Friendly, professional and informative. I'd never had such a wonderful vacation experience until I…read morebooked through Coco Plum last year. Kelly Logan was really amazing helping my friends and I secure a great vacation. I'm planning my honeymoon and am very tempted to make a trip to the keys again to make sure that one of the most important times of my life is as memorable as last year's. Do yourself a favor and hit up Kelly at Coco Plum. She's gonna make sure you and your crew have an awesome time, and you won't lose your wallet in the process :P

We rented 11260 6th Avenue Golf from Coco Plum for two weeks for $9,000.00. We reported the…read morefollowing issues to Coco Plum shortly after arrival. We were told that both managers are on vacation and they don't know when they will return. Really!!!??? * Hole in garage ceiling under bedroom and bathroom. My daughter was sleeping in the room over the hole and was bit on her face. * Pool is filthy on the outside and inside has chipped paint. * Floor so dirty when my infant daughter crawled for five minutes her skin was black. * Outside Grill is unusable and filthy. * Exterior of building has a sheet of drywall that is sitting in front of the closet doors. Drywall is completely bowed and been here for months. * Plumbing issues. (FIXED BY CO * There is plywood on ceiling in enclosed porch. Black mold is growing out of the hole. Handyman mentioned he put plywood there as temporary fix 8 months ago. * Walls, woodwork and closets filthy. * Couch is ripped and broken the middle is gone and you sit at a 45° angle. * Close to half of the houses lightbulbs are burt out. * Exterior has trash, building debris, pool toys and chairs literally tossed everywhere. Coco Plum should have visited this unit prior to having guests stay here and there be ashamed to rent this property. Coco Plum did resolve our plumbing issue and attempted another cleaning. This home is disgustingly dirty and in drastic need to be gutted and updated complete with all new furnishings. That won't help the smell of the seagrass. Not much you can do about that however I was aware of the possible smell. This has been an incredibly disappointing vacation experience.

We started looking at some homes in the Fort Myers area but after visiting the Keys decided to look…read morehere instead. Our agent from Fort Myers referred Lara to us. As a broker from another state I'm always a bit skeptical, especially when it comes to agents. Lara went above and beyond and continues to do so. My wife relies on Lara for local information and Lara is always there to help out. Lara continues to be such a great help as we aclimate to our part time keys lifestyle. Lara was instrumental in getting the deal done and staying on top of the transaction as we were across the country for most of the deal. Lara was fantastic in keeping the line of communication open and quick to respond whether it be phone, text, or email. I known a lot of agents having been in the business for over 30 years and Lara is definitely at the top. We both appreciate Lara and would not hesitate to use her service or recommend her to anyone looking for a great agent to represent them.

Samuel Williams doesn't give a darn about his customers. We are "cash buyers", had an associate…read morevisit and video home in Marathon Fl yesterday and now cannot not even get a phone call back after promising to call us just as soon as he got to the office today. Time now is 11:47 am. My wife and I were very excited about this purchase for 1.6 million cash. Samuel can now go pound sand as I called and HE IS IN THE OFFICE!! Do not use this firm!!!!

After receiving the full refund I would give them 5 stars. Everything else about the interaction…read morewas great.

I stayed in one of their rentals for a week in June of 2026. The rental was "My Beach Key" located…read morein Key Colony Beach. The property is a duplex with a shared backyard. The neighbor residing in the duplex next door (full time resident) was a problem since day 2 of our trip. Scott (the neighbor) complained that our dog was barking all day when we arrived back at the rental around 6pm. He said he couldnt hear his TV. My husband apologized and explained the dog needs to be crated while we're out and he gets anxious being in a strange place. My teenage daughter who was home all day confirmed the dog was not barking all day. I reached out to Coco Plum immediately and told them I didn't feel it was appropriate that the neighbor confronted us and they confirmed we had done absolutely nothing wrong. I asked them to reach out to the neighbor or owner and explain that we are following all the rules and the dog is approved. They declined to get involved but told me to tell him to reach out to them if he had a problem. My husband also witnessed Scott using drugs in the backyard. A couple days later Scott contacted the owner to make a complaint about our dog barking and confronted me and my daughter in the shared backyard. He came outside to confront us and was slurring his speech. I asked him if he was on drugs and he told me he was on prescriptions. My husband had to come out to get him to go back inside. When Scott made the complaint we had only been away from the rental for about 45 minutes having dinner. The next morning I contacted Coco Plum and let them know what happened. My husband had also spoken with them by phone the evening before about the complaint made to the owner. They offered me a very small partial refund but only if I signed a non disparagement agreement (gag clause) which is illegal and not enforceable in the state of FL. I didn't sign and declined the refund. I would steer clear of this company and particularly the above mentioned rental due to the full time neighbor. They don't care about customer service or your trip, they only care about covering up bad experiences and reviews.

We were just down in Marathon for a vacation with extended family and had the pleasure of doing a…read morephoto shoot with Natalie. She was fantastic from start to finish - a pleasure to work with and the photos were fabulous! Can't say enough wonderful things about her - don't hesitate to book with her!

Natalie was so easy to work with. We had constant communication before our family pictures. We…read moreended up taking pictures at Fort Zachery and they turned out fantastic. She took her time with us, made sure all of those little details made us look good (fixing our hair, adjusting our shirts, etc). This was by far the best family photos that we've ever had.

Our family (30 of us!) have been coming here for over a decade & have loved every minute of it! The…read moregrounds are beautiful & well-kept. The condos have great views & are very comfortable. Some of them are definitely more "retro" than others so be sure you look at photos of the individual units before you book if you care about such things. They're all owned by different individuals who allow us, as guests, to rent out their vacation homes so don't expect them to all look alike. ;) The pool is great, too! Key Colony Point is a great Florida Keys retreat; away from the Key West craziness (although that is fun, too).

My wife and I spent a week at KCP with our friends. This place is fabulous! Very spacious, well…read moredecorated, incredible views, and a very helpful staff. Highly recommended stay if you are in the Keys.

Great people and on top of everything and they work very well with people in community to keep…read morethere rentals running well and get it taken care of immediately should an issue arise very proactive definitely recommend them awesome people.

They, as in Carly and David are out for the easy money. If they have to put out any effort, you…read morewill not be getting a phone call back. If you have been pre qualified but are not an easy qualify for the amount of the house they are showing and have to put out some effort to get qualified for a higher amount, they can't be inconvenienced. You have to work around their schedule and they are so inflexible that they are in the wrong business! If you're interested in one of their listings, get your own realtor!

I have been in real estate since 1991 but decided to contact Amy as I live in Wisconsin and am…read moreseeking a property in the Florida Keys. I have very high standards for this profession as real estate is a big investment. Amy has performed above my expectations. Always returning calls, staying in touch with detailed emails. The market research she has done is exceptional. The most critical factor that she does exceedingly well is "listen". I can't tell you how many times a realtor / broker will tell me what they think I want to hear instead of just listening and understanding what I want. This has been a excellent experience and I highly recommend Amy Puto for a buyer or seller Broker / Relator.

From the owner: I specialize in residential real estate in the Upper and Middle Florida Keys, from Key Largo to…read moreMarathon. I also am experienced with vacant land and boat slips and boat racks. In the Middle Keys, Indigo Reef and Tranquility Bay are two of my specialties, having sold over 20 homes at each resort. Contact me and let's talk! And ask me to subscribe you to my Upper and Middle Keys Weekly Market Report to receive all the new listings, price changes, sales and more in your Inbox every Friday!