lake house on Keuka Lake that her family rented out. I will say that I'm glad I played the day after because I think I would've had a nervous breakdown on the course if I played the day of lol. The course was a little dry in some spots, but I loved it there and I loved that it had some scenic views of Keuka Lake!

Photos
Lakeside Country Club

See all

Old Hickory Golf Course - Beautifully maintained

Old Hickory Golf Course

3.6(5 reviews)
18.9 mi

The coarse is in horrible shambles and ruts in-all the fairways with standing water. Very unkept…read more They should have cancelled our tournament. highway robbery. I will never go back

Great course. Scored an 8am tee time during a holiday week by calling the night before! Wow!…read more We showed up early to rent clubs and get balls and tees etc. They had two bags of clubs for us. Between the two bags, it wasn't a full set. We purchased used balls at a dollar a pop and new balls for five bucks a sleeve. Ten tees to a bag was only a dollar, so we grabbed two of those. The shop has some merchandise and snacks. Since we had time, we grabbed a large bag of range balls which cost $8. The pro shop worker let us buy 9 holes for three people and said we could decide if we wanted to do the other nine holes later. Three players for nine holes was $20. Not bad! We asked for a scorecard and headed out to the range. Check the scorecard for a layout of the course. The range was empty. We hit a few balls there. I like how they have distance markers on the range. We skipped the putting range. The greens were well kept but wet from recent rains. The fairways were gorgeous but slow because of the rain. The carts were gas powered. I've never experienced that! No gps or electronic scoring. No windshields, so bugs were all in my face. No towel service either. By the end of the day, we had a great time, my shoes were soaked, and I managed to play like a decent golfer with a 1, 5, 5 hybrid, 7, two 9s, a sand wedge and a putter. Lol. Not a full set, but manageable. Bathroom had no light, had to pee with the door open just to be able to see. The course moved fast. We were done in less than four hours. Only two major water hazards. Lost a few cheap balls, nothing major. Overall, a great time. Bring your own gear, a flashlight and eye protection and you'll do fine. The offering is minimal but keeps cost down. Could use a real restaurant and a snack and drink cart on the course. However, they do a great job maintaining the course, so I would recommend a visit.

Photos
Old Hickory Golf Course
Old Hickory Golf Course - Course layout

Course layout

Old Hickory Golf Course - A little bit of water hazard under those cattails

See all

A little bit of water hazard under those cattails

Reservoir Creek Golf Course - golf - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...